DaveFP wrote:
Bob_S wrote
One thing I've learnt, 3D pop is in the eye of the viewer and totally subjective, the more sentimental the lens, the more 3D pop the viewer sees. Yes.
No.
I disagree, because, I've illustrated the phenomena.
I've uploaded images with what I think some degree of three dimensionality to them and went on and on about how I liked the 3D effect.
I named a nonsense lens and/or camera responsible for the image.
I received some degree of agreement about the 3D effect.
When I use the same image and name an expensive, old, or specific brand of lens I receive much more agreement and commentary on the effect.
I've done this a half dozen times over the last 12-15 years with the same results each time.
Don't underestimate how powerful the placebo of a device with either a high end brand and or name tag can influence a consumer.
What I've found too is that if the lens delivered a single photo with the effect, the owner would rave about how it does this, even though a significantly cheaper lens, new or 'vintage' would have delivered the exact same result for the same scene at the same focal distance, angle etc. etc.
Happy for you to disagree, I'd pay good money for a lens that consistently delivered more three dimensional images, but I cannot find one.
Sometimes a radioactive $10K Zeiss from 1960 that was used for a portrait of Marilyn Monroe will deliver as many 3D images as a Sony FE 1.8/50 on sale via eBay.