fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2005 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2005Fast Wide Prime + IS

  
 
nutek
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Fast Wide Prime + IS
phidong wrote:
I think the biggest assumption in this thread is that IS for wide angle works and that it is as effective as IS in other lenses.

First off, to understand if it is even possible to put IS into a wide angle lens, we really have to understand how IS works. When you shake your camera like a polaroid pictah, what is happening is that you're shifting the image plane around either up and down, forward to backward or right to left. But how does IS compensate for this? Easy. Theres an element or a group of elements that shifts the
...Show more →


While I generally agree with your points regarding the business parts of the debate, from an engineering standpoint, your analysis may be inaccurate.

If the said accelerometers can already "notice a shake and compensate for it" for a telephoto lens, then the same said accelerometers will also be able to notice the shake for a wide-angle lens (keeping of course, the "shake" as well as the size and weight of both lenses constant). The resultant image or FOV has nothing to do with the equation.
May 01, 2005 at 02:49 AM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Fast Wide Prime + IS
nutek wrote:
phidong wroteI think the biggest assumption in this thread is that IS for wide angle works and that it is as effective as IS in other lenses.

First off, to understand if it is even possible to put IS into a wide angle lens, we really have to understand how IS works. When you shake your camera like a polaroid pictah, what is happening is that you're shifting the image plane around either up and down, forward to backward or right to left. But how does IS compensate for this? Easy. Theres an element or a group of elements that shifts the image and projects it in the opposite direction. Canon actually uses two sheets of glass on bellow like things that move together or apart at opposite angles. So now that we understand why it works, how exactly does it know what to do?? Motion detectors and gyros.

If anybody has ever owned a primitive IS lens, you've probably heard the advice to turn IS off when you put it on a tripod. But why? The reason is the detectors would shift the elements or IS mechanism in a sin-like motion (back and forth) because they would get confused. Easy fix, if the IS notices that there is little movement or doesn't detect a lot of movement it will switch to a mode where it only worries about the mirror slap.

Wait, did I just say if it detects little to no movement, it switches into a "stanby-sleep like" state? .. I think I did!

So now that we completely understand how and why IS works, why not in wide angle lenses? When you' deal with a telephoto lens with 10% FOV, a shift in the axis where the sensor is is a HUGE shift in the image plane. What this means is that the motion detectors and gyros will NOTICE a shake and compensate for it. That is why people invented that magic 1/focal length rule. The longer the lens, the shorter the shutter speed needs to be to produce an acceptable image.

On wide angle lenses, this is the reason some people can handhold a 20mm lens for seconds. No, I didn't make a typo. SECONDS. Keep in mind I said some people, this doesn't apply to everybody, but most people should still be able to get pretty steady shots even at some slower shutter speeds.

Now, why not IS in a wide angle lens? The answer is right above. The REASON you can hand hold a wide angle lens has nothing to do with it's size and almost everythign to do with the fact that your photographer's handshake has almost a negligable affect on shifting the image plane, basically you don't shift it enough. The problem then is, if I can hold handhold at 20mm for almost half a second (speaking of me now) and get an acceptable image, where the human eye probably couldn't detect shake...

how will the IS mechanism detect the "shake"? You have to ask yourself then, will IS in a wide angle lens be benefitial or detrimental to the performance of the lens? And even if it did help, how much would it help? 3 stops? 2 stops? 1 stop? Would it be worth the extra 500 dollars for people who can already handhold a wide angle lens at for 1-2 seconds? And for people who CAN handhold the lens that long, would the IS mechanism even be functioning during this time, or would it be in sleep mode because the image plane was being held so still? In which case, the photographer would just be carrying around deadweight.

Answer all these questions then make projections of how many people would buy the lens. IS in a wide angle is almost the equivalent of a 1200mm lens. It's cool, but it isn't practical and not everybody needs it. Well, when I say not everybody I mean very few people need it. So when you think about Canon as a business, it doesn't make financial sense to research and develop a product that few people will buy.

And there is the answer to your question.

Edited by phidong on May 01, 2005 at 12:37 AM GMT
While I generally agree with your points regarding the business parts of the debate, from an engineering standpoint, your analysis may be inaccurate.

If the said accelerometers can already "notice a shake and compensate for it" for a telephoto lens, then the same said accelerometers will also be able to notice the shake for a wide-angle lens (keeping of course, the "shake" as well as the size and weight of both lenses constant). The resultant image or FOV has nothing to do with the equation.

Theres obviously more compensation for a smaller field of view than a larger one (wide angle). And while it will still relize there is movement, whos to say that the degree of accuracy of the mechanism is great enough? Think about why it doesn't work when you're on a tripod.
May 01, 2005 at 02:53 AM
nutek
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Fast Wide Prime + IS
phidong wrote:
Theres obviously more compensation for a smaller field of view than a larger one (wide angle). And while it will still relize there is movement, whos to say that the degree of accuracy of the mechanism is great enough? Think about why it doesn't work when you're on a tripod.


Yes, definitely there will be more compensation for a smaller FOV. I don't know enough about the *precision* (not accuracy) of the IS mechanism, so I won't comment on it.

The new IS mechanisms do detect that the lens is mounted on a tripod. A simple enough algorithm: if shake < threshold, disable IS. If shake > threshold, enable it.

If you're hand-holding it still enough for 2 seconds such that the IS cannot detect the movement, then great, you're as sturdy as a tripod But not everyone can do that...

In any case, this is all for the jest of pedantic debating. It may be surprising to see new forms of photography that may appear, if wide, fast IS lenses become available on the market.


Edited by nutek on May 01, 2005 at 02:07 PM GMT
May 01, 2005 at 02:58 AM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Fast Wide Prime + IS
nutek wrote:
If you're hand-holding it still enough for 2 seconds such that the IS cannot detect the movement, then great, you're as sturdy as a tripod


Yes, I commented on the older IS to illustrate the fact that when there is little movement, the IS shuts off.

Even if you can only hand hold for 1/30s how much would IS be able to help? The amount of "help" you would get is dependant on how *precise* (sorry for my misuse of termonology) the mechanism is.
May 01, 2005 at 03:03 AM
nutek
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Fast Wide Prime + IS
phidong wrote:
nutek wroteIf you're hand-holding it still enough for 2 seconds such that the IS cannot detect the movement, then great, you're as sturdy as a tripod
Yes, I commented on the older IS to illustrate the fact that when there is little movement, the IS shuts off.

Even if you can only hand hold for 1/30s how much would IS be able to help? The amount of "help" you would get is dependant on how *precise* (sorry for my misuse of termonology) the mechanism is.


Yes, that is true. But since the 17-85 IS already exists and is working well, there is evidence to say that the IS mechanism is precise enough for a 17mm (~28mm)-wide lens.
May 01, 2005 at 03:24 AM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Fast Wide Prime + IS
nutek wrote:
phidong wrote
nutek wroteIf you're hand-holding it still enough for 2 seconds such that the IS cannot detect the movement, then great, you're as sturdy as a tripod
Yes, I commented on the older IS to illustrate the fact that when there is little movement, the IS shuts off.

Even if you can only hand hold for 1/30s how much would IS be able to help? The amount of "help" you would get is dependant on how *precise* (sorry for my misuse of termonology) the mechanism is.
Yes, that is true. But since the 17-85 IS already exists and is working well, there is evidence to say that the IS mechanism is precise enough for a 17mm (~28mm)-wide lens.


Again, that's fine. We're talking about a 600 dollar consumer lens meant for cropped sensors. A full frame version would be over the 4 digit mark for a consumer grade lens. The 1-2 stop differential puts you around f/1.8 and theres already a 20mm f/1.8 prime available from Sigma for less than a third of that price which will produce sharper pictures.

You want a f/2.8L? How much would you charge for it? Again, how many people will buy this?

Would you pay 1,500-2,000 for a 17-40mm f/2.8L IS?
May 01, 2005 at 03:32 AM
Kevin Yong
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Fast Wide Prime + IS

Imagine you are on vacation in Europe and want to get a wide shot of a dimly lit church interior. You don't have a tripod or other support but want to stop down for enough DOF (say f/8). The only lens which can do this is the 17-85IS. Yes - IS is useful on a wide angle.

Say you then wanted to take a portrait of the priest in the same church. IS would be no help because the subject cannot stay still enough to prevent motion blur. Thus opening up to f/1.8 or f/2.8 would be the solution. This would mean changing to a faster lens - none of which have IS.

This is where a fast wide lens with IS would be fantastic. It gives the best of both worlds and saves having to switch lenses.

Putting IS on the Sigma 18-50/2.8 or any of the wide primes would be fantastic in this and many other situations.


May 01, 2005 at 03:49 AM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Fast Wide Prime + IS
Kevin Yong wrote:
Imagine you are on vacation in Europe and want to get a wide shot of a dimly lit church interior. You don't have a tripod or other support but want to stop down for enough DOF (say f/8). The only lens which can do this is the 17-85IS. Yes - IS is useful on a wide angle


What shutter speeds are you getting in a dimly lit church at f/8?
May 01, 2005 at 03:52 AM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Fast Wide Prime + IS
If you want fast wide angle lenses with image stabilization, switch to Minolta.
May 01, 2005 at 03:59 AM
normski
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Fast Wide Prime + IS
sounds to me like people are wanting to shoot practically in the dark with no flash. the only solution to that little conundrum is to go infrared. in the meantime the "fastest" lens canon makes for hand holdable operation is the 24mm f1.4L. it has the same hand holdability as the now defunct 50mm f1 and nobody talked about needing IS with that. think about it - a 50mm lens needs 1/50 sec. the 24mm needs 1/24th sec. ie 1 stop difference in shutter speed and there's one stop betwwen f1 and f1.4, so in terms of handholdabilty they equal out. it's also therefore faster in handholdability than the 85mm f1.2L and even the 35mm f1.4 and obviously the 50mm f1.4. so if you want the "fastest" lens get the 24mm f1.4L. it's a real whizz.
May 01, 2005 at 03:42 PM
bwaterme
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Fast Wide Prime + IS
If I remember correctly, an article I read in Popular Photography about IS lenses stated that IS was less effective on the wider end on the lenses tested. Basically, on the zooms the IS might help for up to 3 stops at the long end, but only 1 stop on the wide end.
I guess there are a few scenarios where IS on a fast prime could help improve the image, but probably not enough to justify the cost...IMHO.
May 01, 2005 at 04:23 PM
charlesk
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Fast Wide Prime + IS

sounds to me like people are wanting to shoot practically in the dark with no flash. the only solution to that little conundrum is to go infrared.

Nah, you just have to be creative and not worry if people look at you like you are insane.

Here's a shot from the Royal Tyrrell museum in Alberta. It's a renowned dinosaur museum -- and very dark, with no pods allowed. 17-40 f/4L, 29 mm, f/8 @ 0.3s, taken with the camera smooshed against a sweater held under pressure against the handlebar of my son's stroller.

I took others that involved me holding the camera sideways on walls, or sprawling on my belly across the floor. But many of them came out... --c

http://www.pcguide.com/pers/steg.jpg
May 01, 2005 at 04:31 PM
nutek
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Fast Wide Prime + IS
Good call. I withdraw my argument

Kevin Yong wrote:
Imagine you are on vacation in Europe and want to get a wide shot of a dimly lit church interior. You don't have a tripod or other support but want to stop down for enough DOF (say f/8). The only lens which can do this is the 17-85IS. Yes - IS is useful on a wide angle.

Say you then wanted to take a portrait of the priest in the same church. IS would be no help because the subject cannot stay still enough to prevent motion blur. Thus opening up to f/1.8 or f/2.8 would be the solution. This
...Show more →
May 01, 2005 at 04:40 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister