Did you use the hack saw trick? And if so, did you take off the ef-s mount before hacking away? I recently read a site guiding step by step through the process and am thinking aobut taking the 80-100$ plunge.
I used an orbital sander. I removed the mount scuffed up the underside and filled it with 5 minute epoxy. I then used the sander to sand the mount pretty much flush. It works great. I guess a hacksaw would work to if you where real carefull. The sander only take little amount off at a time.
So what do you think of the lens? How's the color and contrast? Any more pics/comments about it (especially at 18mm)? I was considering doing this, as I'm pretty handy, but was wondering if it was really worth the time/effort.
I would love the 17-40L, but don't have the $ now, would you consider this a decent solution (albeit somewhat temporary) for landscape-minded wideangle?
I'm returning my second 18-50 DC because it front focused on my 10D. Mind you have 8 other lenses that are fine. Also the Rebel kit lens focuses much faster, and at $80 was cheaper.
Scooby when I had my Rebel with kit lens I loved it it is an excellent lens with good shapness and pretty good contrast. It has been directly compared to the 17-40 numerous times and when the comparison pictures between both lenses are posted sometimes you cannot tell the difference. The 17-40 is 1 full stop faster at the tele end but the Rebel kit lens is a 1/2 stop faster at the wide end.
I think the 18-55 is much better than it's Sigma cousin - I tried both. I thought the Canon was also superior to the Tam/Tok 19-35s and even the much more expensive Sigma 17-35 (new one). The Tamron 17-35 is better optically, but the range on the 18-55 comes in very handy as does the decent macro and faster focusing than the Tamron.
I'm glad folks are still looking at my how-to webpage for modifying the lens - I was about to take it down, but I'll leave it up for a while longer - maybe it'll shame Canon into making this lens in the factory as they should have done from day 1.