'but it is interesting to see that for a typical shot'
Focus distance is much closer here and DoF much thinner than a 'typical' image, I'd have thought.
Rather than attempt picks where many factors enter the picture, I like to look at what I prefer in these kinds of comparos then work out why...and #2 is a clear winner because of the little things, the tone range of the more flaxen hair, even the blotchiness on her arm.
These are due to higher and smoother colour contrast (a characteristic Mike Johnston calls 'microcolor' - the variation of colour with contrast) and as a result, a greater sense of reality due to the perception of better shaping, less image 'flatness'. #2 has greater tonal sublety also. How much is lens, how much is format I don't know, have never used any of these.
And yes, it is fun and thanks very much for doing it.