CGrindahl wrote:
obik wrote
photoelle wrote
I wonder what the impact of millions of these very easy to use, *no skill* cameras will have on us professional photographers? It will enable anyone to get photos that are always 100% in focus, with very little noise even in low light, that all their friends and family will be able to interact with. And identical whining was heard with the introduction of autofocus, TTL metering, AV mode, TV mode, P mode, TTL flash, digital, and every other photographic advance of the last hundred years. AND, the income generated by photography has been steadily eroding...
I could say the same about web designing. 15 years ago, if you knew html and how to tie your shoes, you could pull down $100k a year as a web designer. These days, that same skill set will get you nowhere. I haven't heard any gloom-n-doom about the death of web design as a profession lately.
For most of photography's life, professional photographers have been--by and large--camera operators and most of the jobs they were taking were so simple a monkey could do them. Nowadays, any old idiot can operate a camera and all those easy, point and shoot jobs are going to any old idiot. That squeezes things--hard, especially since some those idiots are competing for (and getting) some of the more complex and high end jobs. If you want to sell pictures these days, you have to bring a lot more to the table than the ability to set up some lights, calculate an exposure, and trip the shutter.
And don't forget, this is the first paradigm shift in photography since its inception.
Been to the movies lately?
To a lesser extent, have you handled a print (or negative, I guess), shot medium format or 35mm, shot in color, or used a digital camera? All of those things changed the photographic profession immensely.
Until now a photo regardless of how it was captured, was simply a two dimensional object that once created was simply viewed. This technology allows the viewer to have an interactive relationship with the image.
Sounds like you've never played a computer game before. I was blown away with photos being used in place of computer-painted sprites in the early nineties. THOSE were photos you could really interact with! And the first time I saw a webcam in action impressed me even more--never mind when I actually talked to someone over one. That was unbelievably cool.
Plenoptic cameras are cool, but in terms of interactive photography I view it as being on par with zoomable images: gimmicky, wildly over-used, and only occasionally well executed.
In terms of production and post-production though, plenoptic cameras could be a real game changer.