I'll include my two cents. The Siggy is sharper without question, while the N58 renders significantly better; It's a rather easy read for these aged eyes. They are two distinct lenses each of which emphasizes a different need/want. It is rather silly, IMO, to draw comparisons, as it's apples vis-a-vis oranges. Financial considerations aside, I personally emphasis sharpness (as I visually see it) and would opt (and have indeed purchased) the Siggy. If at some future date my priority or need changes, so too will my choice of lenses.....or, I may add the N58 without selling the Siggy.