denoir wrote:
Speaking of DxO - they claim that the sensor in the C3 is the same as in the Sony A580, Pentax K5 & Nikon D7000 but that it has been tuned differently.
Some of the DxO data is very questionable, but this data about sensors could very well be the case. In the semiconductor industry, chips are always graded into tiers based on their performance. From sensors coming off the same wafer, what if the C3 sensor was tested to a lower performance / IQ metrics than the D7000 sensor tested for tighter / higher performance IQ metrics ?! The price premium one pays, for a higher quality sensor, is partly based on this kind of supply side economics at sensor manufacturers, and of course costs of guaranteeing higher quality.
About being "differently tuned", well it has to be, if the performance spread is wide among the same class of sensors. But I suppose that's obvious . At least to me, what makes DxO data questionable (as can be seen in lens data) is that they take a few data points of a few (?) samples and try to extrapolate it to general performance of a product population. And all it takes is slightly high variations in quality level of a product (insert your favorite Canon / Nikon lens) to throw their data off.
Ajay C wrote: denoir wroteSpeaking of DxO - they claim that the sensor in the C3 is the same as in the Sony A580, Pentax K5 & Nikon D7000 but that it has been tuned differently.Some of the DxO data is very questionable, but this data about sensors could very well be the case. In the semiconductor industry, chips are always graded into tiers based on their performance. From sensors coming off the same wafer, what if the C3 sensor was tested to a lower performance / IQ metrics than the D7000 sensor tested for tighter / higher performance IQ metrics ?! The price premium one pays, for a higher quality sensor, is partly based on this kind of supply side economics at sensor manufacturers, and of course costs of guaranteeing higher quality.
About being "differently tuned", well it has to be, if the performance spread is wide among the same class of sensors. But I suppose that's obvious . At least to me, what makes DxO data questionable (as can be seen in lens data) is that they take a few data points of a few (?) samples and try to extrapolate it to general performance of a product population. And all it takes is slightly high variations in quality level of a product (insert your favorite Canon / Nikon lens) to throw their data off. ...Show more →
Yeah, I never pay much attention to their overall scores and lens tests. I really only look at the more detailed graphs in the sensor section.
carstenw wrote: douglasf13 wroteThe live view in the IQ180 is painfully slow.Ah well, sorry you are disappointed, you can send it to me then. Contax mount, please
Ha, I wish I owned one! I was simply saying that an equivalent live view in consumer cameras would not go over well.
douglasf13 wrote:
I think most would agree that their sensor data is pretty reliable. It is deciphering the data that can hang us up. As for lens testing, like with most lens testing sites, there are too many variable for me to hold much stock in those.
I would imagine that the C3 should be tuned differently, considering the power requirements of such a small camera. Maybe similar to how Intel's mobile chips work?
Not necessarily. Even sensor testing has a lot of variables, but they are less widely understood than lens testing. DxO does report some good data on sensors but without some understanding of pixels and color science, it is easy to misinterpret.
Since this is the alt. gear forum I'll go overboard a little (color science experts need not read below):
For example, DxO's numbers for color response (for Sony NEX-C3) is saying that red is the weakest channel (0.38 relative response) in this sensor, and this has to be amplified by 2.63x times (white balance scales table) before it is mixed with green and blue to get a pure white response. For an advanced amateur (or RAW developers), this kind of data is helpful to achieve a very accurate white response (in different lighting conditions).
"Tuning differently" could very well be IQ performance tuning than just tweaking power numbers.
These are just general impressions, I have not made any proper side by side comparisons.. Color tests between cameras tend to become impossibly complex as you need to take into consideration different RAW developers.
I have compared colors of NEX-5 and M9. I did make a photo of place full of children toys, full of colors. In the middle I put small color checker card, produced by X-Rite.
Then I created profiles for LR\ACR for both cameras. Easy and quick 1 time operation.
Colors were more live, reminding real scene - with M9. The same was with skin.
Unfortunately I do not keep that test shots...
PS: my own profile for M9 - gives more natural results, than Adobe Standard or Embedded one. I highly recommend creating your own profile if you use LR\ACR.
It may appear, that you need few variants for different lenses!
PPS: I just thought - when comparing NEX and M9 colors - best would be to use the same lens, which I didn't in my comparison at that time.
SAR has received claimed prices of the three new lenses.
Zeiss 24mm f/1.8 = $999
Sony 55-210mm f/4-6.3 OSS = $299
Sony 50mm f/1.8 OSS = $349
I am very excited for this update. If the nex7 is as good as it's starting to look, I
might finally sell my Leica film gear and go digital.
I'm just hoping the Zeiss lens is not too big...
KyleR. wrote:
I am very excited for this update. If the nex7 is as good as it's starting to look, I
might finally sell my Leica film gear and go digital.
I'm just hoping the Zeiss lens is not too big...
Jerry_R wrote:
I have compared colors of NEX-5 and M9. I did make a photo of place full of children toys, full of colors. In the middle I put small color checker card, produced by X-Rite.
Then I created profiles for LR\ACR for both cameras. Easy and quick 1 time operation.
PS: my own profile for M9 - gives more natural results, than Adobe Standard or Embedded one. I highly recommend creating your own profile if you use LR\ACR.
It may appear, that you need few variants for different lenses!
I read that due to the way the ACR/LR engine works, a custom profile only works for the color temperature that the target was shot at. So if you're shooting scenes with very different color temps, the colors will be inaccurate even with your custom profile. If I remember correctly this was said by an Adobe engineer -- I read this in a discussion about the "untwisted" and "invariant" profiles for LR/ACR. http://dcptool.sourceforge.net/Hue%20Twists.html
Example images with these profiles don't look very impressive to me, so after some research I lost interest to try them out.
Wow, and I'm the complete opposite.
I always use an invariant, or untwisted profile.
Even when "generating my own" from the ColorChecker Passport.
Shrug, I think they look better.
AhamB wrote:
I read that due to the way the ACR/LR engine works, a custom profile only works for the color temperature that the target was shot at. So if you're shooting scenes with very different color temps, the colors will be inaccurate even with your custom profile. If I remember correctly this was said by an Adobe engineer -- I read this in a discussion about the "untwisted" and "invariant" profiles for LR/ACR. http://dcptool.sourceforge.net/Hue%20Twists.html
Example images with these profiles don't look very impressive to me, so after some research I lost interest to try them out.
A77
24.3 MP Exmor HD CMOS sensor
19 points AF sensor with 11 cross sensors
ISO 100-16000, with expandeable ISO 50 option
1920 x 1080 60p/24p AVCHD 2.0
P/A/S/M manual controls while recording video
1200 zone metering
Completely new developed Bionz processor
12 fps
1/8000 shutter speed
TrueBlack 921k 3-way tilt LCD
3 million dot OLED viewfinder
Smart teleconverter function with 1.4x and 2.0x option
Built-in flash
Built-in GPS
Battery life with over over 500 shots
Magnesium alloy body
Dust and Moisture proof
Multi Frame NR
SD card (no CF!)
A65 (differences with the A77)
A77 has 19 point AF system with 11 cross sensors while the A65 has only 3 cross sensors.
A77 can do 12 fps while the A65 can do 10fps.
A77 has new 3 way tilting LCD, A65 has “classic” tilting LCD
A77 can do 50 ISO while A65 can not.
The A77 has a magnesium body while the A65 has not.
The A77 has 1/8000 shutter while A65 has a 1/4000 shutter
The A77 has a top LCD screen while the A65 has it not.
The A77 is Dust and Moisture proof while the A65 is not
NEX-7
24,3 Exmor HD sensor
100-16.000 ISO
1200 zone metering
1920×1080 60p/60i/24p AVCHD 2.0 (28Mbit/s) video recording
3 million dot XGA OLED viewfinder
3inch 921k TruBlack LCD display (touchscreen)
10 fps
20ms startup time
Built-in flash
New universal hot shoe
Battery life for over 400 shots
Magnesium alloy body
NEX-5N
16.1 MP Exmor sensor (Same us Sony NEX-C3)
ISO 100-25600
1920×1080 60p/60i/24p AVCHD 2.0 video recording
Shutter 1/4000
10 fps
Can take over 430 shots with one battery
Same AF speed as the GH2
VG-20
16 MPX Exmor sensor
1920×1080 60p/60i/24p AVCHD 2.0 video recording
Can record stills in RAW
3 inch touchscreen (swifel)
audio level control
IR AVR remote ...Show more →
EVF is superb. It reminds me of what it’s like looking at an iPhone retina display. You simply can’t see the pixels because they are so small. I didn’t see any rainbow effects and the refresh rate was super fast. There is still a tiny bit of lag when panning but it’s much improved.
Sounds good to me, it may be better in a production version, or after a FW update.
The Nex-7 is also going to be expensive because it has a customized sensor. Sony, I’m told, has struggled a bit with getting good corners because of the short registration distance. Sony originally planned for the NEX to be marketed at consumers and didn’t realize it would be a hit with enthusiast too. To combat the short registration distance, they put in some micro offset lenses. All lenses will benefit from this, including legacy glass so people will see improved performance with their rangefinder lenses.
douglasf13 wrote:
I'm trying not to get too excited, but now SAR is saying that the Zeiss 24mm will have a leaf shutter. Interesting.
My thoughts exactly... almost too good to be true, right? If true, it might require some serious restraint to hold off until Fuji deliver something...
A number of posters have put forward their wish for a FF sensor on the NEX 7, which I can undestand. Yet that looks to be incompatible with the E-mount, which seems to small. However, no-one has suggested that the NEX7/Alpha77 sensor could be APS-H. That would be compatible with the E-Mount, and would give Sony a significant IQ and marketing advantage over M 4/3, Canon, Fuji etc...
This would also let the NEX be "better" with wide angle lenses and not suffer from very high pixel density as would be the case if the 24Mp unit were APS-C. It might also explain why Sony, inexplicably, did not develop more NEX lenses until now. Reason being that the original 3 are APS-C-sized, whereas the "upmarket" ones, (Zeiss 2'mm, 16-50 f:2.8, etc) could be APS-H sized...
Just speculating...
The universal hot-shoe is not seen in the mockup pictures. I wonder if Sony would really be enlightened (no pun intended) enough to allow other flash units to be used with their cameras. Didn't all their DSLR models including the A900/850 have the proprietary Konica-Minolta inherited hot-shoe?