taemo wrote: ratsnest74 wroteD750 here I comei don't think the 5Ds or 5DsR was meant to compete with the D750 anyway
for those saying the jump from 36MP is 50MP is not worth it, seriously?
24MP 6000 x 4000
36MP 7360 x 4912
50MP 8688 x 5792
I don't keep up to date with the latest digital gears now a days and don't know much about Canon's latest sensor but 50MP sounds good to me
I don't think is worth 50 MP with a camera that offers the same DR of the MK III, $4000 juts to obtain resolution? do not make sense. Additionally is your computer ready to handle 50MP files?
Another way of looking at the diff from 50MP to 36MP is PPI
@ 8688 on the long side of a 30 inch (long) print = 290 PPI
@ 7360 = 245 PPI
If the diff @ 245 PPI vs. 295 PPI is critical to your work @ that size or larger, then it might be warranted. But, 245 PPI is no slouch even though 300 DPI is widely used as a default target.
Frankly, my laptop is 2 years old, cost about $1300 and handles 50MP files fine, it depends on your workflow and how many photos you're processing and how you're processing but I've never had an issue with my system crashing.
8TB external drive costs $279.
If there's any issue with this new camera, we don't know it yet, because we don't know the IQ of the sensor. I wish there was 4K, but oh well.
Lightsearcher wrote: taemo wroteratsnest74 wroteD750 here I comei don't think the 5Ds or 5DsR was meant to compete with the D750 anyway
for those saying the jump from 36MP is 50MP is not worth it, seriously?
24MP 6000 x 4000
36MP 7360 x 4912
50MP 8688 x 5792
I don't keep up to date with the latest digital gears now a days and don't know much about Canon's latest sensor but 50MP sounds good to meI don't think is worth 50 MP with a camera that offers the same DR of the MK III, $4000 juts to obtain resolution? do not make sense. Additionally is your computer ready to handle 50MP files?
alundeb wrote:
It seems to me that some Sony A7 / A7r users are willing to take any quirk with a camera as long as it is not less than 14 stops dynamic range:
- Shutter shock at long focal lengths and certain shutter speeds
- Sensor cover glass reflections around bright spots
- Sensor cover glass induced corner smearing
- Adapter thickness and alignment issues with floating elements UWA lenses
- Compressed raw artifacts around bright spots / high contrast detail
- Less dynamic range at very high ISO
- No weather sealing
- Slow startup time
- Short battery life
So the 5ds solves all this and works with Leica M lenses?
Lightsearcher wrote:
I don't think is worth 50 MP with a camera that offers the same DR of the MK III, $4000 juts to obtain resolution? do not make sense. Additionally is your computer ready to handle 50MP files?
I've been scanning 4x5 and soon 8x10 sheets on my pc for over a year now so yes 8600x5700 is fairly normal to me.
if someone needs 50MP for $4000 I think that's a bargain.
After all there are people willing to spend $6000 for a 12fps 18MP camera or a digital rangefinder camera.
Can't comment about DR as I don't know anything about Canon's latest sensor but I've briefly played with a MK III and owned a II and didn't have any complaints with DR, banding yes.
RustyBug wrote:
Glass vs. sensor ... I prefer Canon's glass and dig the lower base ISO. Of course, the lower base ISO means that compared to SoNikon you aren't going to get the same results on the high end of things due to the different starting point.
Lower base ISO? From what I've seen, the base ISO is 100, expandable to 50, like most Nikon/Sony/Canon cameras. The D810 starts at 64, expandable to 32 though.
ken.vs.ryu wrote: alundeb wroteIt seems to me that some Sony A7 / A7r users are willing to take any quirk with a camera as long as it is not less than 14 stops dynamic range:
- Shutter shock at long focal lengths and certain shutter speeds
- Sensor cover glass reflections around bright spots
- Sensor cover glass induced corner smearing
- Adapter thickness and alignment issues with floating elements UWA lenses
- Compressed raw artifacts around bright spots / high contrast detail
- Less dynamic range at very high ISO
- No weather sealing
- Slow startup time
- Short battery lifeSo the 5ds solves all this and works with Leica M lenses?
The previous 5D model solves all those issues, and likely the 5Ds does, but of course it will not work with Leica M lenses. The post was intended for those using or conteplating to use Canon glass on the A7r and finding the 5Ds to be an epic fail because the low ISO DR is 13 stops and not 14.
I own an A7r and use it with alternative lenses, but I found that I value the functionality and thorough quality of a Canon DSLR too much to go only mirrorles yet.
"As far as dynamic range is concerned, we're told that the new 5DS and 5DS R should give the same performance as the current EOS 5D Mark III. If true, this means that the new cameras won't be able to offer the same industry-leading dynamic range of Sony's current APS-C and full-frame sensors, but at least it isn't a step backwards. And hey - 50MP!"
I would call this nonchalance at best, if not disguised negativity, from a neutral review site.
dehowie wrote:
Having finally been convinced that along with Canon most of us dont care about it they can take there whinging and whining over to the Nikon forum where they can start up on the quality of Nikon glass.
Not sure why anyone would want to whine about having superior glass, other than it costs more than some of the other brands...
shirozina wrote:
DR 'officially' same as before - sticking with my A7r and metabones adapter. DR was the main reason I moved from a 5dII last year so not going to loose > 2 stops of DR just for a bit more resolution. I won't use the words ' epic fail' but I'm disappointed. Epic fail? - time will tell.....
Well good thing Canon didn't make it just for you.
Lauchlan Toal wrote: RustyBug wroteGlass vs. sensor ... I prefer Canon's glass and dig the lower base ISO. Of course, the lower base ISO means that compared to SoNikon you aren't going to get the same results on the high end of things due to the different starting point.Lower base ISO? From what I've seen, the base ISO is 100, expandable to 50, like most Nikon/Sony/Canon cameras. The D810 starts at 64, expandable to 32 though.
Otherwise, very valid points.
Forgot about the D810 (even though it caught my attention a month ago for that very point).
Which makes a good point @ when comparing the D810 to the D750 (as an academic study @ inherent design choices) ... the diff's are more noticeable there on both the low end and on the high end, not quite as much in the middle. It makes recognition @ how much influence the "starting" point @ base influences the ending point for a given usage. The D750 wins the high end battle, the D810 the low one.
Kinda reminds of trying to pick a cam profile for an engine. Some folks like low end, grunt pulling torque ... others want high RPM horsepower. Meanwhile, OEM mfr's try to cover the bases for a wide application of users. Too bad we can't swap out sensors to our liking (like we did with film) in our cameras like we can camshafts in an engine.
ben egbert wrote: howard wroteben egbert wroteI missed the link that says Canon admits DR is unchanged. Anyone have a link?From the horse's mouth, so to speak:
interview with Chuck WestfallThanks, I had not seen it. Now it's official. Guess I will have to stay with brackets and HDR.
Reading his body language and certain things he says I think he knows all is not altogether perfect with these cameras
alundeb wrote:
It seems to me that some Sony A7 / A7r users are willing to take any quirk with a camera as long as it is not less than 14 stops dynamic range:
- Shutter shock at long focal lengths and certain shutter speeds
- Sensor cover glass reflections around bright spots
- Sensor cover glass induced corner smearing
- Adapter thickness and alignment issues with floating elements UWA lenses
- Compressed raw artifacts around bright spots / high contrast detail
- Less dynamic range at very high ISO
- No weather sealing
- Slow startup time
- Short battery life
- Shutter shock at long focal lengths and certain shutter speeds - never seen it in my work
- Sensor cover glass reflections around bright spots - ditto
- Sensor cover glass induced corner smearing - not a problem with any lens that can also fit a Canon thus a non issue
- Adapter thickness and alignment issues with floating elements UWA lenses - non issue with me
- Compressed raw artifacts around bright spots / high contrast detail - YAWN - non issue with photography of real world subjects. Contrast ratio needed to provoke this unobtainable with any larger light source as lens flare prevents the contrast drop across small pixel transitions
- Less dynamic range at very high ISO - what cameras have the same or more DR as iso increases?
- No weather sealing - not an issue for me but been out in the rain a few times and both cameras are still going
- Slow startup time - a few seconds - not an issue for my use which is 100% on a tripod
- Short battery life - so what - take more batteries. If you can afford the body and lenses to do the sensor justice a handful of batteries is not an issue.