fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2011 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2011To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update

  
 
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.2 #1To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
uhoh7 wrote:
for 50s I fear the n-7 has the edge....even over the m9

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/sony_nex_7_rolling_review.shtml#m9

I'd love to see some side by sides with the zm18 gxr vs n5 vs n7.

the 5n has issues with many wides, but seemingly not all. great with the cv15 now.

Seems to love the 28cron also.

as time goes by we should get clear on which camera shines where with the M glass.

the GXR + M does look like a wonderful camera


Perhaps, but if one looks carefully at the f/1.4 and f/2.8 corner crops for the NEX, at least I get the feeling that they're a bit nervous looking compared to the M9. Definitely the NEX is better at 5.6, but it makes me wonder a bit just how the corner resolution will be with various lenses on the 7 if that's already evident with a 50mm lens. While the 7 might be the resolution champ, it will be interesting to see how close the AA-less 16MP sensor comes.

I think my preference will be the A16 with optimized micro lenses and hopefully hassle-free wide angle compatibility over the 7 and having to convert RAWs to DNG in order to run Cornerfix. What MR hasn't provided is informative corner crops of detailed scenes, such as foliage, with a less certain lens like the CV12 that he had with him.
Dec 15, 2011 at 12:38 AM
uhoh7
Offline
Details
p.2 #2To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
rscheffler wrote:
uhoh7 wrotefor 50s I fear the n-7 has the edge....even over the m9

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/sony_nex_7_rolling_review.shtml#m9

I'd love to see some side by sides with the zm18 gxr vs n5 vs n7.

the 5n has issues with many wides, but seemingly not all. great with the cv15 now.

Seems to love the 28cron also.

as time goes by we should get clear on which camera shines where with the M glass.

the GXR + M does look like a wonderful camera
Perhaps, but if one looks carefully at the f/1.4 and f/2.8 corner crops for the NEX, at least I get the feeling that they're a bit nervous looking compared to the M9. Definitely the NEX is better at 5.6, but it makes me wonder a bit just how the corner resolution will be with various lenses on the 7 if that's already evident with a 50mm lens. While the 7 might be the resolution champ, it will be interesting to see how close the AA-less 16MP sensor comes.

I think my preference will be the A16 with optimized micro lenses and
...Show more →

agreed-- I also thought the m9 had the corners untill 5.6--but was surprised he did not mention it. This is true on many lenses with he 5n also, corners do not come clean till sometimes f/8 e.g. cv 28/3.5, but centers often spectacular. I'd loke to start seeing more GXR shots---right in the nex images thread, so we can see the contrast.

I'd be surprised if the n7 does not become the king of the centers for many rf lenses, though--for what it's worth
Dec 15, 2011 at 01:38 AM
philber
Offline
Details
p.2 #3To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
If this new GXR module uses the same basic Sony 16Mp sensor as the NEX 5N (though maybe tweaked differently) and offers a Leica M interface, which is an adapter away from the NEX, does it not stand to reason that the results are going to be fairly close to the 5N's, Henryk?
So the difference will be one of electronics (the processing), the AF and the ergonomics, right? And the price of course.
Also, I think it is worth mentioning in a thread on Ricoh products that they recently bought Pentax, IIRC, highlighting their serious commitment to photography.
Dec 15, 2011 at 01:51 AM
Sosua
Offline
Details
p.2 #4To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Given the 5N still appears to be a little 'pickier' with certain lenses, the lack of an AA filter and appropriate micro lenses on the Ricoh would be the biggest wins over the 5N (and a better built and arguably more ergonomic body).

The 5N would appear to retain a better EVF however, tilt LCD and touch screen - will be interesting for sure.

The AF should not be a factor for most here
Dec 15, 2011 at 03:04 AM
philber
Offline
Details
p.2 #5To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Sosua, I don't see how the Ricoh would be any less picky, as its sensor to pupil distance needs to be the same with the same sensor and the same glass, unless they can get a significantly better version of the sensor than Sony can. The lack of an AA filter will improve the cam's ability to retrieve small detail, already a strong point from the NEX, but will, if anything, make it more susceptible to "trouble", including moiré, which can be sometimes seen with the 5N.
Dec 15, 2011 at 03:14 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #6To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Philber: Yup, what Sosua said, to the letter.

Again, for me, the GXR wins out between the two. But that is according to my taste and my shooting style, which is fairly casual nowadays I admit.

The NEX5n has some advantages, the biggest advantage in my book doesn't stem from Sony though: the Hawks' adapter. Without it Sony would be less interesting. This advantage holds true for RF Leica M glass only as it stands for now. Of course Sony has a broader range of lenses to adapt to the NEX mount.

For Ricoh there are already close focusing lenses though, one of them a perfectly fine macro/allround lens. The new zoom lens will probably focus close too. If they ever pull it together and release a 21mm equiv GR module I would ask no more. Well, a 40-ish fast pancake then. They have made a few 21's over the years for full frame so I think there might be room for one on their train of thought on APS-C.

A Sony EVF and tilt LCD would be nice to have but not a deal breaker for me as long as the rest of the camera does not suit me.

My conclusion is that for a small outfit I would not want more than three/four lenses and not bring more than two/three lenses when out and about. So, the GXR does the job with grace. If I were to spend more on glass I would prefer to have a full frame camera as my main camera. However much we debate which APS-C camera is better for M glass I think full frame sure looks a lot nicer and for a wide angle guy there is still no competition between full frame and APS-C.

As a sober alternative to an M9 and full frame the GXR is the ticket for me. The investment in a GXR, EVF and M module is slight, and will always retain its usability for me. Whenever there is a full frame option (or M9 prices drop significantly on the used market) that can cater to my wide angle needs without color cast, wide angle smear and kludgey user interfaces I'd be happy. In the mean time I make do with what I've got.
Dec 15, 2011 at 03:20 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #7To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Ok, first images - very unspectacular so no sample posting - reveals that the ZM18/4 is better at f4 than the A12/28 at any aperture for far distance shots. At f5.6 the A12/28 is starting to look like something but is still short of the bite of the ZM18 at f4. Stopped down to f5.6 improves the ZM18 marginally. I kept the comparison to f4 and f5.6 vs f2.5/4/5.6 on the respective lenses.

The ZM18 has virtually nonexistent CA, where as the A12 exhibits CA wide open and stopped down to 5.6. Not too heavy but clearly visible. The M mount sensor reveals that it is capable of handling the 18mm to the hilt; sharp corners and no smearing even at f4. The 18mm seems to do better on the GXR M mount than on the NEX5n. There is simply put nothing to complain about.

The A12/28 is sharp enough for close range and workable indoors where the ZM18 is too slow.

The first shots at range with the 75 Summarit reveals extraordinary detail right from wide open. Impeccable performance.
Dec 15, 2011 at 07:26 AM
pingflood
Offline
Details
p.2 #8To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
What kind of focus assistance do you get with the GXR? I played with a NEX recently and found the focus peaking to be really neat and useful.

Must say a GXR + M module is quite tempting though. I am betting they as usual cost about twice as much here in Sweden as in the US however...
Dec 15, 2011 at 07:46 AM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #9To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
pingflood the GXR gives you their version of focus peaking, like Sony offers, but in two flavours. "Mode 1" is similar to what you've experienced with the NEX, with contrast outlines on the regular full colour image. "Mode 2" provides the outlines on a flat gray rendition of the image that some affectionately or derisively might call *predator* mode after the sci-fi movie.

I think the accuracy of either mode somehow seems better but I find that Mode 1 on the GXR doesn't provide as strong a visual indication as on the NEX. Mode 2 makes manual focusing easy. Mode 2 may not be to everyone's taste. I like the results I get with Mode 2 that I just haven't bothered going some time with Mode 1 to see if I can get the same results.

But wait, there is more - you can turn focus peaking off and on. You can turn magnification off and on. Both can be assigned to a convenient button, acting as a toggle independently of each other, on the camera. A half-press of the shutter returns you to normal view no matter which focus aides you have enabled at the time.

The NEX doesn't provide a way to toggle peaking off and on and I found with some subjects the visual clutter would actively get in the way of composition.

Does the differences really matter or are they just different ways of getting the same result?

I shot ~1600 images over a three week period trying to make the NEX-5N work for me and consistently I found that my focus hit rate was poor. One day into using the GXR my focus hit rate is way up, much closer to 100%. The difference to me is astounding.

Since a camera I cannot quickly and more reliably than not focus isn't a camera I want to use, the NEX-5N went up for sale in an instant.

These are my experiences... your mileage may vary!

There are trade offs to consider too - for example the current GXR isn't a low light monster like the NEX is, and using the focus aides in more dimly lit situations on the GXR is more challenging than on the NEX. My experience is that the GXR Mode 2 peaking still works better even in dim light, but locating the target requires that I to aim the focus point, with a half press toggling Mode 2 off temporarily, at something that will be more prominent in Mode 2; then I can release the half-press shutter and focus. It becomes second nature soon enough. In most lighting conditions you don't have to think much about it, just focus and go. I was reminded of focusing in dim light yesterday while grabbing some faces from the crowd in an auditorium watching a concert. Probably this aspect of performance will improve radically with the new A16 Mount module and for that reason alone I'd be tempted to purchase the new revised module.

(I should note that my fastest lens for the GXR is f/2; maybe the 50/1.5 I have coming will also help)

Edited on Dec 15, 2011 at 09:18 AM · View previous versions
Dec 15, 2011 at 08:46 AM
wstam
Offline
Details
p.2 #10To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
kosmoskatten wrote:
Ok, first images - very unspectacular so no sample posting - reveals that the ZM18/4 is better at f4 than the A12/28 at any aperture for far distance shots. At f5.6 the A12/28 is starting to look like something but is still short of the bite of the ZM18 at f4. Stopped down to f5.6 improves the ZM18 marginally. I kept the comparison to f4 and f5.6 vs f2.5/4/5.6 on the respective lenses.

The ZM18 has virtually nonexistent CA, where as the A12 exhibits CA wide open and stopped down to 5.6. Not too heavy but clearly visible. The M
...Show more →

Just curious, what photos are you referring to here? Didn't see any photos posted in the thread. Thanks.
Dec 15, 2011 at 09:10 AM
michaelwatkins
Offline
Details
p.2 #11To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
kosmoskatten wrote:
Ok, first images - very unspectacular so no sample posting... The M mount sensor reveals that it is capable of handling the 18mm to the hilt; sharp corners and no smearing even at f4. The 18mm seems to do better on the GXR M mount than on the NEX5n.


Looking forward to semi and full-on spectacular images in the days and weeks to come.

I don't suppose you have access to any of the CV ultra-wides do you? Comparisons are always fun. Sometimes informative even. I wonder if there's one around here somewhere...
Dec 15, 2011 at 09:21 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.2 #12To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
philber wrote:
Sosua, I don't see how the Ricoh would be any less picky, as its sensor to pupil distance needs to be the same with the same sensor and the same glass, unless they can get a significantly better version of the sensor than Sony can. The lack of an AA filter will improve the cam's ability to retrieve small detail, already a strong point from the NEX, but will, if anything, make it more susceptible to "trouble", including moiré, which can be sometimes seen with the 5N.


The difference without the AA filter is not only that there should be better fine detail, but much less likelihood of smearing into the corners with symmetrical and near-symmetrical design rangefinder lenses. It's explained very nicely in this Zeiss pdf starting on page 12 why the extra layers over the sensor can cause problems. Zeiss specifically uses the ZM21 f/2.8 as an example, a lens I own and tested on the 5N with quite poor results as described here in my blog with full-rez image samples. You can clearly see how horrendous the corners are until stopped well down.

Moire can be an issue, but it depends on what you photograph. Having worked with the M9 now for about a year, and 10's of thousands of images later, moire has at times been an issue, but the majority of times it has been when photographing people wearing business attire. It can also appear in repetitious patterns seen in some architectural designs. But for most purposes, I believe the trade-off of no AA filter and better corner/edge performance with an optimized sensor with much less color shift is worthwhile in part because it will mean much less work in post to minimize these issues.

Ron
Dec 15, 2011 at 09:35 AM
wstam
Offline
Details
p.2 #13To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
philber wrote:
Sosua, I don't see how the Ricoh would be any less picky, as its sensor to pupil distance needs to be the same with the same sensor and the same glass, unless they can get a significantly better version of the sensor than Sony can. The lack of an AA filter will improve the cam's ability to retrieve small detail, already a strong point from the NEX, but will, if anything, make it more susceptible to "trouble", including moiré, which can be sometimes seen with the 5N.


Hi philber, I believe it's the micro lens on the sensors that make the different. I bought the 5n on the first day it was available in my country to use with my legacy C/Y lens. Happy with the combinations. Have shared few of my photos on the NEX Image thread here. Then I started picking up RF lenses for the compact size. That's where I started to face problem with lenses <28mm. I know my case could be due to my particular 5n because I saw many people happy with those lenses on this forum (including yourself). I actually posted the problem I encountered in this forum. (Don't intend to elaborate the problem here.) To my surprise, when I tried those WA RF lenses on my friend's 5n, I noticed same problem but just a lot subtle. He didn't even notice it till I pointed out.

One thing for sure, Ricoh designs this M-module to use M lenses. So they must have performed all the design and testing with M lenses. We can't say the same for Sony NEX.

Beside the problem mentioned, I like the GXR body much more than 5n. However, the most important pull factor to me is the color output from the Ricoh. I know, this is personal taste. Of course 5n has many pluses over GXR (like much better EVF, lower noise, better ISO output,..)

Therefore I am excited if Ricoh can perform the same magic to the 16MP Sony sensor. It's like my dream come through.
Dec 15, 2011 at 09:42 AM
wstam
Offline
Details
p.2 #14To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Concerning the problem I encountered with 5n mentioned above, I posted it here but sorry that I have already removed the photo from flickr:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1053384/0#10024837

Someone else reported same problem here:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/969329/115#10091261

I encountered it with Contax G 28mm, ZM 18mm and ZM 25mm. Both ZM lenses work beautifully on the GXR M module.
Dec 15, 2011 at 10:19 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #15To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Just an image from today with the GXR A12 50 module to liven things up until adequate samples are procured, glued down one of the cats to the sofa:



I need another online account for uploading photos, Photob*cket kills off sharpness. Above shot is unsharpened but does look better before being mauled in the upload.
Dec 15, 2011 at 10:32 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #16To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Wstam; that is my thinking as well, Sony went to some lengths with producing an excellent sensor but has chosen software correction for their own lenses and have not had to tweak the sensor for RF lenses, now why would they? Ricoh started with the goal of accommodating RF lenses on digital via a dedicated mount.

Michael: I haven't got any Voigt wides, I'll try to source one up to give it a whirl. The 15mm looks interesting. I can say that the ZM18 works like a charm with no smearing or color casts straight out of the bat on GXR, there are on board processing options for alt glass but I have no need for it as of now - there is nothing to correct on the ZM18.
Dec 15, 2011 at 10:39 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #17To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
75mm Summarit at f2.5. Unsharpened conversion from DNG to Jpeg, then mangled by PB:



Dec 15, 2011 at 10:41 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.2 #18To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
kosmoskatten wrote:
Wstam; that is my thinking as well, Sony went to some lengths with producing an excellent sensor but has chosen software correction for their own lenses and have not had to tweak the sensor for RF lenses, now why would they? Ricoh started with the goal of accommodating RF lenses on digital via a dedicated mount.

Michael: I haven't got any Voigt wides, I'll try to source one up to give it a whirl. The 15mm looks interesting. I can say that the ZM18 works like a charm with no smearing or color casts straight out of the bat on
...Show more →

I'd imagine the sensor tuned bit from Ricoh is probably a little overstated, just as theSuede mentioned about Leica's sensor and microlens tuning. I'd bet if Sony removed the AA filter, like with the GXR, much of the problems with rangefinder lenses would be solved (as implied by the Zeiss paper.). It's a shame Sony included an AA filter on the Nex-7.
Dec 15, 2011 at 10:49 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #19To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
Yes, you are probably correct in that assumption. After reading the Zeiss paper I think the tweaking is minimal at best - the AA-filter excluded.

But, it does a visibly better job with wide angles in the Ricoh implementation so I am really keen on seeing what the A16 M module is capable of. It will be a just comparison to the NEX5n as they share the same, current sensor. I don't expect a remarkable improvement over the previous sensor. But a little bit better.

I am starting to think that the lack of AA-filter is part of the reason the ZM18 does better than the A12/28 module. The latter has a custom AA-filter which is quite weak but still the difference is obvious. And Ricoh know how to make wide angles.
Dec 15, 2011 at 10:56 AM
kosmoskatten
Offline
Details
p.2 #20To the few it may concern... ...GXR M module update
wstam: the photos were quite boring so I would not bother with posting them, just reported the obvious findings. At least I know that the ZM18/4 was a good investment as I have proven for myself it betters the A12/28 module I also have.

I will keep both as the A12/28 is by no means bad, far from it, it is just not stellar.

It would be very interesting to try the CV15/4.5 on the M mount, even more so when and if the A16 module starts shipping.
Dec 15, 2011 at 11:00 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister