fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.15 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/983034/7#14837250

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/int/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html

Fred's link is the US version, p.8 #10 was the post where I had posted the international version.


DaveFP wrote:
tsdevine wroteEarlier in the thread had posted the international version of the link you posted. I definitely think that Zeiss has a "look" in most lenses...and it's a good one. This detour started when someone suggested we shouldn't use the term "pop" and I posted that Batis link to show that even Zeiss is using that terminology.

But any page like this is a marketing page, doesn't mean it isn't true..... Just that you have to take it with at least the knowledge that it is marketing.

And I very much like Zeiss lenses, and agree with much of what they tout as Zeiss advantages.

-Tim

Fred Miranda wrote
tsdevine wroteDon't take my comment the wrong way, if you look at my Batis 40 posts in this thread, I do believe in Zeiss having some of the best 3D pop producing lenses. (I also have quite a few Zeiss lenses....ZE 15, ZE 21, Loxia 21, Loxia 25, Batis 25, Batis 40...even some older C/Y Zeiss.)

But even in their marketing, they mention smooth bokeh and the transitions from focus to out of focus. I see some 3D pop even in my stopped down shooting with the Batis 40. Given the discussion over what exactly produces "3D pop" it's hard to ignore that there is some marketing occurring here. Doesn't mean it isn't grounded in some truth.

-Tim

DaveFP wrote
tsdevine wroteI did say Zeiss's marketing...

-Tim
It is certainly Zeiss marketing but if you review this thread, or any other similar thread on the net, you will see Zeiss come up over and over and over again.

I might sound like a fanboy (and perhaps I am) but I would have to say that none of my lenses from the majors (including Canon, Sony, Nikon) have quite the colors, pop, and punch that Zeiss does.

It's not the only "look" and it may not be one's favorite "look" but if it appeals to you you'd be hard pressed to name a company that does it better.
They like to brag about the "Zeiss Look" and their marketing says it's a combination of "True colors", "Sharpness" and "3D Pop":
https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html
Tim - could you repost the link - can't seem to find it.



Apr 30, 2019 at 10:34 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.15 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
tsdevine wrote:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/983034/7#14837250

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/int/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html

Fred's link is the US version, p.8 #10 was the post where I had posted the international version.

DaveFP wrote
tsdevine wroteEarlier in the thread had posted the international version of the link you posted. I definitely think that Zeiss has a "look" in most lenses...and it's a good one. This detour started when someone suggested we shouldn't use the term "pop" and I posted that Batis link to show that even Zeiss is using that terminology.

But any page like this is a marketing page, doesn't mean it isn't true..... Just that you have to take it with at least the knowledge that it is marketing.

And I very much like Zeiss lenses, and agree with much of what they tout as Zeiss advantages.

-Tim

Fred Miranda wrote
tsdevine wroteDon't take my comment the wrong way, if you look at my Batis 40 posts in this thread, I do believe in Zeiss having some of the best 3D pop producing lenses. (I also have quite a few Zeiss lenses....ZE 15, ZE 21, Loxia 21, Loxia 25, Batis 25, Batis 40...even some older C/Y Zeiss.)

But even in their marketing, they mention smooth bokeh and the transitions from focus to out of focus. I see some 3D pop even in my stopped down shooting with the Batis 40. Given the discussion over what exactly produces "3D pop" it's hard to ignore that there is some marketing occurring here. Doesn't mean it isn't grounded in some truth.

-Tim

DaveFP wroteIt is certainly Zeiss marketing but if you review this thread, or any other similar thread on the net, you will see Zeiss come up over and over and over again.

I might sound like a fanboy (and perhaps I am) but I would have to say that none of my lenses from the majors (including Canon, Sony, Nikon) have quite the colors, pop, and punch that Zeiss does.

It's not the only "look" and it may not be one's favorite "look" but if it appeals to you you'd be hard pressed to name a company that does it better.
They like to brag about the "Zeiss Look" and their marketing says it's a combination of "True colors", "Sharpness" and "3D Pop":
https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html
Tim - could you repost the link - can't seem to find it.


Thanks !

Apr 30, 2019 at 10:54 AM
SeanHew
Offline
Details
p.15 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
I may be in the minority but I think a lot of the 3dness can be recreated in post pretty easily. As long as you have a sharp lens that provides at least a touch of subject separation you can get the 3d look by over sharpening an image (100+ in LR) but masking it so it is just on the outer edges of your subject (70-85 masking in LR)...a bit of contrast and clarity doesn't hurt either.
Apr 30, 2019 at 11:04 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.15 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
this is "3D POP":



Light is important, of course, but the way you draw isn't negligible
Apr 30, 2019 at 11:09 AM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.15 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
tsdevine wrote:
This detour started when someone suggested we shouldn't use the term "pop" and I posted that Batis link to show that even Zeiss is using that terminology.


Yeah that was me. My complaint is that the term is rather meaningless without a definition, and thus it will produce endless, fruitless debates like the current one.

As for Zeiss, see my opinion earlier in this thread:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/983034/3#14834161

Apr 30, 2019 at 11:12 AM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.15 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ripolini wrote:
this is "3D POP":

https://lepassepartout2.files.wordpress.com/2016/03/caravaggio_-_martirio_di_san_pietro.jpg

Light is important, of course, but the way you draw isn't negligible


How about this:



It's actually called "trompe l'oeil" not "pop" lol.

Apr 30, 2019 at 11:17 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.15 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?


do you know Andrea Pozzo's painted ceiling with trompe l'œil architecture (inside the Church of St. Ignatius of Loyola)?

(link)



picture taken with Zeiss lens


Edited on Apr 30, 2019 at 12:12 PM · View previous versions
Apr 30, 2019 at 12:06 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.15 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
vdo1 wrote:
tsdevine wroteThis detour