fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.164 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
OregonSun wroteSome '50s pop
Telisar C 35mm f/3.5

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55594763662_a6cc8583af_o.jpg
Good idea! The outfit, however, looks more like it’s from the 21st century. 😇

If we’re going to do it, let’s do it right!
Here’s a bit of 50s-style pop, captured around 1962 by my father using an Altissa Altix camera.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55632859490_589cd6200b_b.jpg20261104_195944 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr
It does "pop" - in the bottom left corner! 🙂


That’s how it was back then. A young family and very little money. You’d simply borrow a misaligned camera from the photography club at your VEB, one where you had to guess the distance, and yet, you’d end up with such fantastic shots.😎
Today, people are constantly buying and selling high-end gear worth thousands of dollars, obsessively testing for corner sharpness, chromatic aberration, bokeh, and heaven knows what else, only to wind up taking the exact same photos that you feel like you’ve already seen a million times over on Instagram. 😄
Nov 04, 2026 at 02:02 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.164 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
The blue wave
A7V + Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N





SONY ILCE-7M5
1/250s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100










Nov 04, 2026 at 06:58 PM
zeitlos
Offline
Details
p.164 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nov 04, 2026 at 10:49 PM
pressedbunny
Offline
Details
p.164 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
15 years and 164 pages and I'm still not seeing much 'pop' anywhere. 😂
Granted, I don't really have any to share, either. Partly because I don't know what of my old work I can legally share and I never put particularly personal photos on public sites, so that only leaves me with random snapshots and test images, which are no fun for anyone. But even so... I have loved a lot of 'old' lenses and a lot of modern ones, zooms, primes, all different systems, different film/sensor sizes, made in all different countries, ones with lots of rare elements and fancy coatings and lenses with none, and I still couldn't really pick any out as having any inherent 'pop' to them.

To me, 'pop' seems to mostly occur when whatever has been photographed actually has a lot of physical depth to it, with multiple 'layers' of focus. Like, something near the lens totally blurred out, a subject 15' away that is totally in-focus front-to-back, and then nothing else for a few hundred feet, blurry but not as much as the foreground. Three different layers, three different degrees of focus. Simply a couple of inches of focus on a subject near the lens and a big aperture to blur the background doesn't pop, to me. Neither does a landscape image that's completely consistent corner-to-corner.

It's like asking people to suggest a piano which will make you write catchier songs. You've got to find or create the pop; a lens doesn't just make it happen.

ruthenium wrote:
Presently, the influencers seem to strongly promote some new lenses from Chinese companies.
That's got nothing to do with how those lenses function, though. It's just the same thing as when Sony first started the Alpha line and were sending out free cameras to pretty much anyone with 5-figure follower counts so it seemed like all of Instagram was using Sony when really they were still using their phones; 'influencers' are inherently incentivised to promote whatever they're sent, because it's the only way they can get products in advance. If they're not getting early freebies then they'd have to wait for general sale and buy products themselves, their upfront costs would increase and they'd be slower to publish than everyone else, so their hits and revenue would go down. Essentially, if an influencer annoys a manufacturer, their 'career' is over; nobody can afford to not have access. Chinese factories are very happy to send a bunch of free lenses out when it guarantees they're going to get a wave of overwhelmingly-positive 'reviews' online one hour before pre-orders open.
There are also a lot of reviewers who sell on what they get sent, so they literally profit directly from hyping it up. A pal of mine bought a lens on ebay which he found out from the return address was from a certain popular Youtuber (I guess I shouldn't name him, but you'll all have heard of him), selling it just a couple of weeks after a very positive review...
And then of course are all the ones who get a kickback through their affiliate links to pre-order pages.

The reality of today's Youtube and Instagram-led marketing and 'reviewing' is that you basically can't trust anything published earlier than a week or so after a product has actually been on shop shelves.
Nov 05, 2026 at 05:38 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.164 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
Thanks for the tips!!! @JonasB and Makten@

How 'Swede' it is :-)
I turned off EFCS and turned on Anti-Flicker.






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/250s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso320
Nov 05, 2026 at 09:15 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.164 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
pressedbunny wrote:
…It's like asking people to suggest a piano which will make you write catchier songs. You've got to find or create the pop; a lens doesn't just make it happen.


