Portrait from Congo
/forum/topic/824435/0

1
   2   end

Spyros D
Registered: Sep 03, 2007
Total Posts: 670
Country: United States

Taken in Mudja, North Kivu province of Democratic Republic of Congo. C&C always welcome.
Spyros



This image is copyrighted by the owner




george malamis
Registered: Aug 10, 2007
Total Posts: 765
Country: United States

It is a beautiful portrait with your subject perfectly exposed. The only issue I see it that the background isn't complimentary. What I mean by that is the bright background competes with your subject creating some tension but without putting in him in any context which is what you would expect from such an environmental portrait.



Steady Hand
Registered: Dec 03, 2007
Total Posts: 13713
Country: United States

Greetings Spyros.

Nice portrait.

I like the composition, the expression, and overall look.

I think it would look nice in BW too.

Good to see you here again.

Keep up the good work.



Tim Ashton
Registered: Dec 27, 2006
Total Posts: 2643
Country: Australia

Hi Spyros
This one I like a lot
glad to see you are still shooting which means you are well, even if you are busy
Best
tim



dengar
Registered: Oct 21, 2008
Total Posts: 588
Country: United States

Dang, thats a great shot. That would look great as a National Geographic cover.



canon pants
Registered: Jan 12, 2009
Total Posts: 908
Country: Canada

fantastic. great expression. love how the eyes stand out so much. look at his hands and shirt, gotta wonder the story behind that. good to show your kids when they are not finishing their dinner.



Jim Rickards
Registered: Dec 02, 2003
Total Posts: 8410
Country: Canada

Spyros! I've missed your posts. Good to see you again.
This one has good expression and a very nice pose. Nice balance to the composition too.

As for the background, you chose the "darkly exposed subject against a bright background", which works well. It just doesn't add any context - we can't see what the bright background is - as pointed out by George. I see this as a very minor point. There may have been little back there to include, or what was back there was better left unseen.



Ronny Mills
Registered: Jun 29, 2004
Total Posts: 537
Country: United States

Excellent!!

I like the background and think it serves your subject well. "Environment" is not needed. This is a portrait not a photo essay on another starving black child ...



ml744
Registered: Aug 05, 2005
Total Posts: 484
Country: United States

george malamis wrote:
It is a beautiful portrait with your subject perfectly exposed. The only issue I see it that the background isn't complimentary. What I mean by that is the bright background competes with your subject creating some tension .


+1 on that.

george malamis wrote:
but without putting in him in any context which is what you would expect from such an environmental portrait.


-1 on this. I think it's a great portrait on its own and the showing of the environment is not necesarily instrumental to it.

Best,

Matias



timhpark
Registered: Jan 04, 2007
Total Posts: 3453
Country: United States

wonderful portrait! his expression is very penetrating, and i like the way he's standing!

tim



Carolyn1250
Registered: Aug 16, 2006
Total Posts: 518
Country: United States

Wow, this is great, tells 20 stories in one image. The only think I could think of is to dodge a bit (and I mean a real little bit) around his eyes, forehead and lips. Brighten up the face a bit, because that is a powerful expression.

I like the blown out background, gives me the sense he is hiding or hidden in some way.



george malamis
Registered: Aug 10, 2007
Total Posts: 765
Country: United States

ronnymills wrote:
Excellent!!

I like the background and think it serves your subject well. "Environment" is not needed. This is a portrait not a photo essay on another starving black child ...


Just to reiterate my first statement - it is a beautiful portrait. What I mean by environment is that without the title I don't place him there from the rest of the photograph. Now I don't think you need to have Congo blazing in the background either but something that ties me in who he is. It is such a powerful portrait that I want to know more.



Spyros D
Registered: Sep 03, 2007
Total Posts: 670
Country: United States

Hi Steady,

Thanks for your comments, as always. Will try in BW and see what it gives. Best, Spyros



Spyros D
Registered: Sep 03, 2007
Total Posts: 670
Country: United States

Tim Ashton wrote:
Hi Spyros
This one I like a lot
glad to see you are still shooting which means you are well, even if you are busy
Best
tim


Hi Tim, great to hear from you as always. yep, still here, still struggling to find some time to take photos. Cheers, Spyros



Spyros D
Registered: Sep 03, 2007
Total Posts: 670
Country: United States

dengar wrote:
Dang, thats a great shot. That would look great as a National Geographic cover.


Thanks!



Spyros D
Registered: Sep 03, 2007
Total Posts: 670
Country: United States

Jim Rickards wrote:
Spyros! I've missed your posts. Good to see you again.
This one has good expression and a very nice pose. Nice balance to the composition too.

As for the background, you chose the "darkly exposed subject against a bright background", which works well. It just doesn't add any context - we can't see what the bright background is - as pointed out by George. I see this as a very minor point. There may have been little back there to include, or what was back there was better left unseen.


Hi Jim, friends:

Many thanks for your comments. About the background - it was a tough call. I chose in the end to blur the background simply because there was not much there, and I wanted to isolate him. Point noted about need for context.

best, Spyros



Spyros D
Registered: Sep 03, 2007
Total Posts: 670
Country: United States

Carolyn1250 wrote:
Wow, this is great, tells 20 stories in one image. The only think I could think of is to dodge a bit (and I mean a real little bit) around his eyes, forehead and lips. Brighten up the face a bit, because that is a powerful expression.

I like the blown out background, gives me the sense he is hiding or hidden in some way.



Carolyn, thanks so much! I will try out your suggestions. Best, Spyros



Spyros D
Registered: Sep 03, 2007
Total Posts: 670
Country: United States

Steady Hand wrote:
Greetings Spyros.

Nice portrait.

I like the composition, the expression, and overall look.

I think it would look nice in BW too.

Good to see you here again.

Keep up the good work.


Hi Steady, here's the BW version. Best, Spyros



This image is copyrighted by the owner




srudy
Registered: Nov 24, 2003
Total Posts: 951
Country: United States

Wow- the black and white takes the intensity up several notches. In the color version my eye seems to gravitate to his right hand, but in the black and white conversion I focus on the eyes. Nice work.



paulhodson
Registered: Jul 22, 2003
Total Posts: 14344
Country: United Kingdom

As ever



1
   2   end