fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
Makten
Offline
Details
p.17 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ripolini wrote:
Makten wroteI think you are misinterpreting the word "sharp" here. Or maybe the translation isn't the best, because I believe they mean that the transition is steep. Which means that you have your subject (at least almost) entirely in focus, and then the background blur comes in very rapidly behind it.
I understood perfectly. And I disagree. As I tried to explain, smooth (not "sharp" or "steep") transitions between focus plane and planes in front of and behind it help providing a realistic visual effect (i.e. you look at a 2D image but you feel like you're looking at a real object in 3D space); in my opinion 3D pop has little relation, if any, with shallow DOF. Confusing shallow DOF with 3D pop is a rather common mistake.


Sure, but I don't think that is what Zeiss meant, and that you misinterpret their use of "sharp transition". I agree with your opinion, it's not about that.
May 01, 2019 at 08:46 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.17 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Makten wrote:
Ripolini wrote... in my opinion 3D pop has little relation, if any, with shallow DOF. Confusing shallow DOF with 3D pop is a rather common mistake.
Sure, but I don't think that is what Zeiss meant, and that you misinterpret their use of "sharp transition". I agree with your opinion, it's not about that.


Ripolini wrote:
The term "3D POP" is used by Zeiss marketing guys, who most likely are neither photographers nor lens designers. When speaking about "3D POP" of Zeiss lenses, those guys say that their lenses "help photos convey the feeling that the areas in focus appear almost separate to the rest of the image. At wide-open aperture, they create the magical ZEISS 3D pop effect and deliver a harmonious bokeh for great visual impact." They confuse three dimensional illusion with shallow DOF. They should study Piero della Francesca and read his De Prospectiva pingendi. But they won't read it; they are only
...Show more →



The more the areas in focus appear separate to the rest of the image, the more the picture appears like a 2D "cartoon".
May 01, 2019 at 09:19 AM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.17 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
I'm working on it... give me a week.

ftllens wrote:
Honestly, the only way to compare lens abilities to express 3d pop (I also think this is a term that should disappear due to its horrible lack of precision) is to take photos in a flat (or identical) lighting situation in a no depth composition at the same f stop with the same camera body using the same raw processor with no post processing.

Then take those images with exif removed and presented side by side. Not to say there aren't lenses that exhibit this effect straight out of camera, but there are too many variables that can increase that effect
...Show more →

May 01, 2019 at 10:19 AM
WhyFi
Offline
Details
p.17 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
ftllens wrote:
Honestly, the only way to compare lens abilities to express 3d pop (I also think this is a term that should disappear due to its horrible lack of precision) is to take photos in a flat (or identical) lighting situation in a no depth composition at the same f stop with the same camera body using the same raw processor with no post processing.

Then take those images with exif removed and presented side by side. Not to say there aren't lenses that exhibit this effect straight out of camera, but there are too many variables that can increase that effect
...Show more →

A handful of years back, there was a thread on FM Alt that was a blind comparison of Zeiss and equivalent Canon (I think) lenses. It wasn't worded as "spot the 3D pop," but the cumulative results of the guesses were pretty well conclusive. That thread was probably already referenced/linked in this thread.

May 01, 2019 at 10:30 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.17 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
WhyFi wrote:
ftllens wroteHonestly, the only way to compare lens abilities to express 3d pop (I also think this is a term that should disappear due to its horrible lack of precision) is to take photos in a flat (or identical) lighting situation in a no depth composition at the same f stop with the same camera body using the same raw processor with no post processing.

Then take those images with exif removed and presented side by side. Not to say there aren't lenses that exhibit this effect straight out of camera, but there are too many variables that can increase that effect especially in post.

As I understand it, absolute sharpness and lens design and construction affect micro contrast (midtone detail), bokeh structure, aberration resistance, flare and ghosts resistance in backlit high contrast areas, color gradation, and color fidelity across surfaces.

The computational side along with the sensor itself can magnify the dimensional effect and in post with things like selective sharpening and color contrast even more so.

But if we're talking really strong "3D" you cannot beat high end cinema anamorphic lenses. On the photographic side I would say APO glass under 100mm present images closest to reality and therefore a stronger associative dimensional image.
A handful of years back, there was a thread on FM Alt that was a blind comparison of Zeiss and equivalent Canon (I think) lenses. It wasn't worded as "spot the 3D pop," but the cumulative results of the guesses were pretty well conclusive. That thread was probably already referenced/linked in this thread.



What was the general conclusion?

May 01, 2019 at 10:34 AM
WhyFi
Offline
Details
p.17 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
DaveFP wrote:
What was the general conclusion?


Ha. Sorry about that. The Zeiss were very easily distinguished by the forum members.

May 01, 2019 at 10:37 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.17 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
WhyFi wrote:
DaveFP wroteWhat was the general conclusion?
Ha. Sorry about that. The Zeiss were very easily distinguished by the forum members.



Thanks; not surprised.

May 01, 2019 at 10:48 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.17 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
WhyFi wrote:
DaveFP wroteWhat was the general conclusion?
Ha. Sorry about that. The Zeiss were very easily distinguished by the forum members.



the there was also a control group of sorts with the same survey given to a canon forum on a different site, if i recall correctly they also preferred zeiss.
May 01, 2019 at 10:59 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.17 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
WhyFi wrote:
sebboh wrotemy own wandering of the internet has revealed that many people (even many camera gear freaks) have no association of the zeiss name with 3Dness. arguments about the nature of 3D rendering abound in places with no mention of zeiss. i've seen canon fanboys wax eloquent about the magical 3D properties of L glass, i've seen leica newbies talk excitedly about the magical 3D properties of leica glass, and i've even seen olympus nuts argue that olympus sprinkles some magic digital powder on sensors in their high end camera that makes them produce greater 3D than those same sensors produce in olympus's cheaper cameras.

if what you say is actually true (i don't read camera gear sites as often as i used to) it would be a major marketing coup for zeiss, and maybe they should send some of the older forum members here a little kickback for their service.

also, i've always thought zeiss marketing was kinda terrible, but perhaps i'm not their market.
I don't recall ever seeing discussion like that w/r/t L glass, despite spending a lot of time on POTN several years ago, which was very much Canon-centric at the time. I mean, many of those folks had nothing but high praise for L-series lenses, often insinuating that anything less was a waste of time and anything costing more [read: Zeiss] a silly waste of money... but never a discussion on the illusion of depth.

Actually, what lead me to the FM Alt forum in the first place was a dismissive exchange on POTN. I remarked on the depth of someone's
...Show more →

i never spent any time on POTN, but i'm not surprised. every forum develops it's own weird idiosyncrasies.

May 01, 2019 at 11:07 AM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.17 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
DaveFP wroteI would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.
why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:
http://live.staticflickr.com/3856/14611957123_3b0ecaf40b_h.jpg




this image again?..... don't make me buy another lens again.

May 01, 2019 at 11:30 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

sebboh
Offline
Details
p.17 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
bushwacker wrote:
sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteI would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.
why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:
http://live.staticflickr.com/3856/14611957123_3b0ecaf40b_h.jpg
this image again?..... don't make me buy another lens again.



don't worry the lens has terrible field curvature unless you use a pcx or kolari conversion. it is super cheap these days though...

May 01, 2019 at 11:43 AM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.17 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Was that the 28 or 21? 21 still seems to be holding a decent price, 28 less so.

sebboh wrote:
bushwacker wrote
sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteI would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.
why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:
http://live.staticflickr.com/3856/14611957123_3b0ecaf40b_h.jpg
this image again?..... don't make me buy another lens again.
don't worry the lens has terrible field curvature unless you use a pcx or kolari conversion. it is super cheap these days though...



May 01, 2019 at 12:07 PM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.17 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Out of curiosity, if one were to test similar lenses on a consistent scene to evaluate the merits or their POP... what kind of scene would be best? A still life? A street scene? A landscape?
May 01, 2019 at 12:09 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.17 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Was that the 28 or 21? 21 still seems to be holding a decent price, 28 less so.

sebboh wrote
bushwacker wrote
sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteI would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.
why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:
http://live.staticflickr.com/3856/14611957123_3b0ecaf40b_h.jpg
this image again?..... don't make me buy another lens again.
don't worry the lens has terrible field curvature unless you use a pcx or kolari conversion. it is super cheap these days though...


it's the 28, there are a lot more g28s in circulation.
May 01, 2019 at 12:29 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.17 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Out of curiosity, if one were to test similar lenses on a consistent scene to evaluate the merits or their POP... what kind of scene would be best? A still life? A street scene? A landscape?


depends on whether you want to make it hard or easy to perceive 3D?

most important think to make it worthwhile is consistent light across all shots. so indoors at night, here in the pacific northwest in winter, or midday sun with no clouds.
May 01, 2019 at 12:32 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.17 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
DaveFP wroteI would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.
why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:
http://live.staticflickr.com/3856/14611957123_3b0ecaf40b_h.jpg



Great image. Has a surreal quality to it.

Lots of pop there; what lens?
May 01, 2019 at 12:36 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.17 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
DaveFP wrote:
sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteI would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.
why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:
http://live.staticflickr.com/3856/14611957123_3b0ecaf40b_h.jpg
Great image. Has a surreal quality to it.

Lots of pop there; what lens?


see above.
May 01, 2019 at 12:51 PM
jeffersoncasey
Offline
Details
p.17 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
A factor worth mentioning is that not everyone is using good quality display to view the pictures. On my retina MBP the dimensionality difference is more readily apparent, particularly the color gradation. On my mobile phone, not so, with few exceptions that the image quality even shine through lesser quality display.
May 01, 2019 at 01:30 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.17 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Out of curiosity, if one were to test similar lenses on a consistent scene to evaluate the merits or their POP... what kind of scene would be best? A still life? A street scene? A landscape?


If you are into Zeiss lenses and don't care anything else...

Get yourself a Zeiss 2/35 ZE/ZF2 lens either classic or in milvus form... used or brand new whatever you like.. Yeah believe the hype!

Bokeh is little bit nervous but not distracting for my taste, actually I like to have a little just to give some funkiness not even sure funkiness is the right word.., it's like this - a woman with smooth skin, slightly red toned hair... few small sized freckles but noticeable thought not distracting.

If you want all smooth bokeh go with Zeiss 1.4/35

Look for Luka or Luca he got nice 2/35 captures or Helena i think... just browse some of their posts.

May 01, 2019 at 01:34 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.17 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18,


Zeiss 2/35 ZE Classic


May 01, 2019 at 01:35 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister