1dsmk3 long exposure noise
/forum/topic/681651/0

end

DanPBrown
Registered: Nov 21, 2005
Total Posts: 636
Country: United States

Could I get some opinions please. I just came back from Acadia National Park and I took some long night exposures there. It's my first time with the 1dsmk3, I had a 1dsmk2 prior to this camera. The noise seems a bit excessive. Here is the picture, 1 hour exposure iso 400,


This image is copyrighted by the owner



Here is a 100% crop,


This image is copyrighted by the owner



Here is a crop from a 1 hour dark frame exposure that I took right after,


This image is copyrighted by the owner



I don't remember my old camera being this bad. Is this normal for a 1dsmk3?
Thanks,
Dan


mpmendenhall
Registered: Aug 09, 2008
Total Posts: 1310
Country: United States

From the look of the noise artifacts, did you have noise reduction turned on? Noise reduction can sometimes make a noisy image worse, converting unobtrusive uniform noise into sharp artifact spots on a flat, noiseless background. If you had NR on, you might want to try a long exposure without NR to see if the noise is better.



stanj
Registered: Aug 05, 2003
Total Posts: 8000
Country: United States

Because of the amplifier glow (lower left corner of your picture) I'd guess you had NR off (based on experience with my own 1Ds3). I'd suggest turning it on. It's a pain but makes it mildly better. Still, this is not the ideal camera for astro work...



perfectpixel
Registered: Mar 05, 2004
Total Posts: 491
Country: United States

I don't know if any digital camera will give you a low noise 1 hour exposure.
There are some stacker applications used in astrophotography that will stack multiple shorter exposures to give you the same effect without the noise.



Ron Hew
Registered: May 26, 2007
Total Posts: 885
Country: Malaysia

Just wondering....why did you use ISO 400 for an hour exposure?



DanPBrown
Registered: Nov 21, 2005
Total Posts: 636
Country: United States

Noise reduction was off. I also shot in raw and used ACR to process the image.
I used iso 400 to try and get some detail in the foliage.
Dan



end