chez wrote:
ruthenium wrote
Rainbow Chaser wrote
ruthenium wrote
I am a great believer in the transformative power of PP. I would humbly suggest that post-processing belongs in a separate thread. This particular thread about lenses can be incredibly useful to photographers who shoot in JPEG mode and/or want superior results out-of-camera with little or no post-processing. I know what you mean, and you are quite right, except that threads on FM have this seemingly inevitable and natural tendency to turn into a lovely exchange on totally irrelevant topics. Thus, this is quite normal in a way, because many of the FMers are here to socialize and have a pleasant chat and a pleasant time.
The idea of spending thousands and thousands of dollars on photography equipment while being not interested in processing the raw images is incomprehensible to me. To me, the time of taking the photos is like hunting, yet without the subsequent development this is like making the killing shot and then abandoning the game. I think that people who propagate the idea that one can do photography with minimal post-processing by acquiring a few exotic lenses do real harm on photography forums. People all have different priorities. In the film days, many shot slide without any darkroom work, yet many shot film and lived in their darkrooms, One is not more “real photography” than the other…just differing needs. We surely can accommodate both here on FM.
I almost exclusively photographed in black and white and loved working in the darkroom because it was true craftsmanship. You can give electronic image processing and its tools analog-sounding names all you want, but for me it's something completely different, not at all comparable. It's like, on the one hand, carving an object from a block by hand with a file, and on the other hand, operating a 3D printer. In both cases, the creative effort, superficially speaking, was the same. However, the completely different approach gives the final product a completely different meaning. I myself will never be able to love digital photography. It's nothing but utilitarian, without the slightest charm. Retro camera bodies, adapted vintage lenses, and film simulations don't change that, because the workflow remains the same. Computers instead of genuine craftsmanship.