Too finely textured and micro contrast will come into play. Too course and it's meaningless. Ruler is only really good in one axis. presumably the CoC could vary in the saggital and tangential (sorry if my spelling is off). I'd think some sort of fine b&w diamond pattern or a series of b&w crosses on a grid would be ideal, but I don't have a pattern like that... Then you have to see if it falls off different close up (easier to test) or at portrait distance (wee bit harder)...
I think it'd be interesting but don't think I'm up for it!
sebboh wrote:
Mathieu18 wrote
Agree on the surface but is there even an objective measure of this? Could we agree on any lenses that have a quick or slow transition?
sebboh wrote
Ripolini wrote
sebboh wrote
Ripolini wrote
The more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon". the question is not which ones show good 3D, but do you think the one with greater dof has more or less 3D than the one with less dof. The issue is "separation" between areas in focus and the rest of the image. Please, do not confuse DOF with the way the lens renders the transition between planes. IMO, three-dimensional rendering comes from transition between focus plane and other planes, i.e. if the transition is smooth or "abrupt" (sharp, steep, etc.). From a physical point of view, I guess the transition could be partly determined by how much quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs.
A smooth transition is more similar to what or eyes perceive, thus contributing to 3D illusion.
Images with shallow DOF have a visual impact for sure. But this is not necessarily related to 3D illusion. yes it would be better to have a rapid transitioning lens and slow transitioning lens shot at the same aperture, but i don't have any image samples already available that show a rapid transition vs a slow transition at the same aperture and the transition steepness is mostly determined by how quickly, or slowly, the enlargement of the circle of confusion in the adjacent planes in front of or behind the focus plane occurs. in any case, for many of the images where people think they see 3D pop the transition zone isn't really visible and i just want to see what people are actually looking for since many people seem to be choosing completely orthogonal criteria for deciding if something has 3Dness. could just do a ruler test, focus on a ruler at a fixed distance and compare different lenses of the same focal length to see differences in the transition. though maybe a textured surface would be better?