The additional weight is the main concern between this and the Nikon. Sharpness seems to be about the same (if you net all the reviews) with the possibility of slightly faster AF on the Sigma. The only real issue for my use is whether this lens is hand holdable (based on weight).
I have had my Sigma Sport 150-600mm for quite a while now, but haven't used it much this winter. I got out today to the Skagit Wildlife Area on Fir Island, and found this guy. The blue sky here is an anomaly. Seattle is about to break an all time record for the most rainfall from December through February. We got about an hour of sun today - that should last us another month or so...
Bought a 150-600 Contemporary for my wife to use and borrowed it today to give it a spin. I'm impressed with it so far. I prefer the VR on the 200-500 to the OS on the sigma. I like the focus limit options on the sigma better. With it restricted to 2.8-10m the AF is pretty snappy and great for close birds and such. I'm impressed with the IQ and is better than I expected. Better than the Tamron I had and almost as sharp as the 200-500.
TightLines wrote:
How many of you are using this lens hand held?
The additional weight is the main concern between this and the Nikon. Sharpness seems to be about the same (if you net all the reviews) with the possibility of slightly faster AF on the Sigma. The only real issue for my use is whether this lens is hand holdable (based on weight).
Depends on how in shape you are. I find it hand holdable so do some others but there are people that complain about it's weight
Fair enough. I think I can keep reading between the lines and debating this until version II of this lens is out. Just need to get my hands on one and make a decision.
TightLines wrote:
How many of you are using this lens hand held?
I have several lady friends that have no problem handholding the Sport.
They prop it when they can but for overheads and pans...muscle it like
the rest of us. Keep the SS at 1600/2000 and savor the captures.
The Sport is heavier than the Nikon and the Tamron. But also heavier than it's sibling, the Sigma Contemporary. The Sport is the flagship. It's far heavier than the Sigma 150-600mm "C" which is what really should be tried and compared to the Nikon. The Sigma C has about the same IQ as the Sport. What you are buying with the sport is higher quality. You are buying strength and durability. real metal, bigger front element, much better weather resistance. The question people should be asking is not about IQ, but are they willing to pay the premium (Sport versus Contemporary) for the better build quality, which has a price in weight and size. But sometimes, it's the awkwardness toward the front that can sometimes make the difference or make it feel heavier.
What you also have going on right now is the Sigma $200 & $100 off, which gets them to a more affordable price point to compare with Nikon.
ckcarr wrote:
What you are buying with the sport is higher quality. You are buying strength and durability. real metal, bigger front element, much better weather resistance. The question people should be asking is not about IQ, but are they willing to pay the premium (Sport versus Contemporary) for the better build quality, which has a price in weight and size. But sometimes, it's the awkwardness toward the front that can sometimes make the difference or make it feel heavier.
I bought the Sport for just that reason. Yes the IQ is similar but I sometimes go out in less than ideal conditions so I want the extra weather sealing. The 2lb difference wasn't too big for me, but for others it might be a big deal. Honestly if you use a tripod then none of this matters.
Fun thing when you're not shooting with it you can curl it and build your muscles for the future
I've been enjoying the pics and info on this thread over the last couple weeks. Watching for a used copy of the Contemporary version on the Buy/Sell forum. Not sure if it has been mentioned or not, but I noticed on Sigma's website they have a short note about an upcoming firmware update (AF speed) for both versions of the lens scheduled for March 11.
Will describe how to hand hold the sport and I do it regularly. While I used to shoot hand held all the time with long lenses, getting the weight off my body using a tripod lets me come home less tired and while VR (OS) works great, you can still go slower on a tripod and in many cases even with your shutter speed up, results are still sharper on a tripod. As for weather sealing, I love to shoot in weather such as this past Monday during the snowstorm here in New York City.
These are great Morris. I like both of the images so much...
Your conclusions about the tripod match my own. While I use a 200-400 f4 and not the Sigma, I'd rather deal with the inconvenience of a tripod to get the most out of my lens rather than be forced to shoot at higher ISO's so that the image can be shot handheld. I lose a few moments here and their, but when I nail a shot... I nail the shot.
CJMiller wrote:
... Not sure if it has been mentioned or not, but I noticed on Sigma's website they have a short note about an upcoming firmware update (AF speed) for both versions of the lens scheduled for March 11.
Thanks for the heads up on this! If anyone wants to see the announcement, you can find it at:
It is for both the Sport and the Contemporary version of the Sigma 150-600mm lens, and for both the Nikon and Canon mounts. The key item that is mentioned is the following: "It is expected to increase autofocus speed by approximately 20%, to a maximum of 50%, during normal shooting as well as when using “Speed Priority” set through SIGMA Optimization Pro."