philip_pj wrote:
To hopefully show the dramatic effect color handling can have on 3D, here are two images, one from a lens 30 years old and the other from a lens 30 months old. Both images lack leading lines and both are over 50mm in focal length, shot in similar light/time of day. One image lacks colour tone variation (hue gradation) and thus suffers a lack of 3D; the other has well-drawn colour gradients which assist the viewer in understanding the photo dynamic, front to back. I could provide details but if you see it, you'll know.
The first image is beautiful and does indeed have a 3D look and a rich color palette.
The second image is a tougher subject. The range of light to dark is greater in this image, primarily because of the lighter sand, river, and mountain colors. So overall there is a larger color tonal gradient in image two. But it is the layout of that gradient fails to give that 3D pop. There are concentrated areas of relative monotones in the river, the sand field in the forefront, and the large sandbar to the right of the river in the upper center of the image. The image has a patchy quilt-like spread of colors, not the smooth gradients seen in the first image. The image is also a bit overexposed, to my eye. Overall a very flat and, IMO, much less appealing image than the first.
A great example of how the layout of hue gradients contribute to “3D pop.”