shirozina wrote: alundeb wroteIt seems to me that some Sony A7 / A7r users are willing to take any quirk with a camera as long as it is not less than 14 stops dynamic range:
- Shutter shock at long focal lengths and certain shutter speeds
- Sensor cover glass reflections around bright spots
- Sensor cover glass induced corner smearing
- Adapter thickness and alignment issues with floating elements UWA lenses
- Compressed raw artifacts around bright spots / high contrast detail
- Less dynamic range at very high ISO
- No weather sealing
- Slow startup time
- Short battery life- Shutter shock at long focal lengths and certain shutter speeds - never seen it in my work
- Sensor cover glass reflections around bright spots - ditto
- Sensor cover glass induced corner smearing - not a problem with any lens that can also fit a Canon thus a non issue
- Adapter thickness and alignment issues with floating elements UWA lenses - non issue with me
- Compressed raw artifacts around bright spots / high contrast detail - YAWN - non issue with photography of real world subjects. Contrast ratio needed to provoke this unobtainable with any larger light source as lens flare prevents the contrast drop across small pixel transitions
- Less dynamic range at very high ISO - what cameras have the same or more DR as iso increases?
- No weather sealing - not an issue for me but been out in the rain a few times and both cameras are still going
- Slow startup time - a few seconds - not an issue for my use which is 100% on a tripod
- Short battery life - so what - take more batteries. If you can afford the body and lenses to do the sensor justice a handful of batteries is not an issue.
With all the complaining here, this thread ignores the fact that this new Canon may indeed provide the very best image quality available in any DSLR, and possibly anywhere. If I were a studio or "headshot" photographer, I would be extremely interested in this camera.
I clearly understand the benefits of higher DR. But in a studio, you control for that, and in those situations, the higher pixel count matters and the existing DR is more than enough. And remember, no rendering medium has the dynamic range of even a 5Diii. So you have to recover that detail in post, crush it into the DR of a screen or printer, and you'll create a somewhat unnatural-looking photograph.
If I was a wedding or event photographer, and they said: "Shoot this couple HERE, no flash!", then I'd want the high DR. Sure. But for my amateur needs, it is better when I control the lighting by shooting during golden hour or overcast days. And the reason for that is: If I control DR in my composition, the resulting photograph will render better and more naturally. High DR is a valuable tool, but it's still a crutch.
Chuck Westfall in the interview clearly is trying not to undercut the value of the 5D3.
He notes 5D3 has superior video and ISO range than the new 5Ds.
His statements plainly describe the new 5Ds as carefully designed for certain fields,
like landscape and architecture. Canon is continuing its niche design development
style.
Okay, first the Canon man states that DR are like 5D Mark III but he then goes on to states that there is "a much lower noise floor so therefore there is more ability to pull out details in shadows and highlights".
What to make of this? Is there still a bit of hope?
RustyBug wrote: MintMar wroteBut it will drive down 5D3 prices, so I will sooner or later (I expect later) open my wallet for 5D3. At least I will still get latest sensor tech. "latest CANON sensor tech"
Sneakyracer wrotestill the case of a GREAT body looking for a sensor.Don't forget the glass that accompanies the body and for those who use Canon Flash, that as well.
Great Lens / Great Body / Good Sensor ... well, two out of three ain't bad.
So close ... that they could have gone three out of three ... but didn't.
Yeah, totally.
MAD congrats to the Canon Lens Department. They have continued to come out with some trully outstanding lenses. I applaud them.
The sensor department seems to be stuck in the old basement with old tools.
garydavidjones wrote:
Chuck Westfall in the interview clearly is trying not to undercut the value of the 5D3.
He notes 5D3 has superior video and ISO range than the new 5Ds.
His statements plainly describe the new 5Ds as carefully designed for certain fields,
like landscape and architecture. Canon is continuing its niche design development
style.
Yeah, by blatantly cutting features in certain models that are certainly capable of having them. Really insulting to the customers.
garydavidjones wrote:
Canon is continuing its niche design development
style. No! It's not about "developing for niches," it's about developing the best camera you can. Sports and nature photographers are LOVING the 7Dii. They LOVE it. And they don't really care that other photographers don't get it. It's a very difficult type of photography to do well, and it technically takes time to master. But... somebody who drags a $6,000 lens out into a marsh to shoot a rapidly-moving rare bird species in the perfect light of dawn can tell when a reviewer is missing the concept. Is the 7Dii a "niche" camera? I would describe it as the best camera for it's market. The new 5Ds is probably going to be the best studio camera you can buy; the comparison will be Hasselblad, won't it?
