For the record, I do not consider an image with extremely shallow depth of field to be much more than a geeky experiment, typically with a result that has no actual worth of any kind. No newspaper, no magazine of any variant, no art gallery and no other source is interested in such images, except other photography geeks, and they wont pay you either.
To me, 3D pop is if you can "walk into a scene", as it happends especially with certain medium and large format lenses. Specifically it also doesnt require that you use the lens wide open either. We had examples for this in this thread before.
Also, there is definitely the problem of too shallow depth of field. Like the many many head portraits you can find on the net in which one eye is sharp and in focus, and the other is already substantly blurred by a definitely *too* shallow depth of field. Such images are really mostly irritating to look at. You usually want ALL of the subject in focus, and the subject in this case is the whole face, and certainly both eyes. While a certain amount of blurr is of course unavoiable if the eyes are not on the same focus plane, and the amount of blurr that is still tolerable is subjective, it definitely not desireable to have too much shallow depth of field.