Upload & Sell: Off
I like a lot about this image, Scott. It fits the theme perfectly with the ice, the tone, and the visual play on words (cold fish). I don't think the composition is too bad either.
What bothers me a tiny bit is not having more of at least one of the fish in better focus, particularly the eye. I think that when there are eyes in the image, there is sort of natural desire of the viewer to see at least one of those eyes in focus.
That said, I suspect that this image will attract attention on the voting page and at thumbnail size the focus issues will be much less noticeable. Besides, considering a choice between having an eye in focus or the ice, the ice was probably the right decision in this case. Nice job.