I went with a new copy of the Nikon. I wanted consistency with color after trying 3rd party options, and also the warranty which in hindsight isn't a big issue. I think a used 14-24 is probably a good deal because I think many people end up not needing that wide and sell them for lack of use. Going wider than 20mm on a FX body takes a certain skill set to not end up with crap. It takes time to learn to use a UWA, just like it does with a super tele.
The Sigma wasn't out when I made the purchase, the Tamron 15-30 was and I checked it out. As some reviews note, it's more like 16mm and that 2mm is a big difference in a UWA.
F/2.8 is really cool with a UWA, especially with a short minimum focus distance. It's also nice in low light as the 14-24 is pretty sharp wide open for larger subjects. I'm a little biased against 3rd party options, but if you try the Sigma, get the dock too and spend the proper time to really dial in the lens with it. When I had the 120-300, it made a huge difference. I wouldn't expect as much with the 14-24, but one would want to get the most out of the lens. Nikon would do well if they choose to release a dock too.