First time post for HDR
/forum/topic/643292/0

end

amarinelli
Registered: May 01, 2008
Total Posts: 31
Country: United States

Hi everyone I been dabbling with HDR Images for a few weeks now and would like any c&c on this one taken at my home. Any advice or comments appreciated Thanks,
Alan

This image is copyrighted by the owner




sbeme
Registered: Dec 23, 2003
Total Posts: 3002
Country: United States

I'm not sure how to advise you, as I havent worked with HDR. HDR seems very difficult to apply in effective and subtle ways. Your image does not appear quite realistic and I'm not sure why. Probably too light in the interior.



Scott Stoness
Registered: Sep 11, 2006
Total Posts: 3232
Country: Canada

It seems soft and it looks kind of washed out in the colors. The reflections of the cushions on right are really wierd (ghosting).

You have some text showing up on table leg under glass.

I think you have chosen a subject that does not work well with hdr (reflections, moving leaves)

Tell us about your technique. Tripod, how many exposures, which software.

Best technique is use tripod with multishot on and either timer or remote shutter. If there is any movement it will show up as soft because HDR cannot resolve where pictures difer. Obviously if there is any wind in trees the leaves will look soft.

Using highlights and lower saturaton would improve.



amarinelli
Registered: May 01, 2008
Total Posts: 31
Country: United States

Thank you guys I appreciate the input It was a 3 exposure shot off a tripod with 2 second self timer the text is actually the photomatix software watermark that is there while using there software during the trial period.
Alan



Alan321
Registered: Nov 07, 2005
Total Posts: 5849
Country: Australia

I also think that the interior seems too bright for the scene to be realistic, even though on second look the extra reflections indicate that the room is probably lit through windows on two or more sides. In that case I can't see why you'd use HDR to brighten it up.

It is also a very busy scene. Perhaps using a polariser to partial effect would help but probably not - you'd be replacing busy reflections with busy seen-through-the-table details.

A bit of sharpening would help too. At least then the business would look like it's well focused

- Alan



Scott Stoness
Registered: Sep 11, 2006
Total Posts: 3232
Country: Canada

Photomatix does not watermark the hdr software in their demo version - it watermarks the tone mapping etc.

I think you should back up a step and just do hdr alone in photomatix - the tone mapping is taking it to far perhaps.



amarinelli
Registered: May 01, 2008
Total Posts: 31
Country: United States

Thank you scott great advice.
Alan



Scott Stoness
Registered: Sep 11, 2006
Total Posts: 3232
Country: Canada

By the way when I use photomatix, just hdr, I have found that universally it makes the exposure overexposed so the first step is usually to turn down the exposure before adjusting the tiff.



Bruce Sawle
Registered: Sep 26, 2006
Total Posts: 1191
Country: United States

The problem with this picture is the outside exposure is exactly the same as the inside exposure.



end