fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.31 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
That isn’t 3D pop,its a lovely image though. Brighten her face & use less foreground and more sky
All 1.2 lenses have 3D pop,1.4 too....

gunmetal wrote:
I'm still a fan of my Loxia 50 copy. I would be all over the CV 50, but I'm such a fan of the rendering of the L50. Not sure if it's "pop", "3d" or what. I just like it.

Feb 28, 2020 at 01:30 PM
seanj
Offline
Details
p.31 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
I've spent time trying to discover it in various lenses. Even when I have images that seem to demonstrate more of a 3D rendering, it is not apparent in the vast majority of other images I have taken with that lens. Here's the Sony Zeiss 55/1.8. I think the lighting contributes more to the effect and having the various points of interest all on the same plane from the lens, but I also have this too wide open (f/2) to achieve the kind of 3D that is better defined on the first page in one of the first posts (at least of this recent version of this thread).

Feb 28, 2020 at 02:39 PM
JohnDizzo15
Offline
Details
p.31 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
At this point, the two lenses in my lineup that consistently give me (what I perceive to be) the effect are the Sigma 20/1.4 and 35/1.2.

I've posted plenty from the 20mm earlier in the thread. Here's a few very recent ones from the 35.

Sigma 35/1.2 by Johndizzo15, on Flickr

Couple cross-posted ones with the 35.
Sigma 35/1.2 by Johndizzo15, on Flickr
Sigma 35/1.2 by Johndizzo15, on Flickr
Sigma 35/1.2 Art E Mount by Johndizzo15, on Flickr
Feb 28, 2020 at 05:11 PM
osv2
Offline
[X]
Details
p.31 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
fe90 is probably the closest thing that i have to the so-called "3d pop"

Feb 28, 2020 at 05:17 PM
jakelindsay
Offline
Details
p.31 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
KarmaKramer wrote:
That isn’t 3D pop,its a lovely image though. Brighten her face & use less foreground and more sky
All 1.2 lenses have 3D pop,1.4 too....

gunmetal wroteI'm still a fan of my Loxia 50 copy. I would be all over the CV 50, but I'm such a fan of the rendering of the L50. Not sure if it's "pop", "3d" or what. I just like it.


We were going for foreground bokeh with the taller wheat. But I agree that I could definitely lighten her face. If i'm understanding you correctly (and I understand very little about this, lol), aperture is what gives the lens 3D pop? I've always felt like my Batis lineup has quite a bit of pop, but they're mostly F2 with only the 85 being 1.8. Maybe I'm attributing just their color rendering to "pop"?
Feb 28, 2020 at 05:45 PM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.31 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Not an expert in 3D, but I like what I see in these recent shots with the Sony 200-600.

_DGL0012 by Douglas Liu, on Flickr



_DGL0473 by Douglas Liu, on Flickr


_DGL0031 by Douglas Liu, on Flickr
Feb 28, 2020 at 05:50 PM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.31 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
“33 days, sir”
Feb 28, 2020 at 05:55 PM
KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.31 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
Aperture plays a major role, where you stand while taking the photo/framing also matters.“3D pop” to me isn’t about color. Zeiss “pop” is about color. The 3D part is about depth of field and bokeh. Both enhanced by 1.2 or 1.4 lenses. Compose a full length portrait at 1.2 or 1.4 allowing some foreground and you’ll see it.


gunmetal wrote:
KarmaKramer wroteThat isn’t 3D pop,its a lovely image though. Brighten her face & use less foreground and more sky
All 1.2 lenses have 3D pop,1.4 too....

gunmetal wroteI'm still a fan of my Loxia 50 copy. I would be all over the CV 50, but I'm such a fan of the rendering of the L50. Not sure if it's "pop", "3d" or what. I just like it.
We were going for foreground bokeh with the taller wheat. But I agree that I could definitely lighten her face. If i'm understanding you correctly (and I understand very little about this, lol), aperture is what gives the lens 3D pop? I've always felt like my Batis lineup has quite a bit of pop, but they're mostly F2 with only the 85 being 1.8. Maybe I'm attributing just their color rendering to "pop"?

Feb 28, 2020 at 06:06 PM
bestdayz
Offline
Details
p.31 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Pentax 31 1.8 isn’t too shabby
Zeiss 135/2
Zeiss 28/2
Feb 29, 2020 at 02:36 AM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.31 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
KarmaKramer wrote:
Aperture plays a major role, where you stand while taking the photo/framing also matters.“3D pop” to me isn’t about color. Zeiss “pop” is about color. The 3D part is about depth of field and bokeh. Both enhanced by 1.2 or 1.4 lenses. Compose a full length portrait at 1.2 or 1.4 allowing some foreground and you’ll see it.

gunmetal wrote
KarmaKramer wroteThat isn’t 3D pop,its a lovely image though. Brighten her face & use less foreground and more sky
All 1.2 lenses have 3D pop,1.4 too....

gunmetal wroteI'm still a fan of my Loxia 50 copy. I would be all over the CV 50, but I'm such a fan of the rendering of the L50. Not sure if it's "pop", "3d" or what. I just like it.
We were going for foreground bokeh with the taller wheat. But I agree that I could definitely lighten her face. If i'm understanding you correctly (and I understand very little about this, lol), aperture is what gives the lens 3D pop? I've always felt like my Batis lineup has quite a bit of pop, but they're mostly F2 with only the 85 being 1.8. Maybe I'm attributing just their color rendering to "pop"?


I strongly disagree. I actually think "3D pop" is reduced when DOF is too thin, because it doesn't look real and the background is not part of the image anymore.
To me, you get the most 3D pop from well corrected lenses at medium distance and medium aperture. The background should just be a little out of focus and the subject tack sharp.

Like this... Fujinon GF 45/2.8 @ f/4:


3221 by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr
Feb 29, 2020 at 02:54 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.31 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
I don’t see it.

Makten wrote:
KarmaKramer wroteAperture plays a major role, where you stand while taking the photo/framing also matters.“3D pop” to me isn’t about color. Zeiss “pop” is about color. The 3D part is about depth of field and bokeh. Both enhanced by 1.2 or 1.4 lenses. Compose a full length portrait at 1.2 or 1.4 allowing some foreground and you’ll see it.

gunmetal wrote
KarmaKramer wroteThat isn’t 3D pop,its a lovely image though. Brighten her face & use less foreground and more sky
All 1.2 lenses have 3D pop,1.4 too....

gunmetal wroteI'm still a fan of my Loxia 50 copy. I would be all over the CV 50, but I'm such a fan of the rendering of the L50. Not sure if it's "pop", "3d" or what. I just like it.
We were going for foreground bokeh with the taller wheat. But I agree that I could definitely lighten her face. If i'm understanding you correctly (and I understand very little about this, lol), aperture is what gives the lens 3D pop? I've always felt like my Batis lineup has quite a bit of pop, but they're mostly F2 with only the 85 being 1.8. Maybe I'm attributing just their color rendering to "pop"?
I strongly disagree. I actually think "3D pop" is reduced when DOF is too thin, because it doesn't look real and the background is not part of the image anymore.
To me, you get the most 3D pop from well corrected lenses at medium distance and medium aperture. The background should just be a little out of focus and the subject tack sharp.

Like this... Fujinon GF 45/2.8 @ f/4:

https://live.staticflickr.com/7842/40415882613_e2b6501005_o.jpg
3221 by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr

Feb 29, 2020 at 07:15 AM
Alex W
Offline
Details
p.31 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
While my faster lens such as the 135mm GM and 35mm 1.2 Sigma have great 3D pop even my 200-600mm does okay when the background distance, subject and lighting all line up correctly.









Feb 29, 2020 at 07:17 AM
SoundHound
Offline
Details
p.31 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
+1 Sigma 35mm F1.2.Also 400GM.
Feb 29, 2020 at 09:01 AM
padrelar
Offline
Details
p.31 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
The lens you don't have.
Feb 29, 2020 at 09:35 AM
darrellc
Offline
Details
p.31 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
I agree with this. I thought the Loxia 35 had a very real sense of depth and 3Dness stopped down to maybe f3.2-3.5. My Contax 35-70 had the same realistic sense of depth. Even stopped down past f3.4.

You can create a sense of pop with DOF and with various visual cues and elements (we had a thread about this where I and others cited painting techniques that illicit depth perception) with probably any lens. I imagine these cues in an image trump lenses technical considerations.

But the two lenses cited above always stood out for their ability to render a realistic sense of depth stopped down a bit. They’d always stand out and surprise when reviewing images.

It might be interesting to consider lenses that lack pop even at wide apertures to try to understand what differentiates them.

Makten wrote:
KarmaKramer wroteAperture plays a major role, where you stand while taking the photo/framing also matters.“3D pop” to me isn’t about color. Zeiss “pop” is about color. The 3D part is about depth of field and bokeh. Both enhanced by 1.2 or 1.4 lenses. Compose a full length portrait at 1.2 or 1.4 allowing some foreground and you’ll see it.

gunmetal wrote
KarmaKramer wroteThat isn’t 3D pop,its a lovely image though. Brighten her face & use less foreground and more sky
All 1.2 lenses have 3D pop,1.4 too....

gunmetal wroteI'm still a fan of my Loxia 50 copy. I would be all over the CV 50, but I'm such a fan of the rendering of the L50. Not sure if it's "pop", "3d" or what. I just like it.
We were going for foreground bokeh with the taller wheat. But I agree that I could definitely lighten her face. If i'm understanding you correctly (and I understand very little about this, lol), aperture is what gives the lens 3D pop? I've always felt like my Batis lineup has quite a bit of pop, but they're mostly F2 with only the 85 being 1.8. Maybe I'm attributing just their color rendering to "pop"?
I strongly disagree. I actually think "3D pop" is reduced when DOF is too thin, because it doesn't look real and the background is not part of the image anymore.
To me, you get the most 3D pop from well corrected lenses at medium distance and medium aperture. The background should just be a little out of focus and the subject tack sharp.

Like this... Fujinon GF 45/2.8 @ f/4:

https://live.staticflickr.com/7842/40415882613_e2b6501005_o.jpg
3221 by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr

Feb 29, 2020 at 10:32 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.31 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
Makten wrote:
KarmaKramer wroteAperture plays a major role, where you stand while taking the photo/framing also matters.“3D pop” to me isn’t about color. Zeiss “pop” is about color. The 3D part is about depth of field and bokeh. Both enhanced by 1.2 or 1.4 lenses. Compose a full length portrait at 1.2 or 1.4 allowing some foreground and you’ll see it.

gunmetal wrote
KarmaKramer wroteThat isn’t 3D pop,its a lovely image though. Brighten her face & use less foreground and more sky
All 1.2 lenses have 3D pop,1.4 too....

gunmetal wroteI'm still a fan of my Loxia 50 copy. I would be all over the CV 50, but I'm such a fan of the rendering of the L50. Not sure if it's "pop", "3d" or what. I just like it.
We were going for foreground bokeh with the taller wheat. But I agree that I could definitely lighten her face. If i'm understanding you correctly (and I understand very little about this, lol), aperture is what gives the lens 3D pop? I've always felt like my Batis lineup has quite a bit of pop, but they're mostly F2 with only the 85 being 1.8. Maybe I'm attributing just their color rendering to "pop"?
I strongly disagree. I actually think "3D pop" is reduced when DOF is too thin, because it doesn't look real and the background is not part of the image anymore.
To me, you get the most 3D pop from well corrected lenses at medium distance and medium aperture. The background should just be a little out of focus and the subject tack sharp.

Like this... Fujinon GF 45/2.8 @ f/4:

https://live.staticflickr.com/7842/40415882613_e2b6501005_o.jpg
3221 by Martin Hertsius, on Flickr


Agree. Shallow DOF is not required and in some cases it's a detriment to "3D pop". Aside from the lens' characteristics, I think that proper lighting is a more important factor.

Usually lenses with smooth focus transition zone do not have the greatest 3D pop. Is that your experience as well?
Feb 29, 2020 at 10:45 AM
buggz
Offline
Details
p.31 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
For me, 3D pop appears with light polarization in addition to subject isolation.
I'm not certain there is such a thing as one lens over another does it ALL the time.
Certain lenses probably more than others...
Feb 29, 2020 at 01:24 PM
AndereObjektiv
Offline
Details
p.31 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?






summarit-s 120
Feb 29, 2020 at 01:25 PM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.31 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
KarmaKramer wrote:
I don’t see it.


Then we don't have the same definition of "3D pop".

Fred Miranda wrote:
Usually lenses with smooth focus transition zone do not have the greatest 3D pop. Is that your experience as well?


Generally, yes, but I think it is because such lenses are often sharper than those with a smooth transition zone. The Zeiss 35/2 Distagon is a striking example of the opposite though, in that it has THE most 3D pop I've ever seen, and a very smooth transition (but not very smooth bokeh). I've been thinking of getting one again but since I now shoot the GFX it would be of limited use, even though it should do fine at 33x33 mm.
Feb 29, 2020 at 02:40 PM
hasenbein
Offline
Details
p.31 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?


AndereObjektiv wrote:
https://i.imgur.com/2wsN5jA.jpg

summarit-s 120

No significant "3d pop" there.
But most probably you have to somehow justify buying this expensive Leica stuff, so you of course try hard to see some "special rendering" :-)
Mar 01, 2020 at 01:17 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister