cyra wrote:
Chris and Patrick I appreciated your bird images and would love to see more and hear about how the lens works for you. I am on the fence buying one for wildlife (mainly birds).
If the lens works ok I would also consider switching from v1 to v3.
Are you content with the lens?
I am delighted with the 70-300CX and very happy I bought it. The zoom is a little stiff which may contribute to my frequent failure to get optimal framing - either I cut wings off because I didn't zoom out or I didn't use the full 300mm because I forgot to zoom back in after widening the FOV to avoid that issue. I am very frustrated that the tripod mount is still not available here though - and when it is I hope to find a suitable L bracket to facilitate portrait shots. The VR is excellent and with the lack of vibration from the camera one can use surprisingly slow shutter speeds - but it is hard to get perfect framing if zooming in very tight since the framing recorded may have changed due the VR. That is mainly why I want the tripod mount asap. The biggest advantages over my 300mm F4 + FT1 are the ability to zoom out and native focus modes. VR certainly adds to the versatility but is not top of my list because for BIF it is less relevant and for static birds there is the option of a tripod or monopd. IQ for the CX zoom is certainly as good as the 300/FT1 combo IMHO, possibly better but I didn't shoot them side by side and now can't having sold the 300 F4.
I bought the 70-300CX before I sold one of my V2s to buy a V3 even though the V3 was available first. I think that was a good decision - the lens is much better value than upgrading the body. I would actually encourage you to consider a used V2 - I started with a V1 and was very disappointed with the look of the V2 and the change of battery until I bought a used one and found the usability so dramatically improved I sold my other V1 and bought a second V2. The V3 has some nice features and more controls but I would be happier if the grip and VF were integrated. The V2 still looks a bit clunky to me (and so does the V3 with VF and grip) but both feel right in the hand and what matters is how the photos look not how the camera looks.
I wouldn't be too hasty to part with your V1 if you do get a V2 or V3 though as I find it well worth having a second body with a shorter lens since 189mm effective can be pretty limiting. Shooting kite boarders it was definitely helpful to have the 30-110 on a second body when they got close to the beach.
I hope Chris weighs in here with his critical assessment and comparisons with some serious glass on a D800E but for me it boils down to "the best camera is the one you have with you" - I can take the V2 or V3 and the 70-300 on a walk with my wife with barely a second thought, or, if out photographing more seriously add it to my D800 kit to extend my reach.
Best
Patrick