agelessphotog wrote:
mshi wrote
agelessphotog wrote
mshi wrote
The DC lenses are notorious for their poor AF accuracy largely due to their lack of spherical aberration correction - partly because of the need to obtain better skin tones in camera before the digital era - and the issue is particularly acute when shooting at wide open or near wide open. Though DOF is inherently different between f/2 and f/2.8 at a given focus distance, the difference is not hugely different. Bokeh is more a personal preference and taste which is hard to quantity scientifically. Overall, 70-200VRII outperforms both of them, easily. Skin tones and bokeh are much better on the DC lenses than the 70-200VRII. Af may not be as accurate or fast but IQ is better. Also I can tell you the AF on my 135 F2 DC is really good on my D750, not as good on my D600. Even at 2.8 the DC's Bokeh is more buttery and better. The only Nikon lens that renders better skin tones is the 200 F2. Yes and no. If one shoots film or jpg with no post, the answer is yes. If he shoots raw, skin tones can be conveniently changed in post according to his taste since he won't be put into bandage of camera's tyranny. So can any effects of out-of-focus (OOF) blurs.
It seems to me that ultra thin OOF blurs for portraiture, in general, only appeals to newbies. When was the last time that one saw that kind of look in Nadav Kinder's or Annie Leibovitz's portraiture works? Correct me if I'm wrong but doesn't Lisa Holloway shoot wide open at F2 with her Canon 200 and 135?
She also uses them essentially as landscape lenses, getting 35mm-like compositions with extremely blurred backgrounds, while still keeping enough DOF for her subjects to remain sharp.
It's a very specific use of a very specific and expensive lens (in the 200/2L's case) that likely couldn't be very well replicated with a slower prime or zoom, and it's also not a look for everyone.