Many good shots in the thread. It would be good if the picture description also carried the letter S or C to indicate the type. It will help readers to better assess the image details as the optical performance are not same for both. If possible and convenient , approx distance to subject can also be mentioned.
kdrk888 wrote:
OK, I caved in and bought back a Sigma S when B&H had a deal with 10% reward, dock + Sigma 105mm UV filter. I am hoping this time I got a good copy. I read various opinions on the customized settings for the AF and the stabilization, would like to hear how you guys customize those setting.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
to: kdrk888
I posted this coot earlier today, but then I was looking and thought he had a metal band around his beak! Was thinking "Is this domesticated somehow?" Ha! No, just the way the low sun was lighting him up...
unni wrote:
Many good shots in the thread. It would be good if the picture description also carried the letter S or C to indicate the type. It will help readers to better assess the image details as the optical performance are not same for both. If possible and convenient , approx distance to subject can also be mentioned.
I've owned both the C & the S. Pointless to try and compare at web sized image. The C is almost as sharp as the S but you can only tell when you zoom to 100%. I kept the S for slightly better autofocus, great build/weather sealing and push/pull zoom.
m.sommers00 wrote:
Do you find yourself still teaching for the 300/2.8 much since you bought the Sigma, Hardcore?
Hey Mathew,
No, not really. Still want to sell my 300mm but I can't bring myself. I'm collecting telephotos like women with shoes. I have the 300mm PF with a 1.4x that I have been using for walking around & travel so the 300mm F2.8 VRII has to go at some point. Basically the only thing I use it for is dramatic portraits.
I guess I'm still a bit unsure on what direction I want to go. If our dollar wasn't so crappy I might be tempted to grab a new 600mm F4E or the 500mm F4E.
I went out today but not many birds! Oh well, I spent the afternoon trying to adjust the Sportsma or Siggy with the dot tune method! Will see if it was worth it tomorrow.
To the people that own or have owned this lens and the Nikon 200-500 , which would you buy again if one was the only one you would have . Why ? I intend to purchase one of these two as a bird & wildlife lens .
SheltoweeTrace wrote:
To the people that own or have owned this lens and the Nikon 200-500 , which would you buy again if one was the only one you would have . Why ? I intend to purchase one of these two as a bird & wildlife lens .
I have Sigma 150-600 Sports, and I am happy with its performance, not to mention its build quality. I have not yet tried Nikon 200-500, but there has been a lot of discussions and reviews comparing the two, such as:
SheltoweeTrace wrote:
To the people that own or have owned this lens and the Nikon 200-500 , which would you buy again if one was the only one you would have . Why ? I intend to purchase one of these two as a bird & wildlife lens .
Had both and kept the Sigma Sport. My take:
Equally sharp
Sigma: faster AF
50mm advantage on the short end and 100mm on the long end
Top notch build quality. It's a real pleasure to use
Very solid aluminum hood (arguably overbuilt) vs a very cheap Nikon hood
Weather sealing
Push/Pull (as Trench mentioned) is a BIG advantage. Difficult to go from 200-500 on the Nikon a) quickly but b) without repositioning your hand in the process
Dock for updating firmware and tweaking settings (Adorama was including this with the lens for free)
Nikon is significantly lighter. This is the only advantage I saw but is a very meaningful one to a lot of people.
None of the above is a knock on the Nikon. It's an excellent lens at it's price point as well. For the shooting I do, the Sigma offered the better value. Really can't go wrong one way or another.
SheltoweeTrace wrote:
To the people that own or have owned this lens and the Nikon 200-500 , which would you buy again if one was the only one you would have . Why ? I intend to purchase one of these two as a bird & wildlife lens .
Had both and kept the Sigma Sport. The AF on the 200-500 was noticeably slower. I recently shot both soccer and tennis with the Sport and was very impressed with the sharpness and AF. Normally I would shoot both with a 400 2.8 and I barely felt the difference in AF performance when I shot the Sigma instead.
Buildwise the Sport is better, but that also makes it heavier. Still you can hand hold it - though it is not as easy as the 200-500.
150-600 gives better range for composition and slight reduction in sharpness at 1:1 will not be an issue in most situations. Composition is what that basically works inside the viewer , knowingly or unknowingly.