gdanmitchell wrote: RustyBug wroteBTW, did you see the three planes in the sky?Ha! No, I missed them. If I had done my usual dust bunny patrol I might have spotted them, but I only looked closely at the small section I printed and at one other area near a corner where I wanted to reduce a bit of CA.
very disappointed with canon announcement...I had hopes that Canon will do a come back to the top of the line in dslr improvements, but they don't want to compete with the new kids in the block, sony, Panasonic, Fuji, Olympus and Samsung...too bad because canon has the technology and "know how", but they chose to protect high end products....only time will tell if this is the right move or not, for me is the wrong one...that's why I sold all my canon stuff and more than happy with my sony a7s, also by the time Canon 5ds/r will be in the market in June, I am pretty sure Nikon, Sony and someone else will deliver another camera with better specs than this canon dslrs....
IMhO those disappointed with the 5Ds have a right to be and express their opinion without being attacked. After waiting patiently for Canon to answer the Exmor sensor with something to be proud of its understandable some people are extremely disappointed. It's not only happening in this forum but all over the place so its not just a few DtRolls.
Ok, we have yet to see a RAW file and what can be done with it, but on paper and from the samples provided, this sensor isnt even in the same post/zip code as the the exmor sensor, it's a lot closer to APS-c than it is to MF. For many thats fine and they'll buy and hopefully enjoy it, but I'm wondering if when Sony release their 50mp version whether it will put into perspective what could have been. I for one, will reserve judgement until the two have been compared side by side from RAW and if the Canon compares favourably my 5D3 will be for sale. A 1DX and a 5DsR would be a great pair of bodies to own
I'm wondering whether the DR will match the EOS-1D X? The shadow recovery on the 1D X is good enough for me (although it is not close to the Sony EXmor), so that would make the 5DS serviceable.
The EOS 6D is actually a touch better at ISO 160, so may, just maybe?
takowasa wrote:
However, for a given proportion of the photo, it will have 1.6x the electronic noise and 2.56x the saturation of the 7D2 for a given exposure, resulting in a 2/3 stop increase in DR.
I'm not following ... if the pixel density is the same, why would the noise and saturation be different for a given exposure. That (currently) makes no sense to me. Could you break down these two with amplifying clarification?
takowasa wrote:
The DR can be improved in the following ways:
1) Reduce the electronic noise
2) Increase the full well saturation of the pixel.
For a given camera ... can the shooter influence either of these?
Bones74 wrote:
IMhO those disappointed with the 5Ds have a right to be and express their opinion without being attacked. After waiting patiently for Canon to answer the Exmor sensor with something to be proud of its understandable some people are extremely disappointed...
Why would anyone feel the need to be proud of what a manufacturer produces? None of us work for the companies or design the products.
jctriguy wrote: Bones74 wroteIMhO those disappointed with the 5Ds have a right to be and express their opinion without being attacked. After waiting patiently for Canon to answer the Exmor sensor with something to be proud of its understandable some people are extremely disappointed...Why would anyone feel the need to be proud of what a manufacturer produces? None of us work for the companies or design the products.
jctriguy wrote: Bones74 wroteIMhO those disappointed with the 5Ds have a right to be and express their opinion without being attacked. After waiting patiently for Canon to answer the Exmor sensor with something to be proud of its understandable some people are extremely disappointed...Why would anyone feel the need to be proud of what a manufacturer produces? None of us work for the companies or design the products.
That's your opinion. I believe I made my point, not my fault if it sailed over your head
If Canon products are so horrible for dynamic range why are you using Canon?
Just buy a Nikon D800 or D810 and sell off you Canon gear.
If I expose properly, I find the 1D X and 6D serve me just fine.
I do not expect mid-day images to look like the golden hour light.
If I underexpose I do not expect to pull out an far under-exposed shot from the shadows.
I bracket the exposures.
I shoot events and am rarely below ISO1600 to see any benefit of jumping ship. Heck, I would probably see a decrease in my dynamic range. Further, even if I wanted to jump ship, I have so much invested in Canon glass that it would be absolutely foolish to do so for one sensor characteristic that I can mostly achieve using magic lantern dual ISO when I need it.
My entire point, which you seem to have missed, is that there is a solid group of people who absolutely could use that DR and are somewhat locked into the Canon camp due to their glass purchases.
To be perfectly honest, I don't know why people aren't clamoring for Canon to reach sensor parity with a 3 year old sensor. Think about that for a minute, in 3 years Canon has yet to meet the performance bar set by a now outdated camera. It is absolutely absurd. That would be like purchasing a modern car with drum brakes instead of disk brakes because they work just as well except for when they absolutely don't. Being satisfied with outdated technology may lead to a happier lifestyle but it has never advanced society in any meaningful way except to provide the old guard with a sense of security.
