p.23 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
Here is an interactive chart for comps of this concept.
Cool! In a geeky sort of way.
A quick comparison of the 6D, D750, A7R is provided for reference.
My .02 so far is that this ISOless ISO is suggesting that in some camera's raising the ISO has little value regarding your shadow dynamic range beyond pulling it up in post, whereas other cameras continue to benefit from raising ISO. It would appear that this is an inherent design approach variation.
Yep. The advantage for ISO-less being that at low ISO you get the full DR. That is, you don't need to shoot at higher ISO to lift the shadows.
My read on the chart is that it is of little value to raise the ISO in the D750, you can just pull it up in post.
Conversely, there is value in continuing to use higher ISO's in the 6D ... you won't need to pull your shadows up in post.
Yep, Pull'em up in camera instead, if you're using the 6D. You're losing headroom in the highlights, of course, but hey, that's what happens at higher ISOs.
Looks like two different approaches by design that can get you to essentially the same place in the end, just via different mechanisms of approach ... one @ ISO, one @ PP(regardless of tool of choice).
Yep, if that same place in the end is DR at ISO > 800. Nope, if you're talking DR at ISO < 800. But we already knew that.
p.23 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
But not everyone wants (or can afford $$$ / space / etc.) to have specialty cameras for each genre of shooting they enjoy. Then you start getting into the mixed platform controls issue. I even have some trouble switching between Canon cameras. I HATE having to rethink @ which camera is it that I'm using and where are the different button / control layouts ... not to mention different menus, do I have good AF or slow AF, etc.
This was one of my main concerns before buying into a different camera brand (Sony), too after using only Canon for many years. And I admit it took me two weeks to get well familiar with my A7R which was also caused by a very crappy manual which came with the camera. But since I like and enjoy technology, the addition overall came easy to me. Both camera systems have their pros and cons menu-wise - the Sony is in general more customizable, Canon has the better menu layout.
Since I rarely need fast AF or long lenses, the A7R moved me more towards smaller and compact rangefinder lenses, too. I am using the A7R currently 50/50 with EF and MF (SLR and rangefinder) lenses. My regular 5D MkII remains my backup camera and for situations where the A7R proved too cumbersome to use, for example for flash photography, situations where I really need better AF (airshows), or when I want to overlay color with IR photos from my second converted 5D MkII body (using the same camera body here is very advantageous). I am used now handling both Sony and Canon cameras in the same proficiency, but - and this is just my personal opinion - changing exposure, aperture, ISO is more convenient to do on my A7R.
There's no perfect camera (nor perfect camera system), so you choose your course, then choose your horse ... the one that you think will take you the farthest in the direction you want to go ... giving you the least grief along the way. For many Canon shooters, the DR issue doesn't present them any real grief. If it did, they wouldn't be shooting Canon. My SLR/C doesn't cause me any real grief ... if it did, I wouldn't shoot it.
The ones who needed better resolution and/or DR have already switched to or added another camera system.
If having mixed platforms doesn't cause you any grief, then that's cool, go for it. For some folks, things like lugging large Supertele's causes them grief ($$$ / size / weight), so they don't lug around Supertele's. For others, shooting m4/3 causes them grief because the format is too small for their hands. Generally speaking, we tend to stay away from that which causes us grief ... all systems have things to them that are grievous for some folks @ no such thing as a perfect system, nor perfect camera. Just because the SoNikon has more DR ... that doesn't make it less grievous. Neither does having higher ISO performance, nor faster AF, nor better IS, nor smaller / lighter system, etc....Show more →
There are more reasons than just DR to switch or add an A7 series camera - reduced size and weight, sensor performance, and adaptability of all kind of lens systems are the advantages for me. You are right, cameras now seem to specialize more as shown with the A7/A7R/A7S series and in a similar way now with the 5D MkIII, 6D, and 5Ds(R).I personally couldn't care less for high ISO and fast fps performance since I never needed it, neither for video performance. Excellent AF is nice to have - but honestly, I would rarely make good use of a sytem as it is build in the 5D MkIII for example (my tilt/shift lenses are still MF ). An event shooter or photo journalist likely prefers just the opposite camera to me. Good thing is that there are camera choices now!
p.23 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
This sounds more like an ad for the Sony A7R, than a discussion about Canon's DR in the Canon Forum.
It is great that some folks have found it to be a viable camera, system or augmentation to Canon. IIRC, Fred himself is (or at least was at one time) well known to be a fan of the A7R with Canon glass for landscape ... but I don't see him here jacking up the A7R ad nauseum and running down Canon or making insinuations about the poor decision making of those who have not adopted the DR options elsewhere, compared to Canon's current DR.
Vastly, there are many aspects to photography that are a series of choices that include trade-off's and / or compromises. The complexity of those personal decisions is not something that should need to be defended or justified ad nauseum. It isn't like people don't know (or can't easily figure out) that a Ferrari goes faster or handles better than a Ford Truck. Some folks are very satisfied with using a Ford Truck ... even for racing. Keep pitching to them how screwed up they are for racing with a truck and sooner or later, they're gonna take their truck and and drive it over your dang Ferrari. It just isn't something they want to discuss ad nauseum.
It isn't that they don't know about it ... in fact they are very intelligent, well respected fellow FM members, who are very well aware of it ... and have consciously and deliberately decided it isn't for them (for whatever reasons). The incessant, continued, perpetual sales pitch for the A7R in the Canon Forum simply becomes rude and disrespectful to your fellow FM members at some point ... no matter how politely you and dignified you try to and spin it.
At some point (variable) for folks ... it just gets old.
Folks clamored for a dedicated Sony Forum ... can the sales pitch for the A7R not occur in the Sony Forum instead. Can you PLEASE drop the incessant SoNikon sales pitch in the Canon Forum ... and (attempting) masking it as I'm just sharing my opinion. It is one thing to share that opinion ... folks tend to listen just fine to that. But, that isn't the same thing as the incessant pitch and inferences that are rendered in concert with them.
That said ... Thanks to Retrofocus for at least acknowledging some of the cons that the A7R doesn't bode well for ... but it still is wrapped in a rationale of a pitch for the A7R ... even if it is A7R + Canon. We get it, you like the A7R. I wanted to get an A7R ... until I picked one up, Now I don't want one. Until you change the ergonomics of the A7R, I'm not going to want one. Maybe if I have an accident and lose some fingers on my right hand, that'll change ... but until then, the A7R is NOT for me ... please quit interloping into discussions, with the incessant A7R sales pitch.
And, if you don't know what the term "interloping" means ... Webster is available.
p.23 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
This sounds more like an ad for the Sony A7R, than a discussion about Canon's DR in the Canon Forum.
It is great that some folks have found it to be a viable camera, system or augmentation to Canon. IIRC, Fred himself is (or at least was at one time) well known to be a fan of the A7R with Canon glass for landscape ... but I don't see him here jacking up the A7R ad nauseum and running down Canon or making insinuations about the poor decision making of those who have not adopted the DR options elsewhere, compared to Canon's current DR.
Vastly, there are many aspects to photography that are a series of choices that include trade-off's and / or compromises. The complexity of those personal decisions is not something that should need to be defended or justified ad nauseum. It isn't like people don't know (or can't easily figure out) that a Ferrari goes faster or handles better than a Ford Truck. Some folks are very satisfied with using a Ford Truck ... even for racing. Keep pitching to them how screwed up they are for racing with a truck and sooner or later, they're gonna take their truck and and drive it over your dang Ferrari. It just isn't something they want to discuss.
It isn't that they don't know about it ... in fact they are very well aware of it ... and have decided it isn't for them (for whatever reason). The incessant, continued, perpetual sales pitch for the A7R in the Canon Forum is simply rude and disrespectful ... no matter how politely you and diginified you try to and spin it.
At some point (variable) for folks ... it just gets old.
Folks clamored for a dedicated Sony Forum ... can the sales pitch for the A7R not occur in the Sony Forum instead. ...Show more →
Rusty, for one that is so loud about not wanting to discuss Sony in the Canon forum...you sure like keeping this thread at the top of the Canon forum. I would think you contributed the most to this thread. Why not just let it rest.
Now, are we also just as upset with threads that cover Sigma, Tamron and Tokina lenses in the Canon Forum? I currently see plenty of these. Are they not also "polluting the purity" of the forum?
p.23 #6Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I am interested in the discussion about Canon and DR ... I just get tired of the pitch about the A7R.
As to the faulty logic attempt by your lens reference ... if we are discussing the merits of the new 100-400 II ... then bringing an incessant pitch about the Tamron being the best thing since sliced bread is BAD FORM as well. The key words here are "incessant" and "pitch".
p.23 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
The ones who needed better resolution and/or DR have already switched to or added another camera system.
BINGO !!!
So the need to incessantly pitch for it ... has largely expired. Particularly among seasoned, experienced photographers who are already fully aware of it as an option available to them. It's not like it is something that just came out last week and it is an epiphanal revelation that needs to be shouted from the highest mountain, so that all can now be aware of it.
I would imagine that folks considering the 5Ds / 5DsR and wondering about any DR improvements from Canon are already fully aware of the A7R's existence. I get that the A7R has many attributes that folks like (including the popularity with Alt's) ... but it isn't like the folks over here in the Canon Forum NEED an education and sales pitch for the A7R or other SoNikon every other thread. A little common sense, respect and credence to the intelligence of your fellow FM'ers and Canon shooters would go a long way here.
BTW .. I apparently misspoke earlier ... rant wasn't over.
And just to be clear ... this isn't "targeted" @ anyone individual, just an overall pleading to "give it a rest" already. Save it for the A9R (or whatever next marvel awaits).
p.23 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
I am interested in the discussion about Canon and DR ... I just get tired of the pitch about the A7R.
As to the faulty logic attempt by your lens reference ... if we are discussing the merits of the new 100-400 II ... then bringing an incessant pitch about the Tamron being the best thing since sliced bread is BAD FORM as well. The key words here are "incessant" and "pitch".
Rusty, did you really think a discussion of the DR of the new Canon cameras would not heavily include the Sony cameras? Really?
I don't see any selling here. I see a lot of rebuttle to ant-Sony responses dealing with dynamic range. For example I seeba lot the posts talking about why they don't need more dynamic range because they bracket I've replied discussing cases where it is hard to bracket and the extra time in post processing might not be everyone's cup of tea...so a camera with more DR to begin with is a very good option when dealing with high DR scenes.
You call this "selling" or trying to convince people to jump ship. I call this just plain good information. You claim everyone already knows about the Sony cameras...I claim there are many silent readers that do not know and this information is very helpful.
I can see your point if there is a bunch of discussion of Sony in a birds in flight thread...but a dynamic range thread...you really serious saying there is too much Sony discussion?
p.23 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote: retrofocus wroteThe ones who needed better resolution and/or DR have already switched to or added another camera system.
BINGO !!!
So the need to incessantly pitch for it ... has largely expired. Particularly among seasoned, experienced photographers who are already fully aware of it as an option available to them. It's not like it is something that just came out last week and it is an epiphanal revelation that needs to be shouted from the highest mountain, so that all can now be aware of it.
I would imagine that folks considering the 5Ds / 5DsR and wondering about any DR improvements from Canon are already fully aware of the A7R's existence. I get that the A7R has many attributes that folks like (including the popularity with Alt's) ... but it isn't like the folks over here in the Canon Forum NEED an education and sales pitch for the A7R or other SoNikon every other thread.
BTW .. I apparently misspoke earlier ... rant wasn't over.
Rusty, you are making the assumption that no new photographers are entering FM on a daily basis or are getting interested into landscape photography. FM is a very large world wide community that has the vast majority of members being quiet members sitting in the background gathering information. The very small group of active forum participants might know all about the different cameras options out there, but i don't think you can speak for those you don't even know exist.
To me these new high mpix Canon cameras target landscape photography where DR is a very important topic. Talking about options out there for landscape photography is good in my opinion and trying to squash it is something totally wrong.
p.23 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
This sounds more like an ad for the Sony A7R, than a discussion about Canon's DR in the Canon Forum.
It is great that some folks have found it to be a viable camera, system or augmentation to Canon. IIRC, Fred himself is (or at least was at one time) well known to be a fan of the A7R with Canon glass for landscape ... but I don't see him here jacking up the A7R ad nauseum and running down Canon or making insinuations about the poor decision making of those who have not adopted the DR options elsewhere, compared to Canon's current DR.
Vastly, there are many aspects to photography that are a series of choices that include trade-off's and / or compromises. The complexity of those personal decisions is not something that should need to be defended or justified ad nauseum. It isn't like people don't know (or can't easily figure out) that a Ferrari goes faster or handles better than a Ford Truck. Some folks are very satisfied with using a Ford Truck ... even for racing. Keep pitching to them how screwed up they are for racing with a truck and sooner or later, they're gonna take their truck and and drive it over your dang Ferrari. It just isn't something they want to discuss ad nauseum.
It isn't that they don't know about it ... in fact they are very intelligent, well respected fellow FM members, who are very well aware of it ... and have consciously and deliberately decided it isn't for them (for whatever reasons). The incessant, continued, perpetual sales pitch for the A7R in the Canon Forum simply becomes rude and disrespectful to your fellow FM members at some point ... no matter how politely you and dignified you try to and spin it.
At some point (variable) for folks ... it just gets old.
Folks clamored for a dedicated Sony Forum ... can the sales pitch for the A7R not occur in the Sony Forum instead. Can you PLEASE drop the incessant SoNikon sales pitch in the Canon Forum ... and (attempting) masking it as I'm just sharing my opinion. It is one thing to share that opinion ... folks tend to listen just fine to that. But, that isn't the same thing as the incessant pitch and inferences that are rendered in concert with them.
That said ... Thanks to Retrofocus for at least acknowledging some of the cons that the A7R doesn't bode well for ... but it still is wrapped in a rationale of a pitch for the A7R ... even if it is A7R + Canon. We get it, you like the A7R. I wanted to get an A7R ... until I picked one up, Now I don't want one. Until you change the ergonomics of the A7R, I'm not going to want one. Maybe if I have an accident and lose some fingers on my right hand, that'll change ... but until then, the A7R is NOT for me ... please quit interloping into discussions, with the incessant A7R sales pitch.
And, if you don't know what the term "interloping" means ... Webster is available.
I believe you got the wrong impression from my post - in no way I intended to convince you to get a Sony camera or whatsoever - I simply commented on your earlier post agreeing with it by mentioning some examples from my personal experience. Not sure why you react so aggressively on it since I did in no way argue that my decision is better than your or whatsoever....as I tried to make clear several times before, it simply depends on own preference and shooting style. What is important camera-wise for you might be less important for me and vice-versa - that's okay! I have no interest in supporting any kind of brand, neither do I represent or work for a brand here - if brand X shows some benefit for me with another camera, then I will write about it and why when comparing technological debits and benefits. And I will do so in all the forums which are associated with this technology - in our case it is Sony and Canon currently.
But be ensured you will hear a lot more about A7R (or D800E) / A9 sensor technology and cameras here when the new cameras will be finally released and compared with each other. And why not? Or do you only wish to hear what a single brand (Canon here) presents and offers?
p.23 #11Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Chez,
The info @ Sony that how they approach DR technoligically is patented and different from Canon ... that was REALLY good information pertinent to why Canon's advancement in DR isn't on pace with Sony. That gave insight into why Canon's developments are behind the curve compared to Sony leading the way. The incessant "I love my Sony, and you should too." gets old. Pretty simple.
Some of mttrans charts (although, we still could use some clarification) could be contributory as well. I found them to be of interest. The "love fest" for the A7R should be in the Sony Forum, not the Canon forum. I think that's all that many folks are saying.
You claim it is for the benefit of the silent readers ... then maybe we should all go over to the Sony Forum and have a "love fest" about Canon AF systems, just because Sony uses AF for the benefit for the silent readers there as well. After all, using Canon glass on Sony A7R isn't as fast response the best that it could be if you would just use Canon glass on Canon cameras. We should all be over in the Sony Forum explaining that to all the uneducated silent readers in the Sony Forum.
p.23 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote:
I believe you got the wrong impression from my post - in no way I intended to convince you to get a Sony camera or whatsoever - I simply commented on your earlier post agreeing with it by mentioning some examples from my personal experience. Not sure why you react so aggressively on it since I did in no way argue that my decision is better than your or whatsoever....as I tried to make clear several times before, it simply depends on own preference and shooting style.
I didn't take it that way, per se. We're good. Sorry if I came across as if it were in direct response to your post. I was truly appreciative of some of your comments.
Cyber-language is challenging at times. Timing and nuance can be a challenge, ripe for misunderstanding. Please accept any apologies due from one FM'er to another FM'er.
p.23 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
Until you change the ergonomics of the A7R, I'm not going to want one. Maybe if I have an accident and lose some fingers on my right hand, that'll change ... but until then, the A7R is NOT for me ...
I severely hope that you won't suffer any kind of accident in the future and remain healthy and good for a long time of shooting to come with whatever gear you prefer! Just a minor correction here....in case you had less fingers on your hand, it would be very hard to use the A7 camera series even with its lower weight. I use the thumb to hold the back and change ISO quickly on the wheel on its back side, the forefinger is good for changing exposure and/or aperture settings on the top wheels and press the shutter release, the remaining three fingers hold the camera on the grip steadily.
p.23 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote: retrofocus wroteI believe you got the wrong impression from my post - in no way I intended to convince you to get a Sony camera or whatsoever - I simply commented on your earlier post agreeing with it by mentioning some examples from my personal experience. Not sure why you react so aggressively on it since I did in no way argue that my decision is better than your or whatsoever....as I tried to make clear several times before, it simply depends on own preference and shooting style.I didn't take it that way, per se. We're good. Sorry if I came across as if it were in direct response to your post. I was truly appreciative of some of your comments.
