Ripolini wrote:
I respectfully disagree. DoF has nothing to do with dimensionality.
If this assumption were correct, all macro pictures would transmit a sense of depth and/or 3D.
Consequently, this thread would be flooded with close-ups and macro images (with no focus stacking).
Haha, and that's exactly where I think I caught you.... You're right.
If shallow depth of field and ever-increasing sensor resolution were the main ingredients of dimensionality, then this thread should be filled almost entirely with macro photographs and images from the highest-pixel-count cameras on the market.
I think the biggest source of confusion is that we've introduced a new term to describe something that was never clearly defined in the first place: "pop." Nowadays, we constantly hear that an image has more pop, or that a particular lens has more pop. It's become a fashionable expression, but different photographers often mean completely different things by it.
In my opinion, that's where most of the misunderstanding comes from. Some people use "pop" to describe subject separation, others micro-contrast, others smooth tonal transitions, and some simply mean shallow depth of field. Everyone uses the same word while talking about different visual characteristics.
I still remember seeing the term used extensively on DPReview around the time the first Leica APO samples were published. Back then, people often described certain lenses as having more "pop" because the image seemed to have a stronger sense of depth or presence, even if they couldn't fully explain why.
As I've said before, the idea itself goes back to the old Zeiss discussions about images appearing to "jump off the screen." Whether that impression comes from lighting, perspective, tonal transitions, subject separation, micro-contrast, stereopsis, or depth of field is still open to interpretation. Personally, I don't think shallow depth of field is either necessary or sufficient on its own to create the effect, but it can certainly contribute to it.
But 3D Pop is almost the next level of photography folklore. It is not a specific optical property, but rather a perceived sense of depth and presence that may result from a combination of lighting, perspective, subject separation, micro-contrast, tonal transitions, lens rendering, and sometimes depth of field. That's probably why discussions about it never seem to reach a final conclusion. 😄