Canon's AF system and FPS may have been the best around when I got my 1D IIN. That didn't make me proud of Canon. It provided me with a tool that served my needs (okay desires).
Ford makes it a point to always use the bolts for holding their beds on trucks larger than their competitors as something they can lay claim to. The size of the bolts being used are approaching ridiculous (for most needs) in the game of upmanship. Does that make me proud to own a Ford, or do I simply want a tool that lets me do the job I want to use the tool for? Does that mean I need to get a new truck, so I can have Ford's largest bed bolts?
Personally, I don't need the biggest, baddest bed bolt to haul my cameras and tripods. At what point is strong, strong enough. I watch the truck ads and see them pulling 30,000 lbs ... really, what in the world do I need with a truck that can pull 30,000 lbs?
Not everyone needs that "magical" one extra stop of DR for their work. And, when faced with a scene that is four stops beyond your camera's DR, how would one extra stop really change things. You still won't have sufficient DR for the scene and will have to bracket or sacrifice.
Going back to the diff of the D810 vs. the D750 ... there is no such thing as a "free lunch". Folks get caught up in the Canon vs. others, but even with the others, we can see that choices still have to be made regarding preferences / compromises. We'd like to think that we can "have it all", but sometimes that really isn't the case.
I mean, in review of the D810 ... it left me wanting for the high end of the D750. In review of the D750, it left me wanting for the low end of the D810. People are fickle and insatiable. The moment that Canon delivers more DR ... we'll want even more DR.
Being satisfied with outdated technology may lead to a happier lifestyle but it has never advanced society in any meaningful way except to provide the old guard with a sense of security.
Then, you probably should go buy a new car every time they release a new feature each year.
BTW ... tell them to leave out the radio ... that's old technology.
howard wrote: jctriguy wroteBones74 wroteIMhO those disappointed with the 5Ds have a right to be and express their opinion without being attacked. After waiting patiently for Canon to answer the Exmor sensor with something to be proud of its understandable some people are extremely disappointed...Why would anyone feel the need to be proud of what a manufacturer produces? None of us work for the companies or design the products.https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1340814/0#12802754
Being a proud owner of something is different than having a desire to be proud of a product made by a specific company. If canon doesn't make something you would be proud to own, look for a different product.
RustyBug wrote:
+1 ... not an issue of pride, but one of utility.
Canon's AF system and FPS may have been the best around when I got my 1D IIN. That didn't make me proud of Canon. It provided me with a tool that served my needs (okay desires).
Ford makes it a point to always use the bolts for holding their beds on trucks larger than their competitors as something they can lay claim to. The size of the bolts being used are approaching ridiculous (for most needs) in the game of upmanship. Does that make me proud to own a Ford, or do I simply want a tool that lets me do the job I want to use the tool for? Does that mean I need to get a new truck, so I can have Ford's largest bed bolts?
Personally, I don't need the biggest, baddest bed bolt to haul my cameras and tripods. At what point is strong, strong enough. I watch the truck ads and see them pulling 30,000 lbs ... really, what in the world do I need with a truck that can pull 30,000 lbs?
Not everyone needs that "magical" one extra stop of DR for their work. And, when faced with a scene that is four stops beyond your camera's DR, how would one extra stop really change things. You still won't have sufficient DR for the scene and will have to bracket or sacrifice.
Going back to the diff of the D810 vs. the D750 ... there is no such thing as a "free lunch". Folks get caught up in the Canon vs. others, but even with the others, we can see that choices still have to be made regarding preferences / compromises. We'd like to think that we can "have it all", but sometimes that really isn't the case.
I mean, in review of the D810 ... it left me wanting for the high end of the D750. In review of the D750, it left me wanting for the low end of the D810. People are fickle and insatiable. The moment that Canon delivers more DR ... we'll want even more DR. ...Show more →
Why shouldn't we always want for more DR? Or better AF? Or more megapixels? Is desiring more a crime against humanity? It has been the insatiable desire to go faster and go further than our neighbor that has pushed us forward as a society. Do we need a space station or a manned mission to Mars in order to live our lives? No. Is it an amazing feet that should be strived for? Absolutely.
People constantly complain about the millennial generation but people don't see that we aren't the problem.
kezeka wrote:
People constantly complain about the millennial generation but people don't see that we aren't the problem.
I don't recall anyone suggesting that there is a problem with wanting to advance things. That is a far different matter from understanding utility, contentedness and fit for purpose. Give it about 30 years ... you'll look back on this and smile when the "must have more" position is still being promulgated (+1 @ human nature).
Roush is now working on a 1,000 HP Mustang ... does that mean everyone should go buy one? 300HP is sufficient for my taste. And yet somehow, Camry's and minivans keep selling too.
Let's all loosen up a little bit. Nothing wrong with wanting more advanced technology. There is also nothing wrong with being satisfied with what you have already. In fact, I think technology advances like this -- one waves leapfrogs over another, pushing the frontier ever forward. When new technology becomes available, we get excited, we make the best out of it. After a while, we start thinking about what more can be achieved, and a new generation of technology becomes available.
It's always a balance between taking full advantage of what's available today, and pushing for even more possibilities. We can all get along.
We have been beaten over the head by the Nikon/Sony folks over DR and mostly right here on FM, probably the Landscape forum. That has led to high hopes for more DR.
I suppose we had it coming because for years Canon was the leader, first with full frame and until the last go around more pixels.
The irony is that on the web when you have an 800 pixel wide limit, high mp is overkill. I justify high MP because I print, but my printer cannot make much use of more than 22 mpixles.
For DR, I bracket and blend when i have challenging scenes. Both Nik HDR pro and SNS HDR pro can even handle subject motion. I have very few scenes that can't be worked. So I can live with 5D3 level DR, even though more would be better.
I had a real dilemma when the 5D3 was introduced and I already owned the 1DS-mk3. Why upgrade for 1 mp? I eventually did because the sale of the 1ds3 made it more of a swap. I am glad I did. Live view focus which the 1DS3 lacked was a major upgrade for me. The overall AF was also better and the files were cleaner, and finally no dust.
I expect in time to upgrade to a 5DR, and I am sure I will love it. I might have to buy new larger frames and have my prints made outside. I may be induced to buy a 4 k monitor. It will cost money, but heck, its just my kids inheirtence
RustyBug wrote: kezeka wrotePeople constantly complain about the millennial generation but people don't see that we aren't the problem.I don't recall anyone suggesting that there is a problem with wanting to advance things. That is a far different matter from understanding utility, contentedness and fit for purpose. Give it about 30 years ... you'll look back on this and smile.
Roush is now working on a 1,000 HP Mustang ... does that mean everyone should go buy one? And yet somehow, Camry's and minivans keep selling.
No one is forcing anyone to buy this camera and it's not going to replace all the other Canon DSLR's - it's a niche product for a certain type of photographic requirement. That photographic requirement however is not just about pixel numbers and as such for many like me this camera will not be the right choice. I'm using every bit of the 14 stops of DR that I can get out of the A7r and there is no way I'll trade 2 stops for a few more pixels and I'm sure I'm not alone.
shirozina wrote:
I'm using every bit of the 14 stops of DR that I can get out of the A7r and there is no way I'll trade 2 stops for a few more pixels and I'm sure I'm not alone.
So, you've just made the exact point @ "fit for purpose" ... don't buy a Canon if that is what your needs are. Others have needs that their "fit for purpose" requirements rule out the A7R ... so they don't buy the A7R.
Unfortunately, we do not have any single camera that affords all things to all people ... such is life. We simply find those things that best fit our needs / goals / objectives / desires. Sometimes it isn't a matter of what we want that drives our direction, but a matter of what we DON'T want.
In the case of the A7R ... I don't want the ergonomics it provides with certain glass. I don't want to use adapters to use tilt shift glass. I don't want to reduce AF performance via adapters. Those are all "fit for purpose" issues. There are some aspects of the A7R or D810 that would be to my liking, but that there are other things that are not.
Your point that a few extra MP's are of little value to you ... I get that. Just because the extra MP's are available doesn't mean that you are compelled to adopt the advanced MP ... sounds like you've just exacted the very point @ contentedness (just in regard to a different criteria). Likewise, there are those who are not compelled to adopt the advanced DR that is available .... usually for their own "fit for purpose" and contentedness reasons that include criteria other than DR.
Some folks find DR to be their "Holy Grail" ... others, not so much.
Some folks find resolution to be their "Holy Grail" ... others, not so much.
Some folks find XYZ to be their "Holy Grail" ... others, not so much.
takowasa wrote:
However, for a given proportion of the photo, it will have 1.6x the electronic noise and 2.56x the saturation of the 7D2 for a given exposure, resulting in a 2/3 stop increase in DR.
RustyBug wrote:
I'm not following ... if the pixel density is the same, why would the noise and saturation be different for a given exposure. That (currently) makes no sense to me. Could you break down these two with amplifying clarification?
Five pixels on FF would cover the same portion of the photo as two pixels on crop. So, per proportion of the photo, FF would have 1.6x more electronic noise and absorb 2.56x more light for the same exposure.
takowasa wrote:
The DR can be improved in the following ways:
1) Reduce the electronic noise
2) Increase the full well saturation of the pixel.
RustyBug asked:
For a given camera ... can the shooter influence either of these?