hesb wrote:
Hi there,
Has anyone been able to compare this 58mm nikon with the voigtlander 50mm 1.2 Nokton. The latter's rendering is close to the sigma Art, but even smoother. I wonder how it compares with the nikon.
With the Z6 and all the adapters, it is much easier to compare different lenses nowadays.
The fact is that I own a sony A7R2 with the voigtlander, but I sometimes miss the af, and sometimes I'm tempted to go buy a Z6 with a 58mm 1.4 instead...
I've owned both, though I used the Nokton on Leica bodies. They're totally different lenses; frankly, I don't think you can directly compare the 58/1.4 against any other optic. I liked the Nokton just fine, but I love the 58/1.4. It's the reason I shoot with a Nikon body.
The Nokton is the sharper and more modern optic with a touch of old school charm. It's not much of a "character" lens, whereas the Neo-Noct is all about character. Bokeh from both is super buttery, but the fall off of the Neo-Noct is absolutely lovely. The Nokton is the better all-around, more versatile lens if you don't need AF. The Nokton is better built with its all-metal construction and very jewel like, whereas the Nikon makes use of high-quality plastics.
If I had a Z6, I'd go with the 58/1.4 because I prefer a character lens and the added benefit of AF is nice to have.