RoamingScott wrote:
I remain convinced after all these years, and so many unconvincing examples later, that the lens has very little to do with inherent 3D-pop.g
Every so often you forego the drama and simply say something that is correct. Examples of this are what I think of as “Good Scott.”
This is one of those times.
No one can really even define “pop” as a singular, objective thing, so there’s no way we’ll ever agree that some particular lens creates the best version of it.
We all have subjective notions of what it is, a sort of “I know it when I see it” leavened by a dose of “now that I see it and analyze what I’m seeing I can identify several things in the image that create this subjective response.”
They aren’t lenses. They are lighting, perspective, selective focus (and lighting) , composition, color and luminosity relationships and more. It can be created in painting, for God’s sake. I’ve seen it in photos made with film and digital technology, from iPhones, from expensive and cheap cameras, and from expensive and cheap lenses. How can it be the result of using that SuperMegaOpticon 37.5mm f/1.003 Whackagon Popicron (1945 version) lens and no other?
i swear that if I posted a pop-filled photograph from the SuperMegaOpticon 37.5mm f/1.003 Whackagon Popicron (1945 version) lens in this thread and said that it was from a kit zoom… that no one would see it. And if I posted a well composed and executed photograph made with the kit lens and falsely claimed it was made with the SuperMegaOpticon 37.5mm f/1.003 Whackagon Popicron (1945 version) lens that others would gush about how obviously superior the image was…
;-)