fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.90 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?

If you guys could keep my photo out of this back and forth, I’d appreciate it.
Nov 17, 2025 at 09:49 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.90 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
tsdevine wrote:
If you guys could keep my photo out of this back and forth, I’d appreciate it.


For what it's worth, I think your photo is a great example of subtle (not like fake 3d cut out) but definite pop.
Interesting, because I remember we had different views on previous photos posted here .
Nov 17, 2025 at 10:23 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.90 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
jamesdak wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
RustyBug wroteI'd say it is not a universally adopted practice for expecting PP to do all the rendering. Some folks will still prefer the natural aspect of the optic vs. pp.
Regarding: “ I'd say it is not a universally adopted practice for expecting PP to do all the rendering.” Hence threads like this one, right?

And no one suggests that “PP… do all the rendering.” Good lenses are still important, just not in the way and form that they were in the pre-digital past.
Well, as someone who utilizes very little post processing in his work I'll say the performance of a variety of lenses is still very important to me. I guess I still have a lot of the old school mindset that photography is about painting with the light, not manipulating pixels in post processing.

Well, that and I'll readily admit that I hardly now how to do anything in photoshop even with decades of using it, ! I certainly can't believe I'm the only one that still works this way. It seems to me that being an expert in post processing would just make me a sloppy photographer...maybe I'm wrong....

Of course purpose may come into play with how folks view this also. If my living was made off of it, I guess it would be a lot more vital for me to be proficient at the post process side of things. But since my photography is for me and the sheer joy of just doing it I can continue to feel and work the way I do.
Here is another view of how the editing process actually fits into photography these days. A
Every image you make is edited. Either by you or by someone else's algorythm. At least when you edit your own images they are closer to your own image edited to your own vision. This is true whether working analog and sending out for developing and printing, or digital and accepting someone else's algorithmic processing.
For sure, but just to an extent. When I see folks totally change the photograph via post process then it loses me. Like mentioned several post back about how easy it is to remove the tree "growing" out of the boys head. Seems doing stuff like that to me is just a lie. But to each their own. My photography is for me and I play by my own misguided set of rules. !


A perfectly reasonable position to hold.

Back when I was actively racing I had many friends that refused to adapt to the new technologies as they became available and accepted by the sanctioning organizations. Yes, they remained true to their traditions but stopped winning races and so stopped getting seats in cars. Rac9ng and the World moved on from them.
Nov 17, 2025 at 11:19 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.90 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?


1bwana1 wrote:
jamesdak wrote
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
RustyBug wroteI'd say it is not a universally adopted practice for expecting PP to do all the rendering. Some folks will still prefer the natural aspect of the optic vs. pp.
Regarding: “ I'd say it is not a universally adopted practice for expecting PP to do all the rendering.” Hence threads like this one, right?

And no one suggests that “PP… do all the rendering.” Good lenses are still important, just not in the way and form that they were in the pre-digital past.
Well, as someone who utilizes very little post processing in his work I'll say the performance of a variety of lenses is still very important to me. I guess I still have a lot of the old school mindset that photography is about painting with the light, not manipulating pixels in post processing.

Well, that and I'll readily admit that I hardly now how to do anything in photoshop even with decades of using it, ! I certainly can't believe I'm the only one that still works this way. It seems to me that being an expert in post processing would just make me a sloppy photographer...maybe I'm wrong....

Of course purpose may come into play with how folks view this also. If my living was made off of it, I guess it would be a lot more vital for me to be proficient at the post process side of things. But since my photography is for me and the sheer joy of just doing it I can continue to feel and work the way I do.
Here is another view of how the editing process actually fits into photography these days. A
Every image you make is edited. Either by you or by someone else's algorythm. At least when you edit your own images they are closer to your own image edited to your own vision. This is true whether working analog and sending out for developing and printing, or digital and accepting someone else's algorithmic processing.
For sure, but just to an extent. When I see folks totally change the photograph via post process then it loses me. Like mentioned several post back about how easy it is to remove the tree "growing" out of the boys head. Seems doing stuff like that to me is just a lie. But to each their own. My photography is for me and I play by my own misguided set of rules. !
A perfectly reasonable position to hold.

Back when I was actively racing I had many friends that refused to adapt to the new technologies as they became available and accepted by the sanctioning organizations. Yes, they remained true to their traditions but stopped winning races and so stopped getting seats in cars. Rac9ng and the World moved on from them.

For the amateur who sees their photography as a race for online likes, this comparison may be just as apt as for the professional who has to deliver what the masses want if they want to stay in business. Those who pursue photography out of passion, for its own sake, don't need to worry about such things.
Nov 17, 2025 at 11:53 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.90 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?


Nifty Fifty wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wrote
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wrote
gdanmitchell wroteRegarding: “ I'd say it is not a universally adopted practice for expecting PP to do all the rendering.” Hence threads like this one, right?

And no one suggests that “PP… do all the rendering.” Good lenses are still important, just not in the way and form that they were in the pre-digital past.
Well, as someone who utilizes very little post processing in his work I'll say the performance of a variety of lenses is still very important to me. I guess I still have a lot of the old school mindset that photography is about painting with the light, not manipulating pixels in post processing.

Well, that and I'll readily admit that I hardly now how to do anything in photoshop even with decades of using it, ! I certainly can't believe I'm the only one that still works this way. It seems to me that being an expert in post processing would just make me a sloppy photographer...maybe I'm wrong....

Of course purpose may come into play with how folks view this also. If my living was made off of it, I guess it would be a lot more vital for me to be proficient at the post process side of things. But since my photography is for me and the sheer joy of just doing it I can continue to feel and work the way I do.
Here is another view of how the editing process actually fits into photography these days. A
Every image you make is edited. Either by you or by someone else's algorythm. At least when you edit your own images they are closer to your own image edited to your own vision. This is true whether working analog and sending out for developing and printing, or digital and accepting someone else's algorithmic processing.
For sure, but just to an extent. When I see folks totally change the photograph via post process then it loses me. Like mentioned several post back about how easy it is to remove the tree "growing" out of the boys head. Seems doing stuff like that to me is just a lie. But to each their own. My photography is for me and I play by my own misguided set of rules. !
A perfectly reasonable position to hold.

Back when I was actively racing I had many friends that refused to adapt to the new technologies as they became available and accepted by the sanctioning organizations. Yes, they remained true to their traditions but stopped winning races and so stopped getting seats in cars. Rac9ng and the World moved on from them.
For the amateur who sees their photography as a race for online likes, this comparison may be just as apt as for the professional who has to deliver what the masses want if they want to stay in business. Those who pursue photography out of passion, for its own sake, don't need to worry about such things.


I think growth and learning is almost always good in any pursuit. Especially those I am passionate about.
Nov 17, 2025 at 11:57 AM
jamesdak
Offline
Details
p.90 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wrote
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wrote
gdanmitchell wroteRegarding: “ I'd say it is not a universally adopted practice for expecting PP to do all the rendering.” Hence threads like this one, right?

And no one suggests that “PP… do all the rendering.” Good lenses are still important, just not in the way and form that they were in the pre-digital past.
Well, as someone who utilizes very little post processing in his work I'll say the performance of a variety of lenses is still very important to me. I guess I still have a lot of the old school mindset that photography is about painting with the light, not manipulating pixels in post processing.

Well, that and I'll readily admit that I hardly now how to do anything in photoshop even with decades of using it, ! I certainly can't believe I'm the only one that still works this way. It seems to me that being an expert in post processing would just make me a sloppy photographer...maybe I'm wrong....

Of course purpose may come into play with how folks view this also. If my living was made off of it, I guess it would be a lot more vital for me to be proficient at the post process side of things. But since my photography is for me and the sheer joy of just doing it I can continue to feel and work the way I do.
Here is another view of how the editing process actually fits into photography these days. A
Every image you make is edited. Either by you or by someone else's algorythm. At least when you edit your own images they are closer to your own image edited to your own vision. This is true whether working analog and sending out for developing and printing, or digital and accepting someone else's algorithmic processing.
For sure, but just to an extent. When I see folks totally change the photograph via post process then it loses me. Like mentioned several post back about how easy it is to remove the tree "growing" out of the boys head. Seems doing stuff like that to me is just a lie. But to each their own. My photography is for me and I play by my own misguided set of rules. !
A perfectly reasonable position to hold.

Back when I was actively racing I had many friends that refused to adapt to the new technologies as they became available and accepted by the sanctioning organizations. Yes, they remained true to their traditions but stopped winning races and so stopped getting seats in cars. Rac9ng and the World moved on from them.
For the amateur who sees their photography as a race for online likes, this comparison may be just as apt as for the professional who has to deliver what the masses want if they want to stay in business. Those who pursue photography out of passion, for its own sake, don't need to worry about such things.


Exactly! For the same reason I still shoot DSLRs since they get the job done for me still in a lot of circumstances. And my other passion is cycling were a majority of my bikes are rimmed braked steel bikes that are fairly old. I love them and enjoy riding them and have no real use for the latest and greatest carbon fiber, disc braked bikes like the pro's ride. I'm perfectly comfortable with my choices.
Nov 17, 2025 at 11:59 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.90 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?


1bwana1 wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wrote
1bwana1 wrote
jamesdak wroteWell, as someone who utilizes very little post processing in his work I'll say the performance of a variety of lenses is still very important to me. I guess I still have a lot of the old school mindset that photography is about painting with the light, not manipulating pixels in post processing.

Well, that and I'll readily admit that I hardly now how to do anything in photoshop even with decades of using it, ! I certainly can't believe I'm the only one that still works this way. It seems to me that being an expert in post processing would just make me a sloppy photographer...maybe I'm wrong....

Of course purpose may come into play with how folks view this also. If my living was made off of it, I guess it would be a lot more vital for me to be proficient at the post process side of things. But since my photography is for me and the sheer joy of just doing it I can continue to feel and work the way I do.
Here is another view of how the editing process actually fits into photography these days. A
Every image you make is edited. Either by you or by someone else's algorythm. At least when you edit your own images they are closer to your own image edited to your own vision. This is true whether working analog and sending out for developing and printing, or digital and accepting someone else's algorithmic processing.
For sure, but just to an extent. When I see folks totally change the photograph via post process then it loses me. Like mentioned several post back about how easy it is to remove the tree "growing" out of the boys head. Seems doing stuff like that to me is just a lie. But to each their own. My photography is for me and I play by my own misguided set of rules. !
A perfectly reasonable position to hold.

Back when I was actively racing I had many friends that refused to adapt to the new technologies as they became available and accepted by the sanctioning organizations. Yes, they remained true to their traditions but stopped winning races and so stopped getting seats in cars. Rac9ng and the World moved on from them.
For the amateur who sees their photography as a race for online likes, this comparison may be just as apt as for the professional who has to deliver what the masses want if they want to stay in business. Those who pursue photography out of passion, for its own sake, don't need to worry about such things.
I think growth and learning is almost always good in any pursuit. Especially those I am passionate about.

Absolutely! But photography isn't synonymous with digital image editing. And everyone decides for themselves what result he likes and aim for, or at least he should. Because that, too, is something that needs to be learned.
Nov 17, 2025 at 12:11 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.90 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
tsdevine wroteIf you guys could keep my photo out of this back and forth, I’d appreciate it.
For what it's worth, I think your photo is a great example of subtle (not like fake 3d cut out) but definite pop.
Interesting, because I remember we had different views on previous photos posted here .



Well, hopefully I wasn't argumentative. If we didn't seem 100% aligned, doesn't mean we were 0% aligned either I would assume. In the 3D cut out reference, I might say that has "pop", which in the right context I guess I might have said it's 3D pop. But the ones that look like they have dimensionality, like I thought the one I posted did, I wasn't sure that always counted as 3D pop (maybe just 3D.)

In any case, it's hard to be absolutely right, or wrong, in anything when it comes to this.
Nov 17, 2025 at 02:19 PM
Fescue
Offline
Details
p.90 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
I don't know about lenses with the most 3D pop, but I sometimes get photographs with the Hasselblad 38V that give me that vibe. Here's a recent one:







*Edit - I tried to embed a larger size in a spoiler, but it didn't work. Is there functional syntax for that on this forum?
Nov 18, 2025 at 10:24 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.90 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
I remain convinced after all these years, and so many unconvincing examples later, that the lens has very little to do with inherent 3D-pop. I came across this photo from a few weeks back that was taken in the same type of lighting conditions that I routinely see the most 3D-ness...partly cloudy with a slight break in cloud cover that completely illuminates the subject while at the same time still being cloudy in the background...as if a spotlight or flash is on the subject.

Now, if a lens has better microcontrast than other, that's less editing you'd have to do to get to the same ending point, but the LENS ITSELF remains a rather meaningly piece of the puzzle. It's 95% light. I have gotten shots like this with every lens I own, and they are all in conditions just like this.

You can see that the edges of the statue even have a bit of shadow thanks to the directionality of the light, further separating the subject from the background. The more fully your subject is in focus the more pronounced the 3D effect can be, and of course the farther back your background is, the more the effect is enhanced.





Nov 18, 2025 at 11:53 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Fescue
Offline
Details
p.90 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
RoamingScott wrote:
I remain convinced after all these years, and so many unconvincing examples later, that the lens has very little to do with inherent 3D-pop. I came across this photo from a few weeks back that was taken in the same type of lighting conditions that I routinely see the most 3D-ness...partly cloudy with a slight break in cloud cover that completely illuminates the subject while at the same time still being cloudy in the background...as if a spotlight or flash is on the subject.

Now, if a lens has better microcontrast than other, that's less editing you'd have to do to
...Show more →

but... does that image have 3d pop?

I agree that light and framing are essential ingredients, as with any photographic effect, but I don't think a high degree of focus separation gets one to what (I guess maybe only) I consider 3d pop.

but this is a long thread, and I won't pretend to have read it. I'm sure this has all been hashed out ad nauseam.

Edited on Nov 18, 2025 at 03:52 PM · View previous versions
Nov 18, 2025 at 01:08 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.90 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Fescue wrote:
but... does that image have 3d pop?

I agree that light and framing are essential ingredients, as with any photographic effect, but I don't even think a high degree of focus separation gets one to what (I guess maybe only) I consider 3d pop.

but this is a long thread, and I won't pretend to have read it. I'm sure this has all been hashed out ad nauseam.


No, not to my eyes. It is too close to images where the subject looks like it has been pasted into the image on top of a background layer. Perhaps it also doesn't help with the OOF foreground hand. What I do see is some dimensionality in the statue but I don't get any 3D-kick.

I also think the "3D-conditions" are described in a too simplified way here: quoting RoamingScott: You can see that the edges of the statue even have a bit of shadow thanks to the directionality of the light, further separating the subject from the background. The more fully your subject is in focus the more pronounced the 3D effect can be, and of course the farther back your background is, the more the effect is enhanced.

Then again, we all probably see the world in slightly different ways so the above is based on my experience and my body functions.
Nov 18, 2025 at 02:34 PM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.90 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
It's kind of disappointing that there is not a mathematical analysis of the optical phenomenon "3D pop."
Maybe I missed it in there.

EBH
Nov 18, 2025 at 02:39 PM
Picture This!
Offline
Details
p.90 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
This is going to get discussed for another year and we will be in exactly the same spot - still wondering what 3D in a 2D medium really means and if your 3D is the same as my 3D.
Nov 18, 2025 at 03:36 PM
cbass
Offline
Details
p.90 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
RoamingScott wrote:
I remain convinced after all these years, and so many unconvincing examples later, that the lens has very little to do with inherent 3D-pop. I came across this photo from a few weeks back that was taken in the same type of lighting conditions that I routinely see the most 3D-ness...partly cloudy with a slight break in cloud cover that completely illuminates the subject while at the same time still being cloudy in the background...as if a spotlight or flash is on the subject.

Now, if a lens has better microcontrast than other, that's less editing you'd have to do to
...Show more →

Of course it's the light. Without dimensional light there is no way a lens will make something out of nothing. A lens is responsible to collect, bend, and focus the light. That is a given and yes without light a lens does nothing so it is 95% the light. But...lenses bend and focus the light differently and the transition from in focus to out of focus is affected by compromises made in aberration correction. So then the question becomes does that contribute any to 3D rendering and if so then how much.

Look at this link, particularly the three balls with different lighting: high contrast, mid tones, and flat.

https://photo-ebook.net/index.php/light1/

You can't change the light and you need the right light to make a dimensional image. However, lenses do not process light equally and there are differences. How much does this bring to the image if anything is the question all else being equal.

Nov 18, 2025 at 04:40 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.90 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
Subject separation from the BG and modeling provided by the light are well understood ... Scott's statue references those, not necessarily the dimensionality of z axis depth into the scene. Scott presents the statue as though it is an authoritative example ... and it's not even remotely close (imo) to what others are referencing / displaying in terms of spatial depth of a scene.

But, Scott thinks it is wonderful that everyone has been using lighting with a "natural spotlight" situation as he's indicated, so there's that. Curious what his actual light source is, because it doesn't look anything like what I've seen others presenting ... although, he alludes to it being presumptuously representative.

The fact of the matter is that there are numerous images that have been presented in all manner of lighting ... specular, diffuse, frontal, oblique, side, back, interior, mixed, etc. Scotts indication that his lighting example is the "magic sauce" everyone has been using is (imo) ... insert word of choice.
Nov 18, 2025 at 07:12 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.90 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
Subject separation from the BG and modeling provided by the light are well understood ... Scott's statue references those, not necessarily the dimensionality of z axis depth into the scene. Scott presents the statue as though it is an authoritative example ... and it's not even remotely close (imo) to what others are referencing / displaying in terms of spatial depth of a scene.

But, Scott thinks it is wonderful that everyone has been using lighting with a "natural spotlight" situation as he's indicated, so there's that. Curious what his actual light source is, because it doesn't look anything like what
...Show more →

That depth into a scene is what I'm often drawn to. It doesn't even need a singular subject, like my son sitting on the bench. And maybe that isn't 3D pop then, but some shots just cause something to click in my brain and it truly seems like I'm not looking at a 2 dimensional screen showing an image.

And I'm sure we see things differently, so what I see here may just be an ordinary shot to others, since it won't trigger the same perception of the scene as I have.





Nov 18, 2025 at 09:32 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.90 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
RoamingScott wrote:
I remain convinced after all these years, and so many unconvincing examples later, that the lens has very little to do with inherent 3D-pop.g


Every so often you forego the drama and simply say something that is correct. Examples of this are what I think of as “Good Scott.”

This is one of those times.

No one can really even define “pop” as a singular, objective thing, so there’s no way we’ll ever agree that some particular lens creates the best version of it.

We all have subjective notions of what it is, a sort of “I know it when I see it” leavened by a dose of “now that I see it and analyze what I’m seeing I can identify several things in the image that create this subjective response.”

They aren’t lenses. They are lighting, perspective, selective focus (and lighting) , composition, color and luminosity relationships and more. It can be created in painting, for God’s sake. I’ve seen it in photos made with film and digital technology, from iPhones, from expensive and cheap cameras, and from expensive and cheap lenses. How can it be the result of using that SuperMegaOpticon 37.5mm f/1.003 Whackagon Popicron (1945 version) lens and no other?

i swear that if I posted a pop-filled photograph from the SuperMegaOpticon 37.5mm f/1.003 Whackagon Popicron (1945 version) lens in this thread and said that it was from a kit zoom… that no one would see it. And if I posted a well composed and executed photograph made with the kit lens and falsely claimed it was made with the SuperMegaOpticon 37.5mm f/1.003 Whackagon Popicron (1945 version) lens that others would gush about how obviously superior the image was…

;-)
Nov 18, 2025 at 09:32 PM
jeffersoncasey
Offline
Details
p.90 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
I'm seeing two camps here in general based on opinions and pictures - the cut out camp, and the dimensionality camp.

To me, it's both, particularly more towards the dimensionality, contributed by tonality and micro contrast. Cut out look may or may not be desirable even if they look 3D to some people, sometimes they just looked like photographing a signboard over a blurred background.

...you don't need to agree with me after all. 🤪

And this is a boring example of what I like
Nov 18, 2025 at 10:14 PM
OregonSun
Offline
Details
p.90 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
3D POP is real, here's the most reasonable definition/explanation of it I've found: https://www.theatreofnoise.com/2024/04/that-elusive-3d-pop-defined.html

Lenses can enhance the effect, some to a surprising amount.

I shot each of the pairs below with different 28mm M42 lenses a few seconds apart with the same aperture, shutter speed and focus point.

I stood in the same place for each shot. One lens is obviously wider than the other despite their both being labeled as 28mm. Other slight framing differences are due to handholding. None are cropped.

Shot on Fuji Neopan Acros II B&W film, developed by my local lab.

Some exposure adjustments during negative conversion to correct the fact that one of them lets in about a half stop more light at the 'same' aperture. Aside from that, they all got the same additional processing in LR (minor adjustment to black point, straighten) and dust removal/output sharpening in PS.

1st in each pair: Bushnell Automatic 28mm f/2.8
2nd: MC Macro Revuenon 28mm f/3.5 - my copy, at least, is a clear contender for the MOST POP

























Nov 18, 2025 at 11:34 PM


FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister