fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014The 135/2 DC Thread

  
 
agelessphotog
Offline
Details
p.4 #1The 135/2 DC Thread
DSC_0794 by agelessphotog, on Flickr
May 08, 2015 at 10:54 AM
fetopher
Offline
Details
p.4 #2The 135/2 DC Thread
thegame81 wrote:
replaced a 200 f2 with this and so far I'm loving it.


I'd be curious about this as well. I've had the 135DC for a few years and I love it, but just a week ago got the 200mm f2. To me, the 200mm f2 is in a league of its own. I probably won't sell my 135DC since I like having different focal lengths, but I can't see myself using it nearly as much as the 200mm f2.
May 08, 2015 at 10:56 AM
agelessphotog
Offline
Details
p.4 #3The 135/2 DC Thread
fetopher wrote:
thegame81 wrotereplaced a 200 f2 with this and so far I'm loving it.
I'd be curious about this as well. I've had the 135DC for a few years and I love it, but just a week ago got the 200mm f2. To me, the 200mm f2 is in a league of its own. I probably won't sell my 135DC since I like having different focal lengths, but I can't see myself using it nearly as much as the 200mm f2.


Is there really that much of a difference? Is it just sharper? to me the bokeh looks better on the 135 DC. Don't get me wrong the 200 looks amazing to me, but for 4x the price, no way. I doubt my clients would see much of a difference. I know the 200 has less CA and better AF, but the AF is fine for me. I don't use the camera in really low lit areas. I really did not want a lens as big and heavy as the 200, and the price was out of my price range. So far the extra CA seems easy to fix in post.
May 08, 2015 at 11:06 AM
cbbr
Offline
Details
p.4 #4The 135/2 DC Thread
Along the same line if any of you own both - 105DC vs 135DC - Much difference?
May 08, 2015 at 11:48 AM
fetopher
Offline
Details
p.4 #5The 135/2 DC Thread
agelessphotog wrote:
Is there really that much of a difference? Is it just sharper? to me the bokeh looks better on the 135 DC. Don't get me wrong the 200 looks amazing to me, but for 4x the price, no way. I doubt my clients would see much of a difference. I know the 200 has less CA and better AF, but the AF is fine for me. I don't use the camera in really low lit areas. I really did not want a lens as big and heavy as the 200, and the price was out of my price range. So
...Show more →

I've only played with the 200mm f2 a little, but so far the difference is pretty substantial. Sharpness, AF accuracy and AF speed are the three huge differences. CA as well, but less of an issue because it's fixable in post.

I'm sure it's a subjective thing, but to me, the 200mm "feels" like a different class of lens. The 135 is no slouch, and I still love it, but the 200mm is my new love.

Here are my best couple shots with the 135mm and my first couple "test" shots with the 200mm. Maybe it's hard to see a difference at web sizes, but full size, there's a huge difference in sharpness.







135mm







135mm







200mm







200mm

May 08, 2015 at 12:18 PM
agelessphotog
Offline
Details
p.4 #6The 135/2 DC Thread
fetopher wrote:
agelessphotog wroteIs there really that much of a difference? Is it just sharper? to me the bokeh looks better on the 135 DC. Don't get me wrong the 200 looks amazing to me, but for 4x the price, no way. I doubt my clients would see much of a difference. I know the 200 has less CA and better AF, but the AF is fine for me. I don't use the camera in really low lit areas. I really did not want a lens as big and heavy as the 200, and the price was out of my price range. So far the extra CA seems easy to fix in post.
I've only played with the 200mm f2 a little, but so far the difference is pretty substantial. Sharpness, AF accuracy and AF speed are the three huge differences. CA as well, but less of an issue because it's fixable in post.

I'm sure it's a subjective thing, but to me, the 200mm "feels" like a different class of lens. The 135 is no slouch, and I still love it, but the 200mm is my new love.

Here are my best couple shots with the 135mm and my first couple "test" shots with the 200mm. Maybe it's hard to see a difference
...Show more →

I see the better sharpness of the 200 F2. But I think I like the skin tones better on the 135 F2 DC. I'm sure there are some people who might disagree. I could also see where fast moving children the 200's AF would help. I definitely like the sharpness better on the 200 F2 though. To me the skin tones look more natural on the 135.
May 08, 2015 at 12:22 PM
agelessphotog
Offline
Details
p.4 #7The 135/2 DC Thread
fetopher wrote:
Sharpness isn't everything, granted, but here's a 100% crop of two of the images above for comparison's sake. Same amount of post sharpening applied to both. Roughly the same edit for both.

As is the case with many of my 135mm shots, there's a slight softness at the focal point (eyes), but not so much I can't live with it. On the 200mm shot, you can see my little guy has more water in his left eye than his right, and count his eyelashes while you're at it.

Again, I'm not trying to disparage the 135mm in the least. I truly love
...Show more →

No need to get off the subject this is good conversation. I know the 200 is sharper, no doubt. But I do believe that my 135 copy is superior to yours. Mine looked just like yours until I sent it into nikon to have them tune it for a D750, the camera I use. I was almost ready to sell it, I hated the lens, I got it back and now it's probably my favorite lens. Here is an original, then a 100% crop. To me the 135 DC just has better skin tones, I know that's completely opinion only though. I would purchase an F200 F2 if it was a little smaller / lighter to go along with my collection. My photo was shot at F2.8 though, probably giving it a little of an advantage. But I can tell you shooting wide open, after it getting fine tuned by Nikon it definitely looks sharper than your 135 copy.

test2 by agelessphotog, on Flickr

test (8) by agelessphotog, on Flickr

May 08, 2015 at 01:15 PM
rw11
Offline
Details
p.4 #8The 135/2 DC Thread
mshi wrote:
I had only one money shot with the lens.

https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1285/4684529928_43fb76bae0.jpg



I esp. like this one because it is not a portrait. It shows that this lens can do other subjects well too.


I'm a fan of the DC lenses but don't own one.
I swear if they ever update it, I'll buy one. And if I knew they would never update it, I'd buy an old one.
May 08, 2015 at 01:21 PM
Kerry Pierce
Offline
Details
p.4 #9The 135/2 DC Thread
cbbr wrote:
Along the same line if any of you own both - 105DC vs 135DC - Much difference?


I've had both for years. It's been a while since I've used both. I got the 200 f/2 a few months ago and I've been using that more than the DC lenses. But, I can't recall there being much difference in the DC lenses. They both render lovely images. The only issue is getting them to do precise focus on your camera, wide open.

I can't bring myself to part with either of them, so I suspect they'll be in my bag until the end of days. They are much easier to handle, especially for long periods of time, than the 200 f/2.

Kerry
May 08, 2015 at 01:42 PM
mshi
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #10The 135/2 DC Thread
rw11 wrote:
mshi wroteI had only one money shot with the lens.

https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1285/4684529928_43fb76bae0.jpg
I esp. like this one because it is not a portrait. It shows that this lens can do other subjects well too.

I'm a fan of the DC lenses but don't own one.
I swear if they ever update it, I'll buy one. And if I knew they would never update it, I'd buy an old one.


They were designed for long gone film era. Today retouchers can get whatever skintones you fancy in post and I don't think they would bother to update them with DC features.
May 08, 2015 at 01:43 PM
Kerry Pierce
Offline
Details
p.4 #11The 135/2 DC Thread
fetopher wrote:
Sharpness isn't everything, granted, but here's a 100% crop of two of the images above for comparison's sake. Same amount of post sharpening applied to both. Roughly the same edit for both.

As is the case with many of my 135mm shots, there's a slight softness at the focal point (eyes), but not so much I can't live with it. On the 200mm shot, you can see my little guy has more water in his left eye than his right, and count his eyelashes while you're at it.

Again, I'm not trying to disparage the 135mm in the least. I truly love
...Show more →

IMO, the 135 should be able to come much closer to the 200 f/2 than what your shot exhibits. As you say, it's often not detrimental, but my guess is that it needs some serious micro AF adjustment to your camera(s). FWIW, it is harder for me to get precise focus with the 135 than the 200 f/2, but after AF adjustment, my 135 doesn't do too bad.

agelessphotog wrote:
No need to get off the subject this is good conversation. I know the 200 is sharper, no doubt. But I do believe that my 135 copy is superior to yours. Mine looked just like yours until I sent it into nikon to have them tune it for a D750, the camera I use. I was almost ready to sell it, I hated the lens, I got it back and now it's probably my favorite lens. Here is an original, then a 100% crop. To me the 135 DC just has better skin tones, I know that's completely opinion only
...Show more →

Yes, the 200 f/2 is a beast, particularly in comparison to the 105 or 135 DC lenses. IMO, the 200 f/2 has faster, more accurate AF and it's sharper than either of my DC lenses. Otherwise, the bokeh and rendering are about the same to me. I've only had the 200 for a few months, maybe a year now, I don't recall for certain. It's a magical lens to use, just because of the speed and accuracy of the focus. But, at the end of the day, when I'm looking at the photos, they often look fairly similar to my DC lenses and even my 85 f/1.4d.

When you sent your 135 back, did you send the camera with it?

thanks
Kerry
May 08, 2015 at 02:00 PM
Hide Takahashi
Offline
Details
p.4 #12The 135/2 DC Thread
I had to send both my D800 and the 135 to Nikon service center because I got a dark viewfinder when I attached my lens on my camera and I didn't know which one had a problem. It turned out that my camera had a bent aperture lever and they fixed it. Also they cleaned my lens and adjusted the lens. I don't know what they adjusted but when both came back, the lens produced a sharp image and AF was spot on. The image below was shot @ F2.0 and I focused at her eyes. The local areas are a little soft but that's expected. With more practice, I should be able to get a better image.






May 08, 2015 at 03:30 PM
thegame81
Offline
Details
p.4 #13The 135/2 DC Thread
fetopher wrote:
I'd be curious about this as well. I've had the 135DC for a few years and I love it, but just a week ago got the 200mm f2. To me, the 200mm f2 is in a league of its own. I probably won't sell my 135DC since I like having different focal lengths, but I can't see myself using it nearly as much as the 200mm f2.


The 200 f2 is the best I've used for sharpness and the bokeh. The subject isolation is insane. But I used it less because of the size and weight. For example I wouldn't have gotten this shot of my son during the evening walk because I wouldn't have carried my 200 with me

The 135 is considerably less sharp (which i think works for portraits), the CA can be a little annoying but is easily fixable in post in most cases. The rendering is different and I like it. There is no comparison in AF. But the AF on this lens is adequate for shooting portraits.

The following scenario may not apply to everyone. I used to use the 200 f2 with 2x for birds too. It was still sharp wide open at 400 f4. But after picking up a 400 2.8 I just didn't see the need for keeping the 200 just for portraits. The 135 DC for me almost did what the 200 did for people shots at a fraction of the price, weight and size. If you're a professional and want the absolute best equipment for people photographs outdoors, then there is nothing better than the 200 f2.
May 09, 2015 at 06:48 AM
rw11
Offline
Details
p.4 #14The 135/2 DC Thread
the older the subject, the less sharpness you want...
May 09, 2015 at 12:33 PM
agelessphotog
Offline
Details
p.4 #15The 135/2 DC Thread
Kerry Pierce wrote:
fetopher wroteSharpness isn't everything, granted, but here's a 100% crop of two of the images above for comparison's sake. Same amount of post sharpening applied to both. Roughly the same edit for both.

As is the case with many of my 135mm shots, there's a slight softness at the focal point (eyes), but not so much I can't live with it. On the 200mm shot, you can see my little guy has more water in his left eye than his right, and count his eyelashes while you're at it.

Again, I'm not trying to disparage the 135mm in the least. I truly love its rendering. The topic of the difference between the 135mm and 200mm is the only thing I'm trying to show, as it relates to sharpness. With this I'll hop off the 200mm sidetrack, although I'd still love to hear why hegame81 switched from 200mm f/2 to 135mmDC.
IMO, the 135 should be able to come much closer to the 200 f/2 than what your shot exhibits. As you say, it's often not detrimental, but my guess is that it needs some serious micro AF adjustment to your camera(s). FWIW, it is harder for me to get precise focus with the 135 than the 200 f/2, but after AF adjustment, my 135 doesn't do too bad.

agelessphotog wroteNo need to get off the subject this is good conversation. I know the 200 is sharper, no doubt. But I do believe that my 135 copy is superior to yours. Mine looked just like yours until I sent it into nikon to have them tune it for a D750, the camera I use. I was almost ready to sell it, I hated the lens, I got it back and now it's probably my favorite lens. Here is an original, then a 100% crop. To me the 135 DC just has better skin tones, I know that's completely opinion only though. I would purchase an F200 F2 if it was a little smaller / lighter to go along with my collection. My photo was shot at F2.8 though, probably giving it a little of an advantage. But I can tell you shooting wide open, after it getting fine tuned by Nikon it definitely looks sharper than your 135 copy.
Yes, the 200 f/2 is a beast, particularly in comparison to the 105 or 135 DC lenses. IMO, the 200 f/2 has faster, more accurate AF and it's sharper than either of
...Show more →

I did not send my camera back with it, I told them I had a D750 and to use one of their D750's. What ever they did, it focuses as accurate as my Nikon 1.8g lenses now. Before even micro adjust fine tune +20 didn't give me good results. It's like a whole new lens now. Even fine tume adjust +20 I still had to focus on ears to get eyes in focus, it was very annoying. Now it's SPOT ON. I focus on eyes, eyes are in focus. I hear you guys about the AF. It's not the fastest. In good lighting mine is very accurate though. And I have no doubt that when looking at the 200 F2 the images look a little better and sharper. But on a correctly calibrated 135 F2, I doubt you see much difference. Especially without having them side by side. My clients probably wouldn't know any difference. For 1/4th the price and much lighter and much smaller I will pick the 135 any day.
May 10, 2015 at 01:52 PM
Kerry Pierce
Offline
Details
p.4 #16The 135/2 DC Thread
agelessphotog wrote:
I did not send my camera back with it, I told them I had a D750 and to use one of their D750's. What ever they did, it focuses as accurate as my Nikon 1.8g lenses now. Before even micro adjust fine tune +20 didn't give me good results. It's like a whole new lens now. Even fine tume adjust +20 I still had to focus on ears to get eyes in focus, it was very annoying. Now it's SPOT ON. I focus on eyes, eyes are in focus. I hear you guys about the AF. It's not the fastest.
...Show more →

Thanks for the reply. I haven't used mine on the d810 yet, so if it goes south on the d810, it's good to know that I can send it for service and expect to have it fixed.

I agree that the clients wouldn't likely know the diff. I've often been amazed at what they will not only accept, but praise to high heaven. That's a good thing, IMO. If the clients were as picky as we can be, I'd probably never sell a photo.

Kerry
May 10, 2015 at 02:54 PM
benjikan
Offline
Details
p.4 #17The 135/2 DC Thread
All three of these shot wide open at f/2.0 for Harper's BAZAAR Magazine...







Original Post: http://www.benjaminkanarekblog.com/2014/12/24/yulia-serzhantova-70s-hippie-glam-harpers-bazaar-benjamin-kanarek/
May 10, 2015 at 03:19 PM
whatpoem
Offline
Details
p.4 #18The 135/2 DC Thread
May 11, 2015 at 06:47 AM
Frogfish
Offline
Details
p.4 #19The 135/2 DC Thread
fetopher wrote:
Sharpness isn't everything, granted, but here's a 100% crop of two of the images above for comparison's sake. Same amount of post sharpening applied to both. Roughly the same edit for both.

As is the case with many of my 135mm shots, there's a slight softness at the focal point (eyes), but not so much I can't live with it. On the 200mm shot, you can see my little guy has more water in his left eye than his right, and count his eyelashes while you're at it.

Again, I'm not trying to disparage the 135mm in the least. I truly love
...Show more →

Sorry but your focus is clearly off (in both shots I think) maybe this comes down to the AF if you don't use MF. The 135/2 DC is extremely sharp and for portraits you simply don't need anything sharper.

My daughter .. and at 100% (posted earlier in this thread so sorry for the repetition) :



100% crop

May 13, 2015 at 08:04 AM
Jason_Brook
Offline
Details
p.4 #20The 135/2 DC Thread
Guess who just bought a 135 DC again??

The run with the Zeiss was fun, but I can't handle manually focusing at that small of a DoF.
May 18, 2015 at 06:46 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister