Generally agree, but sometimes shots with a lot in focus can look 3D as well, but it's a different look.
I agree my shot above looked flat on here. At full resolution, less so. The B&W above has a bit of depth to it, but not the same as the cutout of the horse or John Dizzo's shots.
RustyBug wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Usually lenses with smooth focus transition zone do not have the greatest 3D pop. Is that your experience as well? +1
Those lenses that have variable transition zones seem to create the strongest effect ... WHEN, the composition places the subject / spatial relationship in the right focal distance / area of the frame / lens to accentuate the transition rate difference.