cheeba Offline Image Upload: On
|
Mannequin was offering his/her critique when criticism was specifically asked for. Go back and read Mannequin's first post - it was blunt, but by no means rude. It was certainly not a personal attack. You guys proceeded with the lame ad hominem BS. Kudos.
How about we keep this forum from being tuned into a mindless praise-fest, and welcome the (perceived) negative criticism. Do we really want to banish negative criticism at the expense of becoming a better photographer?
By the way, I also think that this is a weak image: overprocessed, poor composition, lots of CA, haloing everywhere. Maybe a shot with a WA more upright to the pole, while still including the lamp, would produce a more profound image. Also, I think if the sky is going to be that clipped, maybe the pole could be strobed to compensate. That's my opinion; get all negative about it, or do something positive with it - your choice
|