So, this guy came in today - I've got it for a week. I figure I'd use this thread to post some impressions through the week as I use it.
First impressions: It's built just like the other f/0.95 Noktons - extremely solid and very, very dense. It's a little smaller than the 17.5, but a little heavier too. It is all glass and metal. http://www.jordansteele.com/2013/cv42.jpg
Relatively sharp at f/0.95, though with that light haze from spherical aberration...at f/1.4 the haze is gone (except at really close focus distances) and it's even sharper. This focuses to 0.23m, so REALLY close, and SA is very pronounced at f/0.95 near MFD (which can be cool for a look, but not good for resolution). Transmission/sensor efficiency in conjunction with the mount isn't fully linear at f/0.95, so f/1.4 to f/0.95 seems to affect exposure by about 2/3 stop rather than a little more than one stop, though depth of field and background blur go that full stop+. This should be somewhat fun!
Note that the grain you may see in the images is from the VSCO presets - I really like the look they give, but it does add a little grain.
And at f/1.4 (you can see it gets quite sharp by f/1.4):
Really sharp at f/2.8:
100% crop (f/2.8):
The spherical aberration that gives it a light glow at most focus distances wide open is massively exacerbated at close focus...it also starts to obliterate detail, such that at f/0.95 and close up it's rather soft.
Very cool lens and some great photos to go with it. Looks like it gets significantly better contrast and color saturation at f/1.4 too - almost an entirely different lens! You get dreamy and crystal clear in the same lens. Looks like a great deal though, congratulations!
I can't help but feel that for that $1000+ it's demanding, I'd rather have a fast 85 on FF.
I had to say it, because even with the obvious size differential, it seems like a much more logical setup.
No point in arguing over "but I like the increased DoF with the smaller format" or "but I am not shooting it wide open" or something, because if those things didn't matter, you don't need a .95 lens....
Although, this is currently one of the only games in town for fast short teles on M43, right? Outside of the excellent Oly 45/1.8...
Physics is physics...you want this level of subject separation, you're going to need larger glass...but saying "I'd rather have a fast 85 on FF" misses the point. Sure, if you shoot both FF and Micro 4/3, and you want a shallow DOF portrait, it makes a lot more sense to pick up an 85/1.8 for your FF camera (except where you're shooting static stuff on an OM-D, where you can shoot near base ISO at night with this thing, vs. ISO 1600-3200 on an 85/1.8 on full frame).
However, if I'm a Micro 4/3 shooter, and I want to pick up a portrait lens for shallow DOF shooting, which makes more sense: Spending $999 for this lens, or buying a 6D and an 85/1.8 for $2,000...especially because now you need to carry around a much larger body AND the lens just to be able to get this look, in addition to your normal m4/3 kit.
This isn't a lens for people who supplement their FF kits with mirrorless. This is a lens for mirrorless shooters, period...and there are quite a lot of us. However, I will not get this lens for myself, as I have essentially the same capability currently on my Fuji system with my Hexanon 57/1.2. I will probably pick up the Fuji 56/1.2 when it's released, though the PL 42.5/1.2 looks like it'll be really good too.
Can't say I'm terribly impressed, honestly. I can accept softness as a fact of ultra-large apertures but it has to be nice softness ... especially on that statue's rock the Voigt's softness makes it look almost like camera shake even though it's (probably) not.
When does it start to get ugly at large apertures / close distance? It would seem it's a lot better at WO / F1.2 at medium-long distances...?
And... Did you have the 25/0.95 also? At medium-long distances and F2.0-2.8 it's ridiculously sharp, so I just wondered if the longer sibling had the same traits.
p.1 #10Voigtlander 42.5mm f/0.95 First Impressions
I found it to be pretty good from about 3 to 10 feet. Outside of that range wide open, the spherical aberration starts to get really strong. Stopping down to f/1.4 removes the glow for the most part at all focus distances except for really really close, which takes until about f/2 to become really crisp. Beyond f/2 it's crazy sharp. I haven't shot with the 25/0.95, but I've used (and reviewed) the 17.5.
p.1 #11Voigtlander 42.5mm f/0.95 First Impressions
The bigger issue to me is the odd "normal" perspective with fairly shallow DoF, it LOOKS like a cropped 50ish mm. This, ultimately, is the biggest thing keeping me from cropped lens "systems".
I just can't see spending $999 for this. I could wind up with another M4/3 camera, but this would not find its way onto it lol.
p.1 #12Voigtlander 42.5mm f/0.95 First Impressions
That comment makes no sense at all. There is no 'normal perspective.' This is an imagined thing that has come up a few times recently....perspective is dependent on the distance from subject and has NOTHING to do with focal length or format. These photos were taken with the same subject distance as any other 85mm equivalent lens would be for the same framing which means identical perspective.
Now, a lot of my sample images are taken closer than many FF 85mm lenses can focus, since they typically can only go down to about 0.9m, while this goes all the way to 0.23m...that may be what you're seeing, but it is not a '50mm perspective.'
p.1 #16Voigtlander 42.5mm f/0.95 First Impressions
buggz2k wrote:
I just wish CV made these lenses in Fuji XF mount.
I never bought into the micro 4/3's thing...
APS-C is as small as I wish to go, thanks.
The 17.5 and 25 don't cover APS-C. The 42.5 may however. There is an available (but flimsy) m43 to NEX adapter which has been used to try these out.