RustyBug wroteSteve Spencer wroteHere are my picks:
Scene #1 - I like 1 and 5; and I don't like 2
Scene #2 - I like 5 and I don't like 2
Scene #3 - I like 5 and I don't like 1, 2, 3, or 4
Scene #4 - I like 1 and 5 and I don't like 3 or 4 (for different reason 3 has field curvature that bothers me and 4 has the busiest mid zone)
Scene #5 - I like 5 and I don't like 4 (CA still evident in the corner at f/8)
Here are my guesses for the lenses
1 - Pentax 31 f/1.8 limited
2 - CV 35 f/1.4
3 - Sigma 35 f/2 I-series
4 - Sony 35 f/1.8
5 - CV 35 f/1.2 III
From my scores above it looks like I really like 5 and I basically like 1, but don't think too much of the others.Ditto for 5 & 1Same, but 5 is far in the lead.
I think transition zone tests would have been better if the crops had been something like grass. For the most part they all looked pretty similar to me in that test.
RustyBug wroteSteve Spencer wroteHere are my picks:
Scene #1 - I like 1 and 5; and I don't like 2
Scene #2 - I like 5 and I don't like 2
Scene #3 - I like 5 and I don't like 1, 2, 3, or 4
Scene #4 - I like 1 and 5 and I don't like 3 or 4 (for different reason 3 has field curvature that bothers me and 4 has the busiest mid zone)
Scene #5 - I like 5 and I don't like 4 (CA still evident in the corner at f/8)
Here are my guesses for the lenses
1 - Pentax 31 f/1.8 limited
2 - CV 35 f/1.4
3 - Sigma 35 f/2 I-series
4 - Sony 35 f/1.8
5 - CV 35 f/1.2 III
From my scores above it looks like I really like 5 and I basically like 1, but don't think too much of the others.Ditto for 5 & 1Same, but 5 is far in the lead.
I think transition zone tests would have been better if the crops had been something like grass. For the most part they all looked pretty similar to me in that test.
Speak of the devil
Sample
Crops
Jan 31, 2021 at 07:37 PM
Previous versions of nehemiahphoto's message #15485545 « 35mm blind test p.2 »
