p.21 #3Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
I almost tripped over a 200-400L mounted on a 1DX yesterday. I was at the Wimbledon Tennis and I assume it was a Getty photographer, had just left it lying on the grass where people were walking. I asked him if I could have a look and he kindly obliged. I didn't see any others there, only 300 and 400 2.8's but I assume there must have been several other shooters with 200-400's.
p.21 #6Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
pcho wrote:
Just wondered if anyone has replaced the 200-400mm lens plate with the ones from really right stuff?
Perry
Yes. I wasn't a big fan of the original Canon design. The RRS foot is much better for quick mounting on a tripod, but less comfortable to carry by hand. The RRS foot could be improved with padding to make it easier to carry.
p.21 #7Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
dhachey wrote: pcho wroteJust wondered if anyone has replaced the 200-400mm lens plate with the ones from really right stuff?
PerryYes. I wasn't a big fan of the original Canon design. The RRS foot is much better for quick mounting on a tripod, but less comfortable to carry by hand. The RRS foot could be improved with padding to make it easier to carry.
p.21 #8Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
I have had the Really Right Stuff replacement lens foot on my 200-400 since I first recieved it. The extent of the plate at the bottom allows for easy balance on a ball head or Wimberley with either the lens on its own, or with the 2X extender mounted, and also with either a 5D3 or a 1DX as the body. A pad might be nice for hand carry, but the rounded edges of the RRS plate are fine for me with my bare hand. If you were to use the Canon foot and add on a multi purpose plate, the lens would be a little higher than it is with the RRS dedicated foot, and I like that lower lens mounted height. The pad that is on the Canon foot to help a little with hand holding is kind of far forward, so the balance of the lens when hand held at the place where the pad is does not work out too well.
The only negative of the RRS foot I have noted is one that would be hard to fix. When you hand carry with the foot, the balance is such that you naturally would like to hold the foot a little further toward the rear of the lens, but the connecting support metal of the RRS foot is "in the way", so the lens balance is nose heavy. But to change that would require a different design with more metal further to the rear, and that would increase the weight and perhaps lower the stiffness.
p.21 #9Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Roland W wrote:
I have had the Really Right Stuff replacement lens foot on my 200-400 since I first recieved it. The extent of the plate at the bottom allows for easy balance on a ball head or Wimberley with either the lens on its own, or with the 2X extender mounted, and also with either a 5D3 or a 1DX as the body. A pad might be nice for hand carry, but the rounded edges of the RRS plate are fine for me with my bare hand. If you were to use the Canon foot and add on a multi purpose plate, the lens would be a little higher than it is with the RRS dedicated foot, and I like that lower lens mounted height. The pad that is on the Canon foot to help a little with hand holding is kind of far forward, so the balance of the lens when hand held at the place where the pad is does not work out too well.
The only negative of the RRS foot I have noted is one that would be hard to fix. When you hand carry with the foot, the balance is such that you naturally would like to hold the foot a little further toward the rear of the lens, but the connecting support metal of the RRS foot is "in the way", so the lens balance is nose heavy. But to change that would require a different design with more metal further to the rear, and that would increase the weight and perhaps lower the stiffness. ...Show more →
Thanks Roland. I can't wait to get both my RRS and 200-400 next week
In short its smaller than i thought it would be and sharper.
Particularly when using the internal and external 1.4 attached.
Balance feels good.
Zooming while hand holding will need some practice.
I found setting the zoom to around 280 gave enough wrist movement given the long throw from 200-400 in either direction and worked quite well fir my first try.
I was using a Mk3 as my 1Dx's are in for the recall.
Overall i think half my lens collection is now unemployed and im very glad i never bought the new 500 to replace my Mk1.
When travelling(which i do a LOT of) and hauling lenses i think this lens will be the answer to many peoples desires.
p.21 #14Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
dehowie wrote:
Had my first shots with mine yesterday.
In short its smaller than i thought it would be and sharper.
Particularly when using the internal and external 1.4 attached.
Balance feels good.
Zooming while hand holding will need some practice.
I found setting the zoom to around 280 gave enough wrist movement given the long throw from 200-400 in either direction and worked quite well fir my first try.
I was using a Mk3 as my 1Dx's are in for the recall.
Overall i think half my lens collection is now unemployed and im very glad i never bought the new 500 to replace my Mk1.
When travelling(which i do a LOT of) and hauling lenses i think this lens will be the answer to many peoples desires. ...Show more →
Thanks for update dehowie. That is one of the reasons why I did not update my verion 1 super lenses as usually travel by car to locations and not haul the super lenses for long distances. The 200-400 will be the so call portable lens. Looking forward to collect mine tomorrow
p.21 #16Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Doctorbird wrote:
Sigh!! Wish it were lighter.
Db
Same here.....I could justify its purchase much more readily if it were 3 kg.
It's a very nice lens, no two ways about it, but frankly, the only feature which is likely to give me some effectiveness gain is the practically instantaneous "toggle" from 400mm to 560mm and back.
p.21 #18Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
PetKal wrote: Doctorbird wroteSigh!! Wish it were lighter.
DbSame here.....I could justify its purchase much more readily if it were 3 kg.
It's a very nice lens, no two ways about it, but frankly, the only feature which is likely to give me some effectiveness gain is the practically instantaneous "toggle" from 400mm to 560mm and back.
Pekal, isn't that the biggest advantage and what is was designed for. Sure there are compromises in sharpness but i dont think it will worry me. That is why i kept my series 1 super lenses and waited for this. It covers me for 200 right up to 560mm.
p.21 #19Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
pcho wrote: PetKal wroteDoctorbird wroteSigh!! Wish it were lighter.
DbSame here.....I could justify its purchase much more readily if it were 3 kg.
It's a very nice lens, no two ways about it, but frankly, the only feature which is likely to give me some effectiveness gain is the practically instantaneous "toggle" from 400mm to 560mm and back.Pekal, isn't that the biggest advantage and what is was designed for. Sure there are compromises in sharpness but i dont think it will worry me. That is why i kept my series 1 super lenses and waited for this. It covers me for 200 right up to 560mm.
Perry
To put it another way: At the weight that it is, IF it were spec'd at f/2.8, I'd be more inclined to think about replacing my 400 II with it. Imagine, 200 mm f/2.8 to possibly 1120 mm f/8!! I'd prefer that trade off.
p.21 #20Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Renier1 wrote:
Hi Geoff
I just now received an email that my lens is shipped from B&H. I ordered on 20th May. So it looks like there is movement.
Renier
Thanks for the update. I ordered mine from B&H on May 24th, so maybe there is hope to get it in time to get some reasonable usage out of it before the snow flies.