First real attempt at an old-time look. I really like the color, toning, and texture, but wonder if there's too much detail lost.
Your thoughts?
Thanks! - Tim

The tone is well suited to the image but the vignette and texture need to be dialed way down, you might even try another texture that isn't so repetitive .

Sorry Tim this doesnt do it for me. Way too much texture that I can't really even make out the image. The OOF vignette is very strange to me too. I usually prefer a black vignette. Keep trying!

eric

I agree that black might work better for the vignettes, but I think this is a good start. Maybe the opacity of the grain might be reduced some too. The sepia tone is good.

J.R.

Hey, thanks all for the feedback. Yup, I wondered if it might be a bit much. Back to the drawing board on this!

I agree with Tim, just a bit less texture would have worked better.