fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.19 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
Ripolini wroteThe more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
the question is not which ones show good 3D, but do you think the one with greater dof has more or less 3D than the one with less dof.


The issue is "separation" between areas in focus and the rest of the image. Please, do not confuse DOF with the way the lens renders the transition between planes. IMO, three-dimensional rendering comes from transition between focus plane and other planes, i.e. if the transition is smooth or "abrupt" (sharp, steep, etc.). From a physical point of view, I guess the transition could be partly determined by how much quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs.
A smooth transition is more similar to what our eyes perceive, thus contributing to 3D illusion.
Images with shallow DOF have a visual impact for sure. But this is not necessarily related to 3D illusion.

Edited on May 02, 2019 at 02:38 AM · View previous versions
May 02, 2019 at 12:05 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.19 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ripolini wrote:
sebboh wrote
Ripolini wroteThe more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
the question is not which ones show good 3D, but do you think the one with greater dof has more or less 3D than the one with less dof.
The issue is "separation" between areas in focus and the rest of the image. Please, do not confuse DOF with the way the lens renders the transition between planes. IMO, three-dimensional rendering comes from transition between focus plane and other planes, i.e. if the transition is smooth or "abrupt" (sharp, steep, etc.). From a physical point of view, I guess the transition could be partly determined by how much quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs.
A smooth transition is more similar to what or
...Show more →

yes it would be better to have a rapid transitioning lens and slow transitioning lens shot at the same aperture, but i don't have any image samples already available that show a rapid transition vs a slow transition at the same aperture and the transition steepness is mostly determined by how quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs. in any case, for many of the images where people think they see 3D pop the transition zone isn't really visible and i just want to see what people are actually looking for since many people seem to be choosing completely orthogonal criteria for deciding if something has 3Dness.
May 02, 2019 at 12:36 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.19 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
... for many of the images where people think they see 3D pop the transition zone isn't really visible ...


Yes. People believe that the shallower the DOF the higher the 3Dness. We are lucky Giotto and Piero della Francesca died long time ago and never read fora
May 02, 2019 at 02:44 AM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.19 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
Ripolini wroteThe more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
Makten wroteIf that's your opinion I strongly disagree.
quick guys, which one looks more 3D to you (open in separate tabs and switch back and forth):
A B

A B

A B

A B



I don't see any "3D" at all in the first two sets. The two last ones though! And I think the shallower DOF (or rather the larger background blur) looks more 3D in both those. It's not a large difference and mainly because of the very cluttered background.

Edit: However, the 3D-ness would probably decline if DOF was even shallower. Enough is enough.
May 02, 2019 at 03:48 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.19 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
Ripolini wroteThe more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
Makten wroteIf that's your opinion I strongly disagree.
quick guys, which one looks more 3D to you (open in separate tabs and switch back and forth):
A B

A B

A B

A B



Two sets at the bottom have tremendous 3D (didn't AB)

May 02, 2019 at 04:32 AM
Tirpitz666
Offline
Details
p.19 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
I would agree that I've no "3D feeling" in the first two sets, in the last two definitely more and to my eyes I'd say more in shots A than B.

At least for me, a tad more blur helps in that regard, but for the effect to be convincing enough the background should remain pretty discernible (like in shots A), so that the eyes and brain are still somehow "tricked" in thinking that they are looking at something "real" and "3D" rather than an "artistic" mass of blur and a super sharp subject sticking out.
May 02, 2019 at 05:41 AM
WhyFi
Offline
Details
p.19 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
The first two pair, I'm just not getting much of the effect, tbh. With the third set, decent effect in both but neither significantly better than the other (I do find it curious that the subject contrast seems to be higher on the larger aperture shot). Last set, the smaller aperture shot (B) has the better effect, though it's pretty strong in both.
May 02, 2019 at 07:47 AM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.19 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
Agree on the surface but is there even an objective measure of this? Could we agree on any lenses that have a quick or slow transition?

sebboh wrote:
Ripolini wrote
sebboh wrote
Ripolini wroteThe more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
the question is not which ones show good 3D, but do you think the one with greater dof has more or less 3D than the one with less dof.
The issue is "separation" between areas in focus and the rest of the image. Please, do not confuse DOF with the way the lens renders the transition between planes. IMO, three-dimensional rendering comes from transition between focus plane and other planes, i.e. if the transition is smooth or "abrupt" (sharp, steep, etc.). From a physical point of view, I guess the transition could be partly determined by how much quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs.
A smooth transition is more similar to what or eyes perceive, thus contributing to 3D illusion.
Images with shallow DOF have a visual impact for sure. But this is not necessarily related to 3D illusion.
yes it would be better to have a rapid transitioning lens and slow transitioning lens shot at the same aperture, but i don't have any image samples already available that show a rapid transition vs a slow transition at the same aperture and the transition steepness is mostly determined by how quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs. in any case, for many of the images where people think they see 3D pop the transition zone isn't really visible and i just want to
...Show more →
May 02, 2019 at 10:35 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.19 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Agree on the surface but is there even an objective measure of this? Could we agree on any lenses that have a quick or slow transition?

sebboh wrote
Ripolini wrote
sebboh wrote
Ripolini wroteThe more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
the question is not which ones show good 3D, but do you think the one with greater dof has more or less 3D than the one with less dof.
The issue is "separation" between areas in focus and the rest of the image. Please, do not confuse DOF with the way the lens renders the transition between planes. IMO, three-dimensional rendering comes from transition between focus plane and other planes, i.e. if the transition is smooth or "abrupt" (sharp, steep, etc.). From a physical point of view, I guess the transition could be partly determined by how much quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs.
A smooth transition is more similar to what or eyes perceive, thus contributing to 3D illusion.
Images with shallow DOF have a visual impact for sure. But this is not necessarily related to 3D illusion.
yes it would be better to have a rapid transitioning lens and slow transitioning lens shot at the same aperture, but i don't have any image samples already available that show a rapid transition vs a slow transition at the same aperture and the transition steepness is mostly determined by how quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs. in any case, for many of the images where people think they see 3D pop the transition zone isn't really visible and i just want to see what people are actually looking for since many people seem to be choosing completely orthogonal criteria for deciding if something has 3Dness.


could just do a ruler test, focus on a ruler at a fixed distance and compare different lenses of the same focal length to see differences in the transition. though maybe a textured surface would be better?

May 02, 2019 at 11:33 AM
Sauseschritt
Offline
Details
p.19 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
realVivek wrote:
I am not alone if you do not ignore the many others who posted here.


I have no clue what you're trying to say.

All I was pointing out a strict logical consequence of what you said.

Nothing more.



Also you just made a "eat shit, millions of flies cant be wrong" kind of argument there. Which yields nothing but a shrug from my side.

Facts dont care about belief.

Just because many people believe something thats actually false doesnt make that any less false, or more true. Just because only one guy believes a thing thats actually true, or maybe even nobody at all believes such a thing, doesnt make it any less true, or more false.


May 02, 2019 at 11:38 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.19 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
Too finely textured and micro contrast will come into play. Too course and it's meaningless. Ruler is only really good in one axis. presumably the CoC could vary in the saggital and tangential (sorry if my spelling is off). I'd think some sort of fine b&w diamond pattern or a series of b&w crosses on a grid would be ideal, but I don't have a pattern like that... Then you have to see if it falls off different close up (easier to test) or at portrait distance (wee bit harder)...

I think it'd be interesting but don't think I'm up for it!

sebboh wrote:
Mathieu18 wroteAgree on the surface but is there even an objective measure of this? Could we agree on any lenses that have a quick or slow transition?

sebboh wrote
Ripolini wrote
sebboh wrote
Ripolini wroteThe more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
the question is not which ones show good 3D, but do you think the one with greater dof has more or less 3D than the one with less dof.
The issue is "separation" between areas in focus and the rest of the image. Please, do not confuse DOF with the way the lens renders the transition between planes. IMO, three-dimensional rendering comes from transition between focus plane and other planes, i.e. if the transition is smooth or "abrupt" (sharp, steep, etc.). From a physical point of view, I guess the transition could be partly determined by how much quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs.
A smooth transition is more similar to what or eyes perceive, thus contributing to 3D illusion.
Images with shallow DOF have a visual impact for sure. But this is not necessarily related to 3D illusion.
yes it would be better to have a rapid transitioning lens and slow transitioning lens shot at the same aperture, but i don't have any image samples already available that show a rapid transition vs a slow transition at the same aperture and the transition steepness is mostly determined by how quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs. in any case, for many of the images where people think they see 3D pop the transition zone isn't really visible and i just want to see what people are actually looking for since many people seem to be choosing completely orthogonal criteria for deciding if something has 3Dness.
could just do a ruler test, focus on a ruler at a fixed distance and compare different lenses of the same focal length to see differences in the transition. though maybe a textured surface would be better?



May 02, 2019 at 11:38 AM
darrellc
Offline
Details
p.19 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Perhaps lenses that are easy to focus manually with focus peaking identify lenses with rapid transitions between in and out of focus... from personal experience, the ZM 50 Sonnar and the OM 50/2 Macro seemed to have very “peaky” focus peaking with a steep gradient before and after point of focus down around f/2.8 or faster. They were very easy to focus manually. I’ve other lenses that are challenging to manually focus in similar focal and aperture range.
May 02, 2019 at 11:41 AM
darrellc
Offline
Details
p.19 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Wikipedia has some interesting articles on depth perception, stereopsis, and binocular and monocular cues of depth perception.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depth_perception

The article on monocular cues is particularly relevant as they can be represented in two dimensions (and seen with one eye): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monocular_vision

Interesting quote from that article, as one could possibly apply the same strategy to photography by looking for these patterns in the natural or man made environment or perhaps enhancing in post: “Some painters, notably Cézanne, employ "warm" pigments (red, yellow and orange) to bring features towards the viewer, and "cool" ones (blue, violet, and blue-green) to indicate the part of a form that curves away from the picture plane.”



Edited on May 02, 2019 at 12:02 PM · View previous versions
May 02, 2019 at 11:46 AM
WhyFi
Offline
Details
p.19 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
darrellc wrote:
Interesting quote from that article, as one could apply the same strategy to photography: “Some painters, notably Cézanne, employ "warm" pigments (red, yellow and orange) to bring features towards the viewer, and "cool" ones (blue, violet, and blue-green) to indicate the part of a form that curves away from the picture plane.”



Interesting. This is a technique that's long been used in landscape painting to simulate depth/atmosphere, but I hadn't heard of someone using it on smaller scale forms.

May 02, 2019 at 11:49 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.19 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Piet Mondriaan took this to yet another level.

WhyFi wrote:
darrellc wroteInteresting quote from that article, as one could apply the same strategy to photography: “Some painters, notably Cézanne, employ "warm" pigments (red, yellow and orange) to bring features towards the viewer, and "cool" ones (blue, violet, and blue-green) to indicate the part of a form that curves away from the picture plane.”
Interesting. This is a technique that's long been used in landscape painting to simulate depth/atmosphere, but I hadn't heard of someone using it on smaller scale forms.



May 02, 2019 at 11:52 AM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.19 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
Curious, do either of these look more or less 3D?














May 02, 2019 at 12:02 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.19 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
darrellc wrote:
Wikipedia has some interesting articles on depth perception, stereopsis, and binocular and monocular cues of depth perception.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depth_perception

The article on monocular cues is particularly relevant as they can be represented in two dimensions (and seen with one eye): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monocular_vision

Interesting quote from that article, as one could apply the same strategy to photography: “Some painters, notably Cézanne, employ "warm" pigments (red, yellow and orange) to bring features towards the viewer, and "cool" ones (blue, violet, and blue-green) to indicate the part of a form that curves away from the picture plane.”



it's worth noting that you brain will often ignore stereo cues when they conflict with monocular depth cues (particularly at greater subject distances).

May 02, 2019 at 12:06 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.19 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Curious, do either of these look more or less 3D?


the last one looks the most 3D to me, though the differences are very small (flipping between tabs). i think it might just be due to the greater vignetting and distortion.
May 02, 2019 at 12:10 PM
WhyFi
Offline
Details
p.19 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Curious, do either of these look more or less 3D?


Not to me - none of them really jumps out.

May 02, 2019 at 04:07 PM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.19 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Curious, do either of these look more or less 3D?


No, not to me. The first and last looks like the same image with and without correction for distortion and vignetting.
May 02, 2019 at 04:18 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister