p.15 #1Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I like my a7R's DR; it can be an incredibly useful capability in scenarios where AEB or GNDs are not a viable solution. I also love that it is lighter (nicer for hikes) and has tilting screen that makes it much easier to put the camera way down low or up high. Finally, my a7R is the ideal FF camera for shooting manual focus lenses (handheld); lenses like my TS-Es or Zeiss lenses become fantastically easy to use for handheld shooting.
On the other hand, the 5DS R has stronger capabilities of its own that the a7R does not possess: Like a seriously well-implemented AEB system, or a vast range of native lenses (e.g. I have no plans to shoot wildlife with a 100-400 on my a7R!), or internal bulb timer, customizable menus and shooting modes, etc.
Really I don't see the need to complain about the 5DS' DR shortcomings. When I need 14-stops DR I already have that problem solved: the a7R is available and ready at hand. But if I want to photograph some wildlife with a long lens, or want to get the absolute optimal performance from my most-excellent Canon-mount lenses, or want to capture a 7-bracket shot spaced at .7 EVs, then the 5DS R will be a preferable solution for those uses.
After spending a year with my a7R I discovered - to my surprise - that I used both a7R and 5D III about equally. That has really helped cement my feelings that having both is preferable to having just one, for my needs.
p.15 #2Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote: ben egbert wroteYes, this is fine, but I am speaking of a sun still high enough to be white, usually behind clouds. This is when you get the ring around the clouds effect. I have a single shot of Mesa arch complete with a sunburst that I was able to do in one image not unlike this one. But after I learned some HDR I prefer the effect it has on tone mapping the mid range.I agree - there are still situations as I also mentioned earlier where the contrast is too big to avoid bracketing or HDR. Just wanted to demonstrate above that more DR makes it simply easier to get the shot right out of the box (with little processing). More DR is something which doesn't negatively affect you if you don't need it, but can make a big difference in some situations as above when you make use of it.
You are exactly right retro. More is always better than less...and I too have been getting good results from single exposure shots where previously I used GND filters on the same type of shots. I'm in New Mexico right now under blazing conditions so we'll see how well single exposure with the A7R turn out. From what I've experienced, I think the images will be great.
p.15 #3Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
retrofocus wrote: Scott Stoness wroteretrofocus wroteben egbert wroteBut I doubt one image will meet my needs even with the better DR, so I would probably continue the habit formed back in my film days of using a 3 shot bracket. And a 3 image blend takes about 10 minutes for the blend part. Being retired, I actually need more stuff to do.I can ensure you that you won't if you have the option - this was a big eye-opener for me when I got my A7R that I simply didn't need to bracket landscape shots anymore. In fact the result from a single photo and some simple post processing is better than the bracketed final composition. I am only using bracketing with this sensor for indoor architectural shots with very bright and dark areas in it.
Avoiding bracketing for landscape shots is a big plus - no issues with moving branches or grass in the wind between bracketed shots. The DR of the A7R sensor simply allows to cope with a single shot. It is impossible to do the same with my 5D MkII (and I tried!).Retrofocus and I have different conclusions from the same data.
I bought the a7r when it first came out and continue to use it pending the 5dsr becuase of the 36mpx. I still prefer AEB (better colors in dark areas, 14 stops does not mean good quality in the last 2 stops, and its only 14 stops) and blending or hdr/blending with the a7r. The dynamic range is still not enough to achieve pictures that look like what you see, and require AEB to fix. The big advantage of a7r is mpx, not dynamic range.
Clearly when it comes to images that only work with 1 shot (waves, moving objects) the A7r has an advantage in dynamic range however, the ergonomics of the camera are not as nice, it does not function well in the cold, the evf is too dim in bright light, the ergonomics of the menu suck, the need to use a adapter sucks, the battery life is awful, the shutter chugs along like a freight train, and the dust control is not as good as the canon. In short its a better sensor but everything else is weaker.
I can't wait to ditch the a7r to avoid the multiple systems.We discussed this earlier, so I am not going again in discussing with you your complaints about the performance of this camera (and this is not what this discuiussion is about). It is a difference what you personally prefer and what the camera potentially can do - the 14 stops make a big difference as many Sony and Nikon shooters can confirm.
I agree the 2nd comment I made was off topic and I do agree that Sony shooters (of which I am one) do enjoy greater dynamic range, where I differ is that in my opinion the look you achieve with pushing shadows with the sony sensor is not as good as doing blending after AEB. I think the pushed shadows of sony look like bad versions of use of hdr, compared to good use of AEB/blending/hdr. If you look up in your posted picture the grass is an unatural color.
p.15 #4Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Light might be fleeting ... but it doesn't fleet faster than the fraction of a second it takes for the bracketed shot (particular since the shadows aren't the "fleeting" part).
I get that in certain instances, bracketing is less than ideal ... but I am inclined to think that folks are really not giving credence to the fact that a bracketed shot occurs in less than a blink of an eye.
I mean, if you are shooting an open sky daylight, you are at EV15, and your shadows are about 3 stops below that @ EV12. Even if you are shooting sunset around EV 12-13, your shadows are now around EV9. At ISO 100, your EV 9 is going to be around 1/100 @ f/2 ... or 1/25 @ f/4, etc ... still faster than you can blink.
Light is fleeting, sure I get that ... but really, that's the rationale for not bracketing. It's not like you're releasing the clutch on the film winder, and recocking the shutter, while flipping over your gradient or half filter. Neither are you switching out film sheets @ 4x5 or 8x10 (which might take a bit longer). You're simply pressing the button once and the camera takes the consecutive bracketed images faster than you can say "Jack Robinson".
Shooting @ f16 you say ... okay, so it takes "One Mississi ... " Which, btw, if you are of the argument that motion is an issue between bracketed shots, you aren't shooting longer exposures @ low ISO anyway. Again, more DR is better, but I still don't believe that pulling up 5+ EV shadows is the optimal way to contend with extreme DR. An adequate way, a convenient way ... sure, but I still think you can do better with two well executed exposures, a little forethought and a little more post-effort.
I mean, you drove three hours to get there, hiked for another 2 hours there and back, waited 45 minutes for the perfect moment of that "fleeting light" ... and you can't spend the time for a bracketed shot that takes a fraction of a second or an extra five minutes in post. Yup, that would be too inconvenient.
p.15 #5Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
Light might be fleeting ... but it doesn't fleet faster than the fraction of a second it takes for the bracketed shot.
I get that in certain instances, bracketing is less than ideal ... but I am inclined to think that folks are really not giving credence to the fact that a bracketed shot occurs in less than a blink of an eye.
I mean, if you are shooting an open sky daylight, you are at EV15, and your shadows are about 3 stops below that @ EV12. Even if you are shooting sunset around EV 12-13, your shadows are now around EV9. At ISO 100, your EV 9 is going to be around 1/100 @ f/2 ... or 1/25 @ f/4, etc ... still faster than you can blink.
Light is fleeting, sure I get that ... but really, that's the rationale for not bracketing. It's not like you're releasing the clutch on the film winder, and recocking the shutter, while flipping over your gradient or half filter. You're simply pressing the button once and the camera takes the consecutive bracketed images faster than you can say "Jack Robinson".
Shooting @ f16 you say ... okay, so it takes "One Mississi ... " Which, btw ... if you are of the argument that motion is an issue between bracketed shots, you aren't shooting longer exposures @ low ISO anyway. Again, more DR is better, but I still don't believe that pulling up 5+ EV shadows is the optimal way to contend with extreme DR. An adequate way, a convenient way ... sure, but I still think you can do better with two well executed exposures.
That's fine if your subject matter is not moving, but in the real world lots moves in 1 Mississippi. Just the other day I was shooting in a 40 mph wind during dusk. I had to have a small aperture for the image I wanted...needed a fast shutter to deal with the wind and did not want to go above 3200 ISO...which in my opinion is really pushing things. My solution knowing how malleable the A7R images are, I under exposed the shot by three stops allowing me to shoot at ISO 1600 and still have 2 stops extra of shutter speed. I haven't processed the images yet as I'm still on the road...but added flexibility in the images sure allows for more creative solutions under challenging conditions.
I shoot water falls a lot and the challenge there is usually the surrounding area is in shadows with some bright light coming through, the water at times is quite bright and there is always moving vegetation caused by the spray from the falls. To bracket here would result in blurry images due to movement. Having an image which you expose for the brighter areas and then pull the darker areas in post is a much more achievable solution.
I've used GND filters for many years, merging bracketed exposures since digital and there are just too many situations where both those techniques fall short. Sure there will be scenes which contain DR too great for even a single A7R image, but those numbers have substantially dropped since I started using the A7R.
p.15 #7Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote: RustyBug wroteLight might be fleeting ... but it doesn't fleet faster than the fraction of a second it takes for the bracketed shot.
I get that in certain instances, bracketing is less than ideal ... but I am inclined to think that folks are really not giving credence to the fact that a bracketed shot occurs in less than a blink of an eye.
I mean, if you are shooting an open sky daylight, you are at EV15, and your shadows are about 3 stops below that @ EV12. Even if you are shooting sunset around EV 12-13, your shadows are now around EV9. At ISO 100, your EV 9 is going to be around 1/100 @ f/2 ... or 1/25 @ f/4, etc ... still faster than you can blink.
Light is fleeting, sure I get that ... but really, that's the rationale for not bracketing. It's not like you're releasing the clutch on the film winder, and recocking the shutter, while flipping over your gradient or half filter. You're simply pressing the button once and the camera takes the consecutive bracketed images faster than you can say "Jack Robinson".
Shooting @ f16 you say ... okay, so it takes "One Mississi ... " Which, btw ... if you are of the argument that motion is an issue between bracketed shots, you aren't shooting longer exposures @ low ISO anyway. Again, more DR is better, but I still don't believe that pulling up 5+ EV shadows is the optimal way to contend with extreme DR. An adequate way, a convenient way ... sure, but I still think you can do better with two well executed exposures.That's fine if your subject matter is not moving, but in the real world lots moves in 1 Mississippi. Just the other day I was shooting in a 40 mph wind during dusk. I had to have a small aperture for the image I wanted...needed a fast shutter to deal with the wind and did not want to go above 3200 ISO...which in my opinion is really pushing things. My solution knowing how malleable the A7R images are, I under exposed the shot by three stops allowing me to shoot at ISO 1600 and still have 2 stops extra of shutter speed. I haven't processed the images yet as I'm still on the road...but added flexibility in the images sure allows for more creative solutions under challenging conditions.
I shoot water falls a lot and the challenge there is usually the surrounding area is in shadows with some bright light coming through, the water at times is quite bright and there is always moving vegetation caused by the spray from the falls. To bracket here would result in blurry images due to movement. Having an image which you expose for the brighter areas and then pull the darker areas in post is a much more achievable solution.
I've used GND filters for many years, merging bracketed exposures since digital and there are just too many situations where both those techniques fall short. Sure there will be scenes which contain DR too great for even a single A7R image, but those numbers have substantially dropped since I started using the A7R....Show more →
With NIK HDR pro, I can choose which shot to use for ghosting. That means I can choose one for water and it will only use the other layers for luminance and the detail for the water from the shot chosen. I mostly use another HDR program however and it does not have that option, but does a pretty good job anyway.
p.15 #8Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote:
I get that in certain instances, bracketing is less than ideal ... but I am inclined to think that folks are really not giving credence to the fact that a bracketed shot occurs in less than a blink of an eye.
And I am inclined to think you're not giving credence to the fact that ideal light and narrow apertures (f/11) and low-ISOs do not support blink-of-an-eye shutter speeds.
p.15 #9Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
darbo wrote: RustyBug wroteI get that in certain instances, bracketing is less than ideal ... but I am inclined to think that folks are really not giving credence to the fact that a bracketed shot occurs in less than a blink of an eye.And I am inclined to think you're not giving credence to the fact that ideal light and narrow apertures (f/11) and low-ISOs do not support blink-of-an-eye shutter speeds.
Actually, I already did ... it is the very basis for offsetting the "motion" argument that some make for not taking bracketed shots. If you are taking longer exposures, you are already subject to motion blur in the first shot, the second one is really not any different @ static things remain static, moving things are subject to be different ... whether that is in one image or two.
p.15 #10Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote: chez wroteI under exposed the shot by three stops allowing me to shoot at ISO 1600And how much more DR does the A7R have @ ISO 1600 than the Canon 6D?
Ummm, if DXO measurements are any indication ... that would be .09 EV difference @ 11.21 vs. 11.12
It's a good thing you weren't stuck with Canon's DR ... you'd have never gotten the shot.
(Sorry, couldn't resist.)
Rusty, like I said I haven't processed them...I'll see. I know for certain that if I'd raise the Canon images I would get that ugly Canon banding trademark in the dark areas...not so much with the Sony images. So even if the DR is the same at 1600 ISO...the quality of the images and their ability to be manipulated is still significantly different. Like I said, we'll see.
Bottom line, with the 5d2 that I own, I'd be SOL that evening...with the A7R, I guess the jury is still out until I get back home.
p.15 #12Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
RustyBug wrote: darbo wroteRustyBug wroteI get that in certain instances, bracketing is less than ideal ... but I am inclined to think that folks are really not giving credence to the fact that a bracketed shot occurs in less than a blink of an eye.And I am inclined to think you're not giving credence to the fact that ideal light and narrow apertures (f/11) and low-ISOs do not support blink-of-an-eye shutter speeds. Actually, I already did ... it is the very basis for offsetting the "motion" argument that some make for not taking bracketed shots. If you are taking longer exposures, you are already subject to motion blur in the first shot, the second one is really not any different @ static things remain static, moving things are subject to be different ... whether that is in one image or two.
Gotta run ... got a better offer @ date night.
Depending on what your view of long exposures is. I have many shots where a long exposure goes into the minutes timeframes...bracketing under these situations is just not feasible. Too much in the scene has changed including the light as they are typically taken during dusk when the light is changing quite quickly.
p.15 #13Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I have captured too many bracketed exposures where the exposures are not so long that vegetation is not greatly motion-blurred, yet slow enough that that the vegetation (branches/ leaves) do not occupy exactly the same position from one bracket to another. In those cases, as Ben stated, ghost reduction methods are needed. And that is not ideal either. In those circumstances I would rather circumvent sketchy ghost reduction routines, if possible, by capturing a fully detailed image (fully recoverable highlights and shadows) in one single exposure.
Anyway, I certanly don't desire to argue against bracketing; I rely on it too frequently and enjoy processing the brackets too much to do so. But, I just don't love these arguments that don't appear give due credence to both perspectives.
p.15 #14Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
The bottom line is...wouldn't it be nice not to rely on bracketing, GND filters or other forms of managing large dynamic range scenes and just focus on the composition and light...and then not worry about all the post processing hoops th salvage the shot. The A7R sensor is a step in the right direction...not fully there yet, but a step forward.
p.15 #15Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
I understand that there are situations in which bracketing is not ideal or in which it might be difficult or even approach impossibility. I also understand that it is often preferable to get the shot in a singe frame rather than exposure bracketing.
There are certainly times when exposure bracketing could be problematic due to motion in the subject. However, in many cases the moving subject isn't a problem since the component exposures of the final image can be blended in areas where there isn't motion. (Again, I understand there are exceptions — for example, if the entire frame is filled with a singular high DR subject that is in motion it could be quite tough to do a good blend.)
Example: Imagine a seascape with very bright sky and perhaps reflections on the water, but with a very dark and backlit foreground of perhaps trees and land. At first blush, the motion in the sea and perhaps the clouds would seem to make a bracketing solution problematic. However, the sea and sky portion of the final image would probably come from a single exposure since that portion of the image isn't likely to exceed the camera's DR limits itself, while the shadow portion of the image would come from a separate exposure, with the most likely blend point just inside the darker area. So none of the moving areas are in the blend area, and the motion isn't a problem.
Thinking about my own experience, the vast majority of my photographs (quite a few of which are made in challenging lighting) do not require a blend. I often go ahead and capture bracketed exposures (as do quite a few photographers) since digital "film" is essentially free and it might turn out to be useful to have the extra scene data. But in the end, I probably don't need to exposure bracket more than a few times per year — I can virtually always get what I need for a high quality print from a single exposure using typical techniques in post. (I never use GNDs either — so my most likely situation for a bracket is one where I would otherwise use a GND.)
Does greater DR help? Sure. In the same way that higher ISO, higher sensor resolution, lower noise, better lenses, sturdier tripod, etc are useful, added DR can be useful, too.
Would higher DR solve all of my DR challenges? No. It would reduce the (already small) number of photographs that might require me to use bracketing or other approaches, but there would still be some shots that would include dynamic range greater than what any current camera can handle. So the advantage is real, but it isn't perfect.
Do I feel hampered by the DR of my current cameras? Well, rarely, though there are those few shots where it would be useful — those that fall into that narrow gap between the range of my current camera and the range of the highest DR potential camera currently available.
Would I be happy to have higher DR capability in my cameras? Sure, why not? ;-)
What changes would be worth it to get that increased DR? Some feel that it is so important that switching or adding brands is worth it. That's fine if it seems so to them. The advantage doesn't seem that significant to me in terms of how it would change/improve my photography, so I'm happy to work with what I have and upgrade when the time seems right.
Am I saying that DR is unimportant? No. Am I saying that you shouldn't get a higher DR camera if you feel you need it? No. Am I bad-mouthing Sony or Nikon? Not in the least.
YMMV,
Dan
Just for fun, a three-exposure blend with moving clouds and a bit of wind rippling the water and reflection:
p.15 #16Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
I under exposed the shot by three stops allowing me to shoot at ISO 1600
RustyBug wrote:
And how much more DR does the A7R have @ ISO 1600 than the Canon 6D?
Ummm, if DXO measurements are any indication ... that would be .09 EV difference @ 11.21 vs. 11.12
It's a good thing you weren't stuck with Canon's DR ... you'd have never gotten the shot.
(Sorry, couldn't resist.)
What Is that for sure? I thought the A7r was supposed to have the best IQ. If not, then the other crippling factors in using the camera are very difficult to justify.
p.15 #17Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote: RustyBug wrotechez wroteI under exposed the shot by three stops allowing me to shoot at ISO 1600And how much more DR does the A7R have @ ISO 1600 than the Canon 6D?
Ummm, if DXO measurements are any indication ... that would be .09 EV difference @ 11.21 vs. 11.12
It's a good thing you weren't stuck with Canon's DR ... you'd have never gotten the shot.
(Sorry, couldn't resist.) Rusty, like I said I haven't processed them...I'll see. I know for certain that if I'd raise the Canon images I would get that ugly Canon banding trademark in the dark areas...not so much with the Sony images. So even if the DR is the same at 1600 ISO...the quality of the images and their ability to be manipulated is still significantly different. Like I said, we'll see.
Bottom line, with the 5d2 that I own, I'd be SOL that evening...with the A7R, I guess the jury is still out until I get back home.
With the 5D2, yes you will have some ugly banding. With the 1DX, 6D, 7D2 you will have an equal image with equal DR. With the 5D3 you will have something in between.
p.15 #18Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
Chez, do checkout the 6D, it is most difficult to find 'any' banding and as you move above ISO 100 it stays pretty darn clean. Canon has found something, I'm not sure if it is sensor based or in firmware but it's there. I'm foregoing the 5D3 and all it's goodies because of the 5D3's minimal banding when pushed hard.
I do like the idea of 50MPs as I often crop, my wheels make my up-close-and-personal options sometimes very limited. But there'll be no 5Ds or sr in my kit, a 6D is nearing and later perhaps a 5D4 if one appears. for the moment I'm lightening up my gear, body then lenses; concentrating on the newer f4L IS zooms...
As said before, Sony please we need a touch screen and a slimmer wired remote
Keep shooing Chez, NewMex is most beautiful, hope you get some wonderful images!
p.15 #19Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
chez wrote:
Depending on what your view of long exposures is. I have many shots where a long exposure goes into the minutes timeframes...bracketing under these situations is just not feasible. Too much in the scene has changed including the light as they are typically taken during dusk when the light is changing quite quickly.
Those are easy ... I'm not buying "not feasible" ... you just have to be strategic.
You take your first bracket for the changing light. You take your second one for the remainder (which will be largely unchanged shadows). Or, you reverse it and take your first exposure in advance of your "changing" light and your second one for your changing light.
Your motion variance between shots is already a non-factor because of the extended long exposure.
The crux of the issue is that with extreme DR scenes you have two (or more) different sets of lighting. Doing the analysis of what those different sources are is key to understanding what your strategy is going to be @ how to determine your approach to the separate captures.
One typical extreme DR scene includes taking a portion of the image of a "light source" in addition to light that is reflected off of a subject. That, and / or different portions of the scene illuminated by different light sources ... commonly direct sunlight @ light source or illuminant coupled with the shadow areas that are illuminated by open sky. Those areas illuminated by open sky (i.e. your "fill" @ shadows) remain relatively (or nominally) unchanged from your "fleeting light" even after your fleeting light passes ... i.e. one has rapid change, one has slow change. Plan accordingly.
The notion that your "fleeting light" is very responsible for your low level portions of the scene is likely not as prominent as is often thought. I'm not saying that there is no instance in which a single exposure doesn't have its place ... just that I think folks aren't developing well thought, strategic, bracketing approaches ... and thus are very relieved to have the added DR.
As noted many times, more DR is welcome, but I still find that 5+ EV pull is less than ideal ... even if possible.
chez wrote:
just focus on the composition and light
+1 ... understanding which light is being photographed as a light source, which is being photographed as reflected off an object and which different light sources are serving as your different illuminant(s). We tend to think of light as a "single light", but it really isn't. It is more like studio key, backlight and fill light. The main difference is we don't get a lot of control of the lighting relationships. So, while we get to control the light relationships in studio ... we can alternatively control our exposure relationships when we can't control the light relationships.
I get that we can do that in pp to a degree, but we do have a degree of control over that in capture as well. Just one more tool in the tool box. Your call if you choose to learn it or use it and to what degree you do so.
p.15 #20Canon 5DS dynamic range: zero improvement (RAWs analyzed)
StillFingerz wrote:
RustyBug, bracketing, blending, stitching works for static subjects just fine, but if you introduce movement into your subject, wind, water, whatever, then a single shot is your best if not only option and that's when extra DR; exposure latitude, is a huge benefit.
Bright shy, dark shadows, which do you choose, not having to would be nice, freeing in some respects, like when light is fleeting; at sunrise/sunset
sometimes. I usually wont hesitate to do landscapes with moving scenes and HDR. 1 shot is a ton more convenient for sure, takes less time, and less to process.
that said, I do take a ton of bracket shots with the sony just in case.
another reason my HDR is a PITA is when you're focus stacking...... just a pain in the butt to focus stack AND do HDR.