mdude85 Offline Image Upload: On
|
The Nerd Series, Part I | |
lordarka wrote:
mdude85 wrote:
Yes, I agree ... anybody can take technically great photos
Not only is the above statement completely untrue, but the underlying creative motivation behind these "technically great photos" is not so oblique.
Great series by the way.
Arka C.
I respectfully disagree -- first off, anybody can take technically great photos by buying a slew of expensive equipment, reading a few books and practicing in the studio. To suggest otherwise is a little pretentious I think. Not saying that's what this photographer is doing, but we have all seen photos having perfect lighting and focus but lacking meaning, vision, motivation, I could go on...
Obviously this photographer knows the photos are technically fine. Notice that no one in the thread has even addressed any technical details of the set other than the placement of props. In this case, the props further serve to obfuscate the meaning of this set.
Who is this man having a date with? As the viewer, am I a person who is having a date with a preoccupied "nerd", or am I a computer monitor and the man is on a date with someone in cyberspace? What is the purpose of the dog napkin? Is this even a napkin or a placemat? Why are the flowers suddenly in his mouth in shot 4? Is he doing the Tango or something? What on earth is the meaning of the tattoos? Is it a list of what he should bring to the date, and if so, why is it on his arm? Why is everything mis-spelled? What is the difference between shots 7 and 8? Why are both of them there? And the over-arching question is just plain "why"? This shoot was obviously meticulously planned and set up, I'm sure taking hours to prepare and complete... maybe even days.
The set is also highly stereotypical and overgeneralized, almost to the point of being slightly offensive. I don't want to be mean, but I can't imagine what the motivation was to take this set. Maybe the OP can give us some insight. Just looking at the photographer's other work, he is highly talented ... but this set seems way out of place.
Edited by mdude85 on May 02, 2008 at 05:38 PM GMT
|