True. I’m likely to quote that one, as it is so apt.

(My main background is actually in the music field, and we have the same issue — people imagining that getting the perfect instrument will make their music, uh, “pop.”

At some level, it is true that using good equipment (in photography or music) that is designed well for what you are doing is important. But it rarely makes any difference until you are pretty advanced — beginning pianists do not benefit from Steinways, a decent amateur violinist using a Stradivarius will still sound like a decent amateur violinist.

And beyond that, there is little ultimate agreement among musicians about which thing is actually the very best one… and it changes over time. If you know professional symphony musicians (I do) you’ll note that over years and decades the thing that was once regarded as the best option often fades away and some other version comes to the fore.You’ll also find that not everyone accepts that instrument A is actually the very best, and others will use instrument B or C instead.

In the end, what actually matters isn’t the instrument they own but what they do with it.
Nov 05, 2026 at 10:17 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.164 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
This is an interesting but imperfect analogy. A musical instrument directly produces the product - the sound of music.
A lens doesn't produce an image - it only projects light (a scene) onto a sensor, and the product image is created behind the lens (including post-processing). Projecting light through glass adds aberrations to images and some photographers like this added effect.

The nearest analogy for lenses in music is the venue where the music is played. The sound projected toward an audience is naturally affected by the acoustics of the room or hall where musical instruments are played. This is akin to light being affected by the glass in a lens.

The question that a musician can answer is whether an ideal music hall is one where the sound of an instrument can reach the audience unperturbed, or whether certain aberrations (e g., due to reflections from the walls) can positively add to the experience of the audience.
Nov 05, 2026 at 01:09 PM
OregonSun
Offline
Details
p.164 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
This is an interesting but imperfect analogy. A musical instrument directly produces the product - the sound of music.
A lens doesn't produce an image - it only projects light (a scene) onto a sensor, and the product image is created behind the lens (including post-processing). Projecting light through glass adds aberrations to images and some photographers like this added effect.

The nearest analogy for lenses in music is the venue where the music is played. The sound projected toward an audience is naturally affected by the acoustics of the room or hall where musical instruments are played. This is akin to
...Show more →

Or you could just ask the audience
Nov 05, 2026 at 01:24 PM
simplejoy
Offline
Details
p.164 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
I'm still kinda torn on the whole 3D pop topic... but I do see an image from time to time, where I would say the description applies. In most of my own shots, which have good feeling of plasticity of objects or separation it mostly comes down to the amount of blur in the background, particular objects which help with their own three-dimensional shapes or color contrast. So I don't think I have taken many shots which I'd categorize as 3D pop.

One general question though:
Do you think real 3D pop should work without colors, in B&W?

Because I think a lot of shots people tend to classify as 3D pop (including a good number which I've seen in this thread) mainly work because of color(-contrast) and I'm not sure that can be attributed to a specific lens to such an extend that it becomes meaningful. I'd be curious to hear your opinion on that.
Nov 05, 2026 at 03:44 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.164 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
OregonSun wrote:
ruthenium wroteThis is an interesting but imperfect analogy. A musical instrument directly produces the product - the sound of music.
A lens doesn't produce an image - it only projects light (a scene) onto a sensor, and the product image is created behind the lens (including post-processing). Projecting light through glass adds aberrations to images and some photographers like this added effect.

The nearest analogy for lenses in music is the venue where the music is played. The sound projected toward an audience is naturally affected by the acoustics of the room or hall where musical instruments are played. This is akin to light being affected by the glass in a lens.

The question that a musician can answer is whether an ideal music hall is one where the sound of an instrument can reach the audience unperturbed, or whether certain aberrations (e g., due to reflections from the walls) can positively add to the experience of the audience.
Or you could just ask the audience


The thought that you might be suggesting that we should care about the opinions of others who view our photos - it makes me shudder! 😱
Nov 05, 2026 at 03:56 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

rodenmg
Offline
Details
p.164 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
simplejoy wrote:
I'm still kinda torn on the whole 3D pop topic... but I do see an image from time to time, where I would say the description applies. In most of my own shots, which have good feeling of plasticity of objects or separation it mostly comes down to the amount of blur in the background, particular objects which help with their own three-dimensional shapes or color contrast. So I don't think I have taken many shots which I'd categorize as 3D pop.

One general question though:
Do you think real 3D pop should work without colors, in B&W?

Because I think a lot
...Show more →

Yes? No? Maybe?






Nov 05, 2026 at 03:59 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.164 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
simplejoy wrote:
I'm still kinda torn on the whole 3D pop topic... but I do see an image from time to time, where I would say the description applies. In most of my own shots, which have good feeling of plasticity of objects or separation it mostly comes down to the amount of blur in the background, particular objects which help with their own three-dimensional shapes or color contrast. So I don't think I have taken many shots which I'd categorize as 3D pop.

One general question though:
Do you think real 3D pop should work without colors, in B&W?

Because I think a lot
...Show more →

Absolutely - color makes things stand out.
I don't claim that my example below exhibits "pop," yet it may work as an illustration.




  GFX100S II    GF20-35mmF4 R WR lens    35mm    f/8.0    1/150s    160 ISO    0.0 EV  

Nov 05, 2026 at 04:01 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.164 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
This is an interesting but imperfect analogy. A musical instrument directly produces the product - the sound of music.
A lens doesn't produce an image - it only projects light (a scene) onto a sensor, and the product image is created behind the lens (including post-processing). Projecting light through glass adds aberrations to images and some photographers like this added effect.

The nearest analogy for lenses in music is the venue where the music is played. The sound projected toward an audience is naturally affected by the acoustics of the room or hall where musical instruments are played. This is akin to
...Show more →

I could answer it, as a person whose lifelong career and academic training has been in music…

… but I have other things on my mind.

BT W, no analogy that I am aware of requires a perfect parallel, which is why we are likely to say that “A is like B” rather than that “A is identical to B.”

Nov 05, 2026 at 04:16 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.164 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
The nearest analogy for lenses in music is the venue where the music is played.


I'd offer that the choice of materials used induces a different resonance ... a mahogany top vs. a spruce top guitar render the same notes differently. For some folks, they find the difference of little matter, while others find a mahogany vs. sapele vs. maple vs. spruce (etc.) of great significance.

The choices in lens design for not only size and shape and number of elements, coatings, etc, but also materials used will induce a variance. If there were no differences in the lens designs, then Fred's excellent reviews would all be of little merit. Rather, Fred's and a cadre of others who differentiate rendering of lens reviews in great depth exist ... for a reason.

Nov 05, 2026 at 06:57 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.164 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
Absolutely - color makes things stand out.


Rate of change ... more rapid rate of change = more "pop".

Point being, if the HUE of colors induce a rapid change from one hue to another ... more pop.
If the SATURATION of colors induce a rapid change from saturation levels ... more pop.
If TONAL values induce a rapid change ... more pop.
If FOCAL plane induces a rapid change ... more pop.
If CONTRAST induces a rapid change ... more pop.
If MICROCRAST or FIELD CURVATURE induce rapid change ... more pop.
If ABERRATIONS induce a rapid change ... more pop.
If SCALE induces a rapid change ... more pop.

If XYZ ... rapid change ... more pop.

To the degree that subject, light, lens induce rapid changes ... the human physiological response to rapid change is the perception of "pop". The attribute(s) and the source of the attribute(s) work in combination(s), whether that be driven by a single dominant attribute, or the combinations of nuance attributes.

Wherein "pop" is generally defined as a rapid rate of change. "Pop" gun, "Pop" goes the weasel. A balloon "pops". Bubble gum "pops".

The inherent use of the term "pop" is an attribute of rate of change, associated with human physiological response to a given attribute.

So, yes ... absolutely monochrome can "pop", as well so can color.

Pop, however ... not to be confused with modeling or dimensionality, per se. That is a different aspect (i.e. the 3D-ishness perception can be slower or faster in transition, and still have good dimensionality / modeling, without having a lot of "pop"). Conversely, something can have a lot of "pop" and not have good modeling / dimensionality. The OP thread put them in combination, while they are two independent aspects ... that can co-exist in tandem, or individually alone.

Nov 05, 2026 at 07:17 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.164 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
ruthenium wroteAbsolutely - color makes things stand out.
Rate of change ... more rapid rate of change = more "pop".

Point being, if the HUE of colors induce a rapid change from one hue to another ... more pop.
If the SATURATION of colors induce a rapid change from saturation levels ... more pop.
If TONAL values induce a rapid change ... more pop.
If FOCAL plane induces a rapid change ... more pop.
If CONTRAST induces a rapid change ... more pop.
If MICROCRAST or FIELD CURVATURE induce rapid change ... more pop.
If ABERRATIONS induce a rapid change ... more pop.
If SCALE induces a rapid change ... more pop.

If XYZ ... rapid change
...Show more →

I agree with "pop ... not to be confused with modelling or dimensionality".
This is why in my example posted above I added "I don't claim that my example below exhibits "pop."
In fact, seeing the "pop" is relatively uncommon in this thread.
Nov 05, 2026 at 08:03 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.164 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N + Sony A7V






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/640s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100
Nov 05, 2026 at 08:04 PM
simplejoy
Offline
Details
p.164 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
rodenmg wrote:
Yes? No? Maybe?



Yeah, I think this is a good example. It's perhaps not quite as obvious as some of the color-aided ones, but I think some aspects which add to the phenomenon of the subject standing out in a 3D way are better visible in B&W. Thanks for the image!

Nov 06, 2026 at 01:06 AM
simplejoy
Offline
Details
p.164 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
Rate of change ... more rapid rate of change = more "pop".

Point being, if the HUE of colors induce a rapid change from one hue to another ... more pop.
If the SATURATION of colors induce a rapid change from saturation levels ... more pop.
If TONAL values induce a rapid change ... more pop.
If FOCAL plane induces a rapid change ... more pop.
If CONTRAST induces a rapid change ... more pop.
If MICROCRAST or FIELD CURVATURE induce rapid change ... more pop.
If ABERRATIONS induce a rapid change ... more pop.
If SCALE induces a rapid change ... more pop.


If XYZ ... rapid change
...Show more →

Thanks a lot for that definition! I think that's very helpful in understanding why the phenomenon is hard to describe or classify, since it's influenced by a number of aspects.

RustyBug wrote:
So, yes ... absolutely monochrome can "pop", as well so can color.


Indeed. I found that true for my perception as well. However it's very rare that I feel strong pop with B&W images, unless we're talking about large format, where I regularly see it (camera movements might add a lot to that as well).

From what I'm seeing probably a vast number of shots given as examples are based on the color aspect and almost completely lose their pop without it.

RustyBug wrote:
Pop, however ... not to be confused with modeling or dimensionality, per se. That is a different aspect (i.e. the 3D-ishness perception can be slower or faster in transition, and still have good dimensionality / modeling, without having a lot of "pop"). Conversely, something can have a lot of "pop" and not have good modeling / dimensionality. The OP thread put them in combination, while they are two independent aspects ... that can co-exist in tandem, or individually alone.



That's interesting... do you perhaps have an example of "good dimensionality without a lot of pop"?

Nov 06, 2026 at 01:21 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.164 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
simplejoy wrote:
That's interesting... do you perhaps have an example of "good dimensionality without a lot of pop"?



Look through some of the early stuff in this thread ... pages 8-10 have a few that offer a difference in the amount of "pop" they present, wherein some have spatial depth, but not a lot of "pop", and others have significantly more pop. With over 100 pages to consider, there's plenty to look at in this contextual difference, for your own assessment.

Eye of the beholder kind of stuff ... and a plethora of images in this thread that you could put as different in that regard. Personally, some of PJ's image offerings from Thypoch strike me as affording a slower spatial depth transition, without a lot of pop. This in contrast to some of the more rapid Voigtlander / Zeiss, etc. offerings. Imo, Leica often sits in the middle ground between those two. S(Z)ony tends to lean a bit Zeissy, at times, too.

Scroll down to post #10 in this link below. Two different lenses (trivial diff in FL at 45 vs. 50, since significant FL / DOF is not part of the scene), noting the saturation, acutance, micro-contrast and aberration difference(s) ... your call if their physiological response for "pop" is the same, or different based on different optics being used (sans spatial depth oof cues).

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1608234/48/


Nov 06, 2026 at 09:23 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister