fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2005 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2005Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss

  
 
Guest
Offline
Guest

p.1 #1Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss

Recently the interest of exotic lens especially the Zeiss and even more recently Leitz lens has drawn great interests. The number of users has dramatically increase in certain lens specifically the Wide Angle (WA) and Super Wide Angle (SWA) Lens while normal and short telephoto lens have been slow but steadily increase as well. Two of the major reasons for the slow increase in normal and short telephoto usage of Zeiss and Leica lens is 1) Canon build great telephoto lens and 2) the autofocus of Canon Telephoto lens. I am here not to degrade the Canon telephoto lens against the Zeiss and Leitz lens but to demonstrate that the mechanism of German (Zeiss and Leitz) lens 3D characteristic profile as compare to Japanese lens. Even at the telephoto focal length where Japanese lens are well known for their high resolving power with brand names like Canon, Nikkor, Olympus and Minolta. I thought it would be interesting to identify the mechanism of the observed and reported 3D effect of Zeiss and Leica lens. Furthermore, I also thought it would be interesting to see if we can compare the German lens versus the Japanese lens 3D effect at the strength of the Japanese lens, the Telephoto focal length lens.

The Olympus system is considered as the Leica of the Japanese lens. In fact, it has been reported on the website that the Olympus 180mm F2.0 with rare earth dispersion free optics is the prototype that some claims Leitz copied to build the Leica 180mm APO-R and it is as good or even superior than the Leitz lens. Thus, I purchased the Olympus 180mm F2.0 and tested against the Leitz APO-R 180mm.

The results in figure 1 demonstrates that the Leitz APO 180mm has a higher resolving power. At close up look at 200% crop, Figure 2 demonstrates the Micro-Contrast (MC) characteristic as the mechanism of the German lens 3D characteristics as compare to the Japanese lens. This data is also in agreement to the support evidence that the Leitz 280mm F2.8 APO-Telyt-R lens has a distinct MC as compared to the Canon EF 300mm F4.0L. You can imagine if you cut an image of a person from a magazine and pasted onto another board you will see the 3D effect. The reason for this is the same as what the mechanism I am showing here. Figure 2 demonstrate that the black letter on white background of the $4,000 Olympus 180mm F2.0 is not well define on the edges but has the transition grey area around the letter while the Leitz APO 180mm clearly showed a distinct and well defined edge contrast of the black letter against the white background. These observations also have been oberved with the Zeiss Planar 85mm F1.2 60th and 50th Anniversary versus the Canon EF 85mm F1.2L and the Zeiss Sonnar 135mm F2.8 versus the Canon EF 135mm F2.0L. The Zeiss Distagon 21mm F2.8 will also showed the 3D effect and thus it seems that across the board this is the Zeiss and some Leitz (I say some here because I have not test every single lens in the Leitz-R lens family) lens signatures.

Figure 1:
http://homepage.mac.com/phamminhson/.Pictures/Photography/Post%20Images/180mmTestB.jpg

Figure 2:
http://homepage.mac.com/phamminhson/.Pictures/Photography/Post%20Images/180mmTests.jpg

Conclusions:
Even at the focal length where the Japanese lens shine the best, the Japanese telephoto lens, those that I have tested, showed lower in Resolving Power RP and MC than the German telephoto lens.

The mechanism that showed the characteristic of 3D effect is dependent mainly on the lens ability to have MC.

When it comes to lens I do not look at focal length but I look at the characteristic of the lens optical performance and how it will be best used under certain applications. For example, for architecture photographer, you don't need wide angle lens all the time but what you need is no distortion. Also for product shot, I would consider this type of image as a big macro image where the focus is not in close up like the macro lens application but the focusing is at midrange or sometimes even at infinity but it also requires no distortion like the macro lens application. Thus, in this situation the Carl Zeiss 100mm F2.0 would be a great lens for product works and for architecture works where distortion must be kept to minimum and the focusing distance is at midrange instead of the close up range like the macro lens. Therefore, the value of each lens should be measured only in its applications and not the focal length of the lens.

The Contax Carl Zeiss 50mm F1.4 is a very special lens but you must know how to search for this extremely sharp wide open aperature. Alot of the Carl Zeiss 50mm F1.4 are bad copies thus leading to quite of different reports from folks. The Zeiss Planar 50mm F1.7 is an extremely sharp lens and you will find that not too many lens can beat this lens. Furthermore, it has the lowest distortion value compare to other normal lens and the sharpest lens at midrange to infinity focus; if you have a very sharp Zeiss Planar 50mm F1.4 it will be as sharp as the 50mm F1.7. The reasons that the Zeiss 50mm F1.4 copies vary so much is due to the fact that it was the kit lens and it was mass overproduced to compete with other brand and the F1.4 is not as easy made as the 50mm F1.7. Therefore, most of the 50mm F1.7 Zeiss Planar are very sharp copies.
Jun 02, 2005 at 03:20 AM
djgarcia
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Son, nice comparison . I take it you used a tripod, or a very high shutter speed? Do you know how the CZ 180 compares to these two lenses? In between? Below?

Inquiring minds want to know ...
Jun 02, 2005 at 01:03 PM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #3Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
DJ, the Zeiss 180mm F2.8 is a nice lens but not in the same league as the Leitz 180mm APO.

Yes, I put on the tripod with mirror lock up.
Jun 02, 2005 at 01:13 PM
kidigital
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Son...Thanks for the comparison...nicely done. The 180 apo is really a wonderful lens. It is heavy, but compact...making handholding the lens managable. What I like best about the lens is the ease with which you can achieve manual focus.

I'm not certain that I've ever taken a picture above f2 with this lens...it is just so amazing wide open.

Kurt
Jun 02, 2005 at 01:40 PM
Bob Bell
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Nice work as usual Son. It is nice to see scientific type discussions here. I am not sure how much time you have anymore, but I would be interested in seeing what kind of degradation happens to high end lenses like these when you use Schott (Zeiss) filters, such as a B+W UV 010 MRC. And if the lenses are capable of out resolving the sensor with a filter on. Living in Phoenix, there are benefits when shooting outside to UV filters, the sky is hazy a lot and it is really dusty at times, and it would be nice to quantitatively address the impact of filters.
Jun 02, 2005 at 01:52 PM
sapro
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Son, nice write up! The other terms refer to resolving power and micro-contrast are sharpness and contrast. When we talk about constrast of a lense, we normally refer it to what you called micro-constrast. In your comparison, there is no fine details to clearly show if Olympus is losing on sharpness or on constrast. Have you done the same test on ISO 12233 Test Chart? That may be a little more scientific
Jun 02, 2005 at 02:00 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Jun 02, 2005 at 02:06 PM
kidigital
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Monito, good link.

That site ain't for no Jethro's...you preenyur need a sixth grade edgucashun to cipher those equations.

Kurt
Jun 02, 2005 at 03:18 PM
Pondria
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Son,
Thank you for the comparison and the nice writing up. And this is a profound topic. 3D and MC are very advanced concepts that I have not successfully appreciated yet. I confess that I do not even apprehend the difference between the Contrast and the Resolution. To me, they are the same quality as You use one to measure the other. When you measure the resolution, you measure the spatial frequency where the contrast falls below the threshold ( like 50%) with the b/w line pair target. When you measure the contrast, as Son said, you measure the rising slope of the black/white transition, which is actually a resolution. Can anyone shed some lights ?
Jun 02, 2005 at 09:48 PM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #10Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Jia, yes it would have been nice to have fine details which would have made the test much more comprehensive. However, there are other ways to look at resolving power of the lens such as these small words where the image that was taken with the Olympus lens show that the letters are softer than the letter taken with the Leitz lens.

Monito, the link is very important if we need numberical values as measurement of optical resolving power and contrast. At this time I do not have the time to do these type of testing but I would like to somtime in the future.

Instead of using numberical value we can also be practical to see which lens has more of pop out look as compare to lens that cannot separate the object in the image from the background. The image clearly demonstrates that the words taken with the Leitz lens has a well define edges versus the words taken with the Olympus lens where the letters seems to stick onto the background. After all when we look at photographs we appreciate the image visual effects and not just the numberical value.
Jun 02, 2005 at 09:57 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Pondria,

As I understand it, micro-contrast refers to performance of the lens at 40cycles/mm on the MTF graph, i.e. perceived detail. Macro-contrast refers to the 10cy/mm performance, i.e. the impact or "punch" of the image. In this modern age, more is better. I like to see 40cy/mm at 80%, and 10cy/mm at 95%.
Jun 02, 2005 at 09:58 PM
Pondria
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
rico wrote:
Pondria,

As I understand it, micro-contrast refers to performance of the lens at 40cycles/mm on the MTF graph, i.e. perceived detail. Macro-contrast refers to the 10cy/mm performance, i.e. the impact or "punch" of the image. In this modern age, more is better. I like to see 40cy/mm at 80%, and 10cy/mm at 95%.


Ah ha, that answers 95% of my question. Now I cannot imagine a case where you have a great micro-contrast and poor macro-contrast.
Jun 02, 2005 at 10:04 PM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #13Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Pondria, I agree with you it is quit difficult to separate out MC and Resolution. Both gives us the perceptual of high quality image and allow us to read the information more easily. My background is not an optical physicist but I still try to demonstrate the mechanism behind what we perceives as 3D effect as practically as I see in these difficult concepts.
Jun 02, 2005 at 10:12 PM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #14Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
It is always great to have Rico and Pondria to enter and expand this topics.
Jun 02, 2005 at 10:15 PM
Pondria
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
PhotoCinematic wrote:
It is always great to have Rico and Pondria to enter and expand this topics.


I think Rico must be a teacher or he should be. He explains things so well and easily.
Jun 02, 2005 at 10:17 PM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #16Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Pondria, Iike I said before and I will say it again since the day that I first join FM forum I have always have great respect for both you and Rico. Though we may have disagreement but it is like family here where each one of us have our own character.

-Son
Jun 02, 2005 at 10:21 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Not a teacher, just a student with many bookmarks. In the area of this thread, I find Erwin Puts (Mr Leica) to have deep insights. I think he's Dutch, so the writing is slightly odd, but the material is covered in great detail:

http://www.imx.nl/photosite/technical/resolution/resolution.html

Here is the Master writing about the Summicron-M 28, probably the best 28mm in the world. You need to breath deeply, assume a Zen-like trance, then begin...

http://www.imx.nl/photosite/leica/mseries/testm/m2-28.html

Good stuff!
Jun 02, 2005 at 11:14 PM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #18Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Bob Bell wrote, "I am not sure how much time you have anymore, but I would be interested in seeing what kind of degradation happens to high end lenses like these when you use Schott (Zeiss) filters, such as a B+W UV 010 MRC. And if the lenses are capable of out resolving the sensor with a filter on. Living in Phoenix, there are benefits when shooting outside to UV filters, the sky is hazy a lot and it is really dusty at times, and it would be nice to quantitatively address the impact of filters. "

Bob, I have not done any extensive test but I did manage to do a few tests on the effect of UV or Haze filter has on image quality. The limited tests that I have done showed that in most lens that I have used with high quality filters (B+W, Heliopan) has no attenuation of the resolving power of the lens. However, there was one case where the Leica protective filter on the Leitz APO-Telyt-R 280mm F2.8 attenuated the resolving power significantly by eyesight observation.

My recommendation is to get high quality filter if you want to use the filter on your lens. Most of the time I don't think it will affect your optic performance. However, in one case that I have observed the filter did degrade the image quality. In this case keep the filter to protect your lens and take it out when you take the picture.
Jun 02, 2005 at 11:28 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
PhotoCinematic wrote:
DJ, the Zeiss 180mm F2.8 is a nice lens but not in the same league as the Leitz 180mm APO.


I heard the CZ S180 is unmodified (except for T*) from the original "Olympia Sonnar", so called because of its introduction at the Olympic Games of 1936 Germany. That makes it 70 years old! The designated camera body was the Contax rangefinder! That was a head-scratcher until I saw the actual lens just ten minutes ago: yup, eBay listing. The secret is a reflex housing built right into the lens barrel. Love that crazy German engineering! Can't determine if we can cram the thing onto an EOS DSLR but, at $2000, it's an expensive thrill. The uncoated glass would give some serious glow.
Jun 03, 2005 at 04:06 AM
Guest
Offline
Guest
Details
p.1 #20Micro-Contrast 3D Characteristical Mechanism of Leica/Zeiss
Rico that Olympia Sonnar is a piece of the great Zeiss history.
Jun 03, 2005 at 06:55 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister