RustyBug wrote:
[The point of the sharing it ... bearing in mind it wasn't Fred's mission to produce some kind of exceptional 3D shot when he shot those ... the point of me referencing them was to present that it is about as good an A:B comp with the primary diff being the lenses. And, as such ... the amount of diff (none of them super-monster 3D-ish, pop) is a factor of the lens variance used ... inducing the diff as it is presented.
Well, on an abstract level, sure. What I'm seeing in this example though is merely that if a lens performs so bad in a scene, that I would consider it unusable (at least with the given settings), it can also destroy a 3D effect otherwise present in the scene. This is not a comparison with a decent modern lens. If we exclude the first, than there is still some difference in 3D, but this still seems to correspond merely to two of them being soft (by modern standards). I have no doubt that some old school piece of window glass may not show what decent lenses can.
Bear in mind that such a difference can be "amplified" or "reduced" by soft vs. contrasty lighting. If these were taken in different lighting, the variance might be even greater ... so, you kinda need to use your noodle a bit when understanding the point of the diff's being a byproduct of the different optic. The point is that the difference IS visible, not that the AMOUNT is tremendous, as the "best" example.
Show a better comparison then. One where all lenses involved manage to be reasonably sharp on the subject. You think this too big of an ask?
I also linked a previous 50mm (iiirc) shootout (quite some time ago) that one could see some diff's too, but I thought Fred's were "easier" to see how a different lens can contribute to a different amount being realized (under same conditions).
For other lens criteria folks come up with some type of comparison that will highlight the difference. Works for reflections, LACA, LOCA, sharpness, Bokeh, etc. Not for 3D pop. Does that not make you pause?
PS: no idea why you think my "noodle" needs mentioning here.