So what does that make the Nikon D750? Well, it makes it a second-rate sports and studio camera, doesn't it? Still a very nice camera, no doubt, but when you spend $3,000 on a body, you actually ought to have some interest in mind, not merely general-purpose snapshots.
Okay, first the Canon man states that DR are like 5D Mark III but he then goes on to states that there is "a much lower noise floor so therefore there is more ability to pull out details in shadows and highlights".
What to make of this? Is there still a bit of hope?
a lower noise floor enables you to pull more detail out of the highlights............?
If It did indeed have higher DR don't you think Canon would be promoting this? Do they think most potential users of this camera only understand sensor quality in terms of numbers of pixels?
Which is why I'm still stuck in 2004. I was hoping to make a bigger leap than that. Guess I can pretty much quit hoping for that to happen ... this year anyway.
I mean, I got more excited about my Lumix FZ1000 than I have anything Canon has brought to the table since I came aboard in 2009. Really rather disheartening ... not debilitating, but disheartening nonetheless.
shirozina wrote:
a lower noise floor enables you to pull more detail out of the highlights............?
If It did indeed have higher DR don't you think Canon would be promoting this? Do they think most potential users of this camera only understand sensor quality in terms of pixels?
MarshallG wrote:
So what does that make the Nikon D750? Well, it makes it a second-rate sports and studio camera, doesn't it? Still a very nice camera, no doubt, but when you spend $3,000 on a body, you actually ought to have some interest in mind, not merely general-purpose snapshots.
Well, heck, the next time I see _____________ out and about with his 750, dragging along his reputation as a former NPPA photographer of the year and Pulitzer finalist -- among a pile of other awards -- I'll inform him that he ain't foolin' MarshallG into believin' he knows anything about choosing a camera. Did get some nice general purpose snapshots for Getty with it at the recent Big Game, though.
henry albert wrote: MarshallG wroteSo what does that make the Nikon D750? Well, it makes it a second-rate sports and studio camera, doesn't it? Still a very nice camera, no doubt, but when you spend $3,000 on a body, you actually ought to have some interest in mind, not merely general-purpose snapshots.Well, heck, the next time I see _____________ out and about with his 750, dragging along his reputation as a former NPPA photographer of the year and Pulitzer finalist -- among a pile of other awards -- I'll inform him that he ain't foolin' MarshallG into believin' he knows anything about choosing a camera. Did get some nice general purpose snapshots for Getty with it at the recent Big Game, though.Just because the D750 isn't the best camera in the world for sports (and it isn't), that doesn't mean a pro photographer can't use it. 99% of our craft is about the person and 1% is the equipment. Obviously, you need certain focal lengths for sports, but these things we quibble over pale in comparison to what the photographer brings.
Personally, I'd love to have a D750. I just don't want to sell my lens collection.
Sneakyracer wrote:
The sensor department seems to be stuck in the old basement with old tools.
So far the 1D sensor progression has been good to me. So long as that continues I don't really care if it's old tools or not. If the 1DX2 offers better performance then my 1DX I'll buy it.
ggreene wrote: Sneakyracer wroteThe sensor department seems to be stuck in the old basement with old tools.So far the 1D sensor progression has been good to me. So long as that continues I don't really care if it's old tools or not. If the 1DX2 offers better performance then my 1DX I'll buy it.
RustyBug wrote: Methodical wroteWhat type of photography is a wider DR best used for?
ThanksNon-studio ... i.e. dynamic range of natural ambient with back or side lighting. Mixtures of ambient and artificial @ interior architectural (real estate) with windows. Subjects that warrant fill lighting, but are too large or too distant achieve, etc.
I'm sure there are others, as well.
So, wildlife photographers can benefit from this too?
Methodical wrote: RustyBug wroteMethodical wroteWhat type of photography is a wider DR best used for?
ThanksNon-studio ... i.e. dynamic range of natural ambient with back or side lighting. Mixtures of ambient and artificial @ interior architectural (real estate) with windows. Subjects that warrant fill lighting, but are too large or too distant achieve, etc.
I'm sure there are others, as well.So, wildlife photographers can benefit from this too?
Yes, of course, do you dispute that?
Higher DR will benefit all types of photography; the degree depends on the situation.