Cyber-language is challenging at times. Timing and nuance can be a challenge, ripe for misunderstanding. Please accept any apologies due from one FM'er to another FM'er.
No biggie, we are fine. I got your points well before on earlier pages in this thread.
p.23 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
Chez,
The info @ Sony that how they approach DR technoligically is patented and different from Canon ... that was REALLY good information pertinent to why Canon's advancement in DR isn't on pace with Sony. That gave insight into why Canon's developments are behind the curve compared to Sony leading the way. The incessant "I love my Sony, and you should too." gets old. Pretty simple.
Some of mttrans charts (although, we still could use some clarification) could be contributory as well. I found them to be of interest. The "love fest" for the A7R should be in the Sony Forum, not the Canon forum. I think that's all that many folks are saying.
You claim it is for the benefit of the silent readers ... then maybe we should all go over to the Sony Forum and have a "love fest" about Canon AF systems, just because Sony uses AF for the benefit for the silent readers there as well.
Rusty, what is faulty is your perception about people trying to sell you on Sony. Thst is just your issue as I don't see anyone selling anything here. I see people talking about different aspects of DR including how we can manage it using GND filters or multiple exposures ad well as augmenting their system with a camera that is more capable in this area. I see zero selling as you call it.
Discussions wander and a lot of that wandering is caused by posts such as..."yeh, I don't need more DR and the Sony shutter is too loud". In reality, most these types of threads wander due to people having a problem discussing like adults aspects of different systems. Somehow, there appears to be a threat to some here if you mention anything other than Canon. I think that says a lot about some people.
p.23 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Paul Mo wrote: anscochrome wroteI wish Canon would have taken the 5DS/5DS-r concept a step further. I would like to have a 5DS-r monochrome, and get serious about black and white photography again. I am envious of the results skilled shooters get with the M9 monochrome.Surely that is a psychological impediment - that my camera is black and white therefore authentic - it is all I can shoot with it.
Is there mental baggage surrounding converting to black and white in post in some M9 users? Definitely. Somehow 'in camera' is seen as the purer practice.
That being said, at times I enjoy restrictive means to certain ends too.
I spent quite a few years as a custom black and white printer for fine art photographers who did not wish to to do it themselves. I became pretty good at translating their vision to a final print. I have always approached post shooting processing as if I was making a print. B&W conversions always leave me unsatisfied, like something is missing. I cannot really express it in words to a satisfying degree. And yes, I would gladly carry a dark orange, dark red, and dark green filter with me when using a dedicated monochrome camera. Would rather start with a base of known lightened and darkened tones, and adjust tonal gradations from there.
p.23 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote: jctriguy wrotechez wroteRustyBug wroteI am interested in the discussion about Canon and DR ... I just get tired of the pitch about the A7R.
As to the faulty logic attempt by your lens reference ... if we are discussing the merits of the new 100-400 II ... then bringing an incessant pitch about the Tamron being the best thing since sliced bread is BAD FORM as well. The key words here are "incessant" and "pitch".Rusty, did you really think a discussion of the DR of the new Canon cameras would not heavily include the Sony cameras? Really?
I don't see any selling here. I see a lot of rebuttle to ant-Sony responses dealing with dynamic range. For example I seeba lot the posts talking about why they don't need more dynamic range because they bracket I've replied discussing cases where it is hard to bracket and the extra time in post processing might not be everyone's cup of tea...so a camera with more DR to begin with is a very good option when dealing with high DR scenes.
You call this "selling" or trying to convince people to jump ship. I call this just plain good information. You claim everyone already knows about the Sony cameras...I claim there are many silent readers that do not know and this information is very helpful.
I can see your point if there is a bunch of discussion of Sony in a birds in flight thread...but a dynamic range thread...you really serious saying there is too much Sony discussion?You, retro and several others are delusional. This is a constant sales pitch and people are tired of it. It isn't adding anything to the discussion here. Stop trying to paint your contributions as simple information sharing that you do a pathetic job of justifying.JC, show me one thread in which you added any value to. Just one. All I see is your constant attacks which really start to get a little boring. Can you actually talk about photography?
Apparently you can't resist my posts, take your own advice. You should be much wiser given your significantly advanced age, guess the old adage isn't always true.
What did you offer here by saying an a7r could've taken a photo of a seagull at 560mm, just a blatant sales pitch for your god exmor. What a pointless contribution that was.