IS is good, but in this range, honestly, for me would be just a bonus, and not the main deciding factor. I had the tamron 28-75, and then bought a 28-70L. More than anything else, the autofocus of tamron was slow and had a hard time locking in low light. Huge improvement with the L. the tamron was fantastic when i was shooting it on a crop, and infact, I think it makes a phenomenol portrait lens on a crop with fov of 45-120mm, but on full frame, it has soft corners, esp on wide end