Jason_Brook wrote:
Yeah, this is definitely a lens that can be a very expensive mistake for people not willing to work with it. In many circumstances, the 50/1.8G goes toe to toe. Push the limits and there's a clear winner.
For example; see below. If it weren't for the EXIF, I doubt many would be able to tell.
This post right here, is why I sold the 58. Right now I have the 50 1.8G. But two things that bother me about the 1.8. It needs some contrast. Not bad, just not as much as I want. But mostly, it doesn't give me BIG OL giant flare the way I want. But for 90% of shooters, the 50 1.8G is all you need. It looks like a total turd, feels like a turd, but it's really pretty outstanding. When you own a business, it's nearly impossible to justify $1700 vs $200.
That aside, I've said this like ten times now: If I was prosumer, or hobbyist, the 58 would be the only lens I owned. I'd work slow, overshoot, and enjoy the soft dreaminess.