p.5 #2Initial NEX 7 impressions from a NEX 5N owner
wfrank wrote:
Thanks Nanh, appreciate your post! Any chance for a full scene shot of both the battery (?) and the outdoor scene on Flickr to put it in perspective?
In my case I wont (or seldom) do landscaping and therefor the midframe is the most important part and corner sharpness seem to be the main issue with the lens. I dont worry too much about the color fringing as I find it hard to spot, and when it appears - it would be easy to correct.
Main obstacle for the lens, however, is its price. At least twice that of the excellent G28 that it without any rangefinder degradation (that I can spot at least). 600€+ (with clear defects) makes other alternatives look more interesting. But I still have to find an option that suit what I am willing to pay. ...Show more →
Again don't let the heavy smog in Shanghai fool you. The lens is very contrasty.
I don't have better samples at the moment but hopefully these are enough for you to make your judgements.
Since I have got this lens I haven't used the G28 much. From my tests G28's corner isn't much stronger and in the center the overall signatures are similar. I simply prefer the wider view of the G21. The ebay price can be as low as 360 pounds the last time I checked. I bought mine a few months ago for around 430 pounds with the finder. Not exactly cheap, but much lower than the 21mm ZM lenses and not to mention Leicas. Also, a big advantage for me is the f/2.8 aperture, compared with VC and the Kit zoom. Looking around, I don't see a lot of alternatives if you want it a bit wider than 28mm.
p.5 #3Initial NEX 7 impressions from a NEX 5N owner
inglis wrote:
Nanh,
Thanks much for this helpful comparison.
Are the jpgs with the Contax G 21mm better than the raws?
You might want to link this to the Very Best Wides for Nex 5n discussion, https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1063956/13
Good suggestions. I am not sure what you mean. Why would jpgs be better than raws?
p.5 #4Initial NEX 7 impressions from a NEX 5N owner
Thanks again Nanh, appreciate you posting. Very helpful. I will hopefully be able to pick one up from a fellow FM:er - as I dont mind that corner degradation too much as the rest of its qualities are as good as they are. I normally shoot close quarters with a "centerish" subject so I think I will be fine. It will be my fourth G, I am enjoying the otherones very much - but then with 100% quality.
I dont agree that the G28 share the same corner issues, that's so far my mainstay on the 5N. Corners are not as sharp as in the center but characteristics are much more like any other high grade lens to me.