p.2 #1Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
rscheffler wrote: rscheffler wroteOne other observation after years of 400/2.8 IS v.1 use: the tripod collar of the 200-400 is so smooth and effortless to rotate (with the usual 90 degree detents). I love it! Over the years I've had lots of problems with the screws retaining the ball bearings in the 400/2.8's collar working loose and jamming the collar (thread locker has helped), but it just was never super smooth. It's why there's a piece of black tape where the 400's ID plate should be in my photo, to allow quick in-the-field access to the BBs in order to tighten them back down again.KINGOFKNGS wroteRon, this is more a 400/2.8 question than the 200-400, but I've used a 600/4 IS for about 2.5 years now and just recently acquired the 400/2.8 IS about a month ago (both are Ver 1). I noticed that the collar on the 400/2.8 is quite a bit more difficult to rotate. It's smooth, there's just more resistance. Does this match your experience?
RyanI find the 600 more difficult to rotate than my copy of the 400.
From my understanding based on some research into this a few years ago on the Sportsshooter.com forum, there are two versions of the 400 IS v.1 tripod collar. It seems, IIRC, the earlier version, until maybe around 2005, which I have, has a design based on ball bearings supporting the rotation while the newer version uses some kind of low-friction pads (which is also what's used by the 600). If you have the BB version and it's tight, you might want to take off the lens ID cover and have a look at the retaining screw for each BB. If one has worked loose, it pushes up against the inside of the collar and makes rotation quite difficult. The problem here is that it will eventually jam and excessive force will break the BB package, releasing a lot of small metal bits to jam up the other BBs. This happened to me once, before I knew how to service it, and Canon's repair process is to replace the entire collar. I think it cost me around $400. But self-servicing is easy. Remove the ID cover's four tiny screws, which reveals a large opening. As you rotate the collar, you'll be able to inspect each BB. I think there are six in total. If you find a loose screw, tighten it down, though I would recommend some thread lock fluid as well. Before I used thread lock, I was tightening the screws every few months or so, but with thread lock it hasn't been an issue. If you remove the ID cover and it looks different, then you have the newer version and there really isn't anything that can be adjusted, from my understanding. Years ago at a CPS event, I had them look at my 600's tripod collar... they took it all apart but really weren't able to improve anything with it. Its tightness really seems to depend on whether or not I give a slight amount of lift at the front of the lens - if I do, it rotates more smoothly.
Thanks Ron, my 600 is a UN date code and my 400 is a UR date code, I think, but it may be older. I'll check out the ball bearings on the 400 tomorrow. Thanks for the advice!
One of the guys there had a UR lens and it had the BB-less collar design, which in hindsight kind of makes sense because IIRC, when the lens first came out, a lot of people complained about how difficult it was to rotate. If you have the BB-less design, I guess you could have Canon replace it with the newer style, though it will cost $500-600. Or keep your left hand under the front of the lens lifting it slightly to help rotation.
p.2 #10Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
If the Sigma is focused correctly in the cute dig image there is a significant advantage to the 200-400..apart from an extra 260mm at the long end...
Thanks for posting!
p.2 #11Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Lars Johnsson wrote: tonywong88 wroteAndrewsk, which Sigma 120-300 do you have, the OS model or non-OS?I would be more interested in if it is the new S (sport line) lens or not.
p.2 #12Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
lowa2 wrote: Lars Johnsson wrotetonywong88 wroteAndrewsk, which Sigma 120-300 do you have, the OS model or non-OS?I would be more interested in if it is the new S (sport line) lens or not.It's v1 of the OS Sigma. I pm'ed him last night.
p.2 #14Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Yes but many other differences that in the end probably will affect the image or IQ. The new lens comes with these customized options.
Autofocus Motor Speed
Microfocus Adjustments
Focus Limiter Setting
Lens Firmware Updates
Optical Stabilizer Customization
Multiple Custom Settings
p.2 #15Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
Lars Johnsson wrote:
Yes but many other differences that in the end probably will affect the image or IQ. The new lens comes with these customized options.
Autofocus Motor Speed
Microfocus Adjustments
Focus Limiter Setting
Lens Firmware Updates
Optical Stabilizer Customization
Multiple Custom Settings
All of which point to the new siggy being able to get even closer to the super canon .
But hey I picked up my siggy OS a while back for a tenth of the cost of the canon . I will never be in a position to own the canon but the fact that the siggy gets even a bit close makes me a very happy chappie
Still interested in the new siggy but in truth I doubt I could justify the extra cost
One of the guys there had a UR lens and it had the BB-less collar design, which in hindsight kind of makes sense because IIRC, when the lens first came out, a lot of people complained about how difficult it was to rotate. If you have the BB-less design, I guess you could have Canon replace it with the newer style, though it will cost $500-600. Or keep your left hand under the front of the lens lifting it slightly to help rotation.
I also owned a 400/2.8 IS with the UR date code, mine didn't have the ball bearing design.Mine got pretty tight to turn and I ordered the ball bearings that the Sportsshooter article referred to and when I disassembled it, much to my surprise, no ball bearings.More like a plastic bushing, which I ended up putting a small amount of white lithium grease on, which helped fo some time.
I have been trying to decide if the new version of the Sigma would be worth exchanging my canon for. I still plan to wait for more test results but right now it doesn't look like I will make the trade . . .
p.2 #19Hands-on: EF 200-400mm f/4L IS USM Extender 1.4X
andrewsk wrote:
Hope this is ok with rscheffler. Ill tag on and make this the official thread?
First up for me i am posting some comparisons between the CANON 200-400 and the SIGMA 12-300 with the TC attached.
Sorry that I do not have a CAT. The lovely tessa will fill in for one.
SIGMA is on the LEFT and CANON on the right. Here we are at F4, ISO 400 and 400mm for both. The detail in the CANON is already evident. Working on more now.
Keith
The canon does look way better in that comparison. I wonder if the sigma is a touch front focused though?? That can make a big difference, it looks like the Canon placed the focus just a trace deeper. Which version of the Sigma 120-300? (actually not that any of this really matter to me seeing how now way I can afford the 200-400 anyway at least not now).