15 years and 164 pages and I'm still not seeing much 'pop' anywhere. 😂
Granted, I don't really have any to share, either. Partly because I don't know what of my old work I can legally share and I never put particularly personal photos on public sites, so that only leaves me with random snapshots and test images, which are no fun for anyone. But even so... I have loved a lot of 'old' lenses and a lot of modern ones, zooms, primes, all different systems, different film/sensor sizes, made in all different countries, ones with lots of rare elements and fancy coatings and lenses with none, and I still couldn't really pick any out as having any inherent 'pop' to them.
To me, 'pop' seems to mostly occur when whatever has been photographed actually has a lot of physical depth to it, with multiple 'layers' of focus. Like, something near the lens totally blurred out, a subject 15' away that is totally in-focus front-to-back, and then nothing else for a few hundred feet, blurry but not as much as the foreground. Three different layers, three different degrees of focus. Simply a couple of inches of focus on a subject near the lens and a big aperture to blur the background doesn't pop, to me. Neither does a landscape image that's completely consistent corner-to-corner.
It's like asking people to suggest a piano which will make you write catchier songs. You've got to find or create the pop; a lens doesn't just make it happen.
ruthenium wrote:
Presently, the influencers seem to strongly promote some new lenses from Chinese companies.
That's got nothing to do with how those lenses function, though. It's just the same thing as when Sony first started the Alpha line and were sending out free cameras to pretty much anyone with 5-figure follower counts so it seemed like all of Instagram was using Sony when really they were still using their phones; 'influencers' are inherently incentivised to promote whatever they're sent, because it's the only way they can get products in advance. If they're not getting early freebies then they'd have to wait for general sale and buy products themselves, their upfront costs would increase and they'd be slower to publish than everyone else, so their hits and revenue would go down. Essentially, if an influencer annoys a manufacturer, their 'career' is over; nobody can afford to not have access. Chinese factories are very happy to send a bunch of free lenses out when it guarantees they're going to get a wave of overwhelmingly-positive 'reviews' online one hour before pre-orders open.
There are also a lot of reviewers who sell on what they get sent, so they literally profit directly from hyping it up. A pal of mine bought a lens on ebay which he found out from the return address was from a certain popular Youtuber (I guess I shouldn't name him, but you'll all have heard of him), selling it just a couple of weeks after a very positive review...
And then of course are all the ones who get a kickback through their affiliate links to pre-order pages.
The reality of today's Youtube and Instagram-led marketing and 'reviewing' is that you basically can't trust anything published earlier than a week or so after a product has actually been on shop shelves.