Good advice is to be wary of any 'study' that asks anonymous photo forum readers to indicate whether they 'see 3D' in any image, because visual skills vary (very) significantly, down to very small p values. You would need to control for visual skills in the respondent sample.
Whether you see more 3D in images from a certain lens as compared with other lenses is strongly influenced by your visual skills, and very few ever do any vision training. This extremely important aspect of sensory performance has received belated attention in recent decades. Modern lifestyles appear to be very damaging to visual processing. Despite its importance, we need to keep the chat lighthearted so just a few quotes for now:
'vision encompasses a broader meaning as the mental process of deriving meaning from what is seen and is the output of visual pathway integrity, visual efficiency and visual information processing.'
'The eyes send information to the brain where it is integrated and interpreted as a three-dimensional (3D) phenomenon. The integration of visual information from both eyes into a 3D image is called fusion.'
'The perception of color affects visual acuity. Some people have difficulty discriminating between red and green, or between blue and yellow. This color deficiency is found in about 8 to 10% of males and less than 1% of females..'
'when the performer "looks" or fixates the eyes, information is gathered. The location, order, and duration of these fixations are assumed to reflect the perceptual decision making strategy used to extract information from the environment'
'In totality, vision is a learned complex and developed set of functions that involve a multitude of skills'
'..training of the visual skills following a definite approach is intended to improve these skills with sensory integration and improve the ability to interpret what is seen.'
If you could see as others see, what a surprise that would be.