aut0maticdan wrote:
Great start to the thread. These photos really pop.
Do any of you own the 14-24 in addition to this lens? I've always used having the zoom as an excuse not to look too much at the 24/1.4. I tend to shoot at 14 or 21-24 most often. Can you help rationalize the purchase of this fine lens? haha
I have both, and didn't need to justify having both because each lens is used for distinct purposes: 14-24 is phenomenal for interior shoots and 24 1.4 is excellent in low light. Horses for courses....
When I got this lens I was shooting primarily with a d7000. I wanted something wider and faster, and I new I would be moving up to FX eventually. On the d7000 it became my favorite lens. On my d800e though I felt it left something to be desired when shooting at f1.4. I did some research and found others have felt and noticed the same thing. So for a while unless I was going to be blurring the background or was in extreme low light I usually ended up covering the 24mm FL with the 14-24 or 24-70 depending if I was planning to shot wide or normal. In the last few months though I realized that the magic of this lens comes back rather nicely at f2 and above. I did some more research and found others have found this too.
I am not sure I will put it back in my top 5 lens list yet, but it's definitely seeing a nice amount of uses again at f2 and above. It's a great lenses, it's only weakens is really it's f1.4 sharpness on FX.
aut0maticdan wrote:
Do any of you own the 14-24 in addition to this lens? I've always used having the zoom as an excuse not to look too much at the 24/1.4. I tend to shoot at 14 or 21-24 most often. Can you help rationalize the purchase of this fine lens? haha
I have both and use them for different purposes. The 24mm is a great walkabout lens, especially in the city, that is quite descrete compared to the 14-24. The 24 can take a polariser and ND grads easily and is much less prone to flare. Also, using wide apertures is an advantage for the 24mm for those narrow DOF shots.
The 14-24 is a more specialised lens and I mainly only put it on when I want under 20mm. Being larger, heavier and has an exposed bulbous front element, it generally stays in the backpack until I need under about 20mm.
However, there is no doubting the excellent IQ 14-24 and the 24 f1.4G is more of an extravagance than a necessity.
DWOfPaul wrote:
It's a great lenses, it's only weakens is really it's f1.4 sharpness on FX.
must be a pixel density issue. this lens lives at f1.4 on my d700. sharpest f1.4 prime i've used wide open, tied with a sigma 85. it really leads to me being a bad photographer... i need to stop down more, but it performs so well wide open!
static808 wrote: DWOfPaul wroteIt's a great lenses, it's only weakens is really it's f1.4 sharpness on FX.must be a pixel density issue. this lens lives at f1.4 on my d700. sharpest f1.4 prime i've used wide open, tied with a sigma 85. it really leads to me being a bad photographer... i need to stop down more, but it performs so well wide open!
Mine was somewhere in between these two statements. On my D800 it was definitely sharp wide open, although not nearly as good as my Sigma 85. I did think it was sharper than my Nikon 35 1.4 though.
To me it was all moot. I had no problem shooting them wide open for client work.
I just traded away my 20/1.8 and 28/1.8 for this lens, more out of curiosity than any sort of need. Really impressed with what I see so far, the color, sharpness and contrast are fantastic. I thought the Canon 24L II was exceptional, could this lens actually be better?
I'd love to see more of what this lens can do from forum members!
I regret selling this lens. I loved it on my D700 but I struggled with focus on my D800. I think my 800 might have had focus issues since I had more misses with all my lenses but this one became very frustrating. I loved it when I got good focus but it was becoming a rare event.
Now that I have the D810 and I almost never have a miss focus I really wish I still had this lens
I also had the 14-24 and to me its not a either or situation. THey are used for different things
I think the 85mm f1.4 and Sigma 35mm and 50mm f1.4 Art's have spoiled me though. This past weekend I tried the 24mm at f1.4 again and ended up switching to the 35mm Art.