jonnyt5050 wrote:
Sweet! I've found the 45mm PC-E to be super sharp. (and don't forget it works as a great macro lens too).
My only issue with the PC-E lenses is watching to make sure they don't tilt when I'm setting up. My lens will lock but sometimes that knob will loosen a bit and it will tilt on me on accident.
Enjoy!
Jonny5050,
I just got a 45mm PC-E and am running it thru its paces and learning curve now. I already had the 24 & 85. My 24mm does what you described when the tilt knob is on the left side. There seems to be little damping of the gears and it slips unless I almost tighten it, then it stays in place until I do tighten it. I don't have the problem with the other two lenses and on the 24 it only happens when the tilt knob is on one side. The shift does the same thing on one side only as well. I dialogued with Nikon service about it since it is still in the 5 year warranty window and they wanted me to send it in but if this is a known issue and I don't have to spend postage and insurance money I won't. I think I still have another year left on the 5 years so will watch it for any degradation of the issue.
Thanks for all the great images you post. Some of them contributed to my desire to add the 45mm to my bag.
My 24mm does that too. Oh well, it's like a British car...
According to the lens review sites I've found which actually have tested these lenses, the 45mm PC-E is sharpest, followed by the 85mm PC-E, and then the 24mm PC-E.. Which makes perfect sense to me for no real reason...
ckcarr wrote:
My 24mm does that too. Oh well, it's like a British car...
According to the lens review sites I've found which actually have tested these lenses, the 45mm PC-E is sharpest, followed by the 85mm PC-E, and then the 24mm PC-E.. Which makes perfect sense to me for no real reason...
Well, it appears I am in good company then. Alignment seems to be fine so I guess it is just the quirky personality of this lens.
My 24 will tilt and shift when I wrestle it out of the camera bag, so it's always good to reset it before shooting. One of the lock knobs (the tiny ones) is also uncomfortably close to the prism, so sometimes it's hard to get to it, especially if you have big fingers or gloves.
Nevertheless, the lens renders beautifully ... if you can work around its personality, which is mostly about extreme field curvature.
I've heard that the 85 is the sharpest of the three, but that all 3 are probably the most Zeiss like of the Nikon lens library. The 85 also tends to have a pretty stiff focusing ring, but I've never used it myself.
Yeah, I think the locking knob slipping is just part of the design.
I haven't closely examined the mechanics but just know I need to double check to make sure things aren't shifted/tilted if I didn't want it to be.
Glad to hear I made a positive impression with my photos. It's a slower, more deliberate way of shooting but I like the results. I suspect my 50mm sigma Art is getting jealous.
The slipping isn't any different really, from when I used 4x5 and 8x10. The tilts on those cameras (with the exception of one) were always loose and dependent upon being held in place until tightened. I agree whole heartedly with you on slowing down. It is the only way for me to really understand the questions and attractions I have with a scene.
My used 45 PC-E is scheduled to arrive Thursday. I'm anxious to try it out, and compare it against the Canon 45 TS-E, the Nikon having an excellent reputation for IQ and sharpness, and the Canon, not so much -- although it is one of my favorites among the Canon line.
I must say that the TS/PC types of lenses are my overall favorite, most being really well corrected and offering versatility no standard lens can match. Second favorite type: macro lenses from Canon and Nikon.
Looking forward to more PC-E images posted by FM'ers.
Got the 45 PC-E today. It's well used, and the knob for adjusting tilt is non-functional, but the lens seems quite good in limited testing so far. Seems to be back-focusing at the moment. Testing continues in good light tomorrow.
I pulled out my Canon 45 TS-E and will do an A/B comparison in upcoming days.
The lens looks like it may have great potential, once I get it dialed-in. Here are a few of my first PC-E shots.
No aesthetic merit here: While putting the 45 PC-E lens though it's paces, I thought I'd show a comparison of 3-shot panos taken in the vertical and horizontal shifts in the "landscape" orientation.
PP in LR2015CC. Images from camera mounted on tripod with cable release (earlier shots all hand held).
Note: Three RAW images taken on 36MP sensor, when combined in LR, create a 200MP .dng file!
Nice comparison. How much wide can you go when using Kipon adapter? Can you go wider than 35mm? Don't know if there are wider lens with Mamiya that you can get. Also what are your impressions on the adapter itself?
Gunzorro wrote:
Comparison of 45 PC-E with Mamiya 645 35mm f/3.5N on Kipon shift adapter.
ramkumar999 wrote:
Nice comparison. How much wide can you go when using Kipon adapter? Can you go wider than 35mm? Don't know if there are wider lens with Mamiya that you can get. Also what are your impressions on the adapter itself?
Gunzorro wroteComparison of 45 PC-E with Mamiya 645 35mm f/3.5N on Kipon shift adapter.
Hi Ram,
In response to your questions:
The Kipon adapter (purchased from Adorama, on sale a few months ago for around $180) is a simple manual slider (up/down, or side-to-side) on a rotating mount (spring loaded release). A side shift button is pressed and the unit shifts by hand. Marking show +/- of 15mm each direction, but upward is impacted by the overhanging flash protrusion of the prism cap -- stops at around 10mm. Image circle is big enough to take advantage of full movements. Lens IQ is not up to PC-E standards of sharpness, but still very good at f/8-11, where it is most likely to be shot. The Dehaze slider in LR is a big help on wider apertures.
The Kipon is well made, with no wiggle in the mount or slide. Very smooth.
The lens is extremely well made. Unlike the PC-E lens I've tried, the focus has a very smooth long throw, making precise focus easy. Typical aberrations are: CA (correctable), barrel (somewhat correctable -- note slight wavering on white post on f/11 composite, using LR manual setting of +5 distortion), and curvature of field on sides coming toward lens (not correctable). Still, a pretty decent package for the price.
I believe the 35mm is the widest rectilinear Mamiya 645 lens, at least at an affordable price.
I like the adapter, but added an indicator to show where zero was on the shift scale (hard to see as the scale faces the body when mounted). Overall, I'm happy with it and the combination is far superior to the two old '70s and 80s versions of Nikon 35/2.8 PC lens I've owned (and don't mount on D800).
I'll post some test shots next.
Maximum upward shift, ~10mm
Rear of lens, showing shift scale (red dot added by me)
Here are three shots taken wide open at f/3.5 at each of the three shift positions, focus is on wooden fence. DOF is not bad, and sharpness is surprisingly good. Most problems wide open have to do with micro flaring in branches and CA, which mostly clear when stopping down and applying CA correction in LR. (Note: white border areas in f/3.5 shots showing the result of distortion adjustment.)
The large composite are three images shot at f/11 to give an idea of the sharpness and DOF, which is pretty good due to curvature of field, allowing the grass in front and the monkey puzzle tree in distance to be sharp. Still, the furthest corners and edges never get razor sharp in the shifted positions. All in all, a very respectable performance.
Gunzorro wrote: ramkumar999 wroteNice comparison. How much wide can you go when using Kipon adapter? Can you go wider than 35mm? Don't know if there are wider lens with Mamiya that you can get. Also what are your impressions on the adapter itself?
Gunzorro wroteComparison of 45 PC-E with Mamiya 645 35mm f/3.5N on Kipon shift adapter.Hi Ram,
In response to your questions:
The Kipon adapter (purchased from Adorama, on sale a few months ago for around $180) is a simple manual slider (up/down, or side-to-side) on a rotating mount (spring loaded release). A side shift button is pressed and the unit shifts by hand. Marking show +/- of 15mm each direction, but upward is impacted by the overhanging flash protrusion of the prism cap -- stops at around 10mm. Image circle is big enough to take advantage of full movements. Lens IQ is not up to PC-E standards of sharpness, but still very good at f/8-11, where it is most likely to be shot. The Dehaze slider in LR is a big help on wider apertures.
The Kipon is well made, with no wiggle in the mount or slide. Very smooth.
The lens is extremely well made. Unlike the PC-E lens I've tried, the focus has a very smooth long throw, making precise focus easy. Typical aberrations are: CA (correctable), barrel (somewhat correctable -- note slight wavering on white post on f/11 composite, using LR manual setting of +5 distortion), and curvature of field on sides coming toward lens (not correctable). Still, a pretty decent package for the price.
I believe the 35mm is the widest rectilinear Mamiya 645 lens, at least at an affordable price.
I like the adapter, but added an indicator to show where zero was on the shift scale (hard to see as the scale faces the body when mounted). Overall, I'm happy with it and the combination is far superior to the two old '70s and 80s versions of Nikon 35/2.8 PC lens I've owned (and don't mount on D800).
Thank you for your write up. This is precisely what I was looking for considering., I have the 35mm f3.5 PC Nikkor with me and what to find out if this route helps or not. Thanks again.
ramkumar999 wrote: Gunzorro wroteramkumar999 wroteNice comparison. How much wide can you go when using Kipon adapter? Can you go wider than 35mm? Don't know if there are wider lens with Mamiya that you can get. Also what are your impressions on the adapter itself?
Gunzorro wroteComparison of 45 PC-E with Mamiya 645 35mm f/3.5N on Kipon shift adapter.Hi Ram,
In response to your questions:
The Kipon adapter (purchased from Adorama, on sale a few months ago for around $180) is a simple manual slider (up/down, or side-to-side) on a rotating mount (spring loaded release). A side shift button is pressed and the unit shifts by hand. Marking show +/- of 15mm each direction, but upward is impacted by the overhanging flash protrusion of the prism cap -- stops at around 10mm. Image circle is big enough to take advantage of full movements. Lens IQ is not up to PC-E standards of sharpness, but still very good at f/8-11, where it is most likely to be shot. The Dehaze slider in LR is a big help on wider apertures.
The Kipon is well made, with no wiggle in the mount or slide. Very smooth.
The lens is extremely well made. Unlike the PC-E lens I've tried, the focus has a very smooth long throw, making precise focus easy. Typical aberrations are: CA (correctable), barrel (somewhat correctable -- note slight wavering on white post on f/11 composite, using LR manual setting of +5 distortion), and curvature of field on sides coming toward lens (not correctable). Still, a pretty decent package for the price.
I believe the 35mm is the widest rectilinear Mamiya 645 lens, at least at an affordable price.
I like the adapter, but added an indicator to show where zero was on the shift scale (hard to see as the scale faces the body when mounted). Overall, I'm happy with it and the combination is far superior to the two old '70s and 80s versions of Nikon 35/2.8 PC lens I've owned (and don't mount on D800).
I'll post some test shots next.Thank you for your write up. This is precisely what I was looking for considering., I have the 35mm f3.5 PC Nikkor with me and what to find out if this route helps or not. Thanks again.
Some amazing photos throughout this thread BUT, what is missing are magical shots taken with these lenses that isolate details while washing the scene with delicious blur. Here is a link to a series of images Anton, who posts as Agentbird, dropped on the Manual Focus Nikon Glass thread. I LOVE his whimsical view of the world, created more often than not with a Nikon tilt-shift lens.
CGrindahl wrote:
Some amazing photos throughout this thread BUT, what is missing are magical shots taken with these lenses that isolate details while washing the scene with delicious blur. Here is a link to a series of images Anton, who posts as Agentbird, dropped on the Manual Focus Nikon Glass thread. I LOVE his whimsical view of the world, created more often than not with a Nikon tilt-shift lens.
With all due respect, I've been impressed by the restraint in this thread. There is so much more in focus than not! It is a big contrast to the way that T/S lenses are used in the Portrait or Wedding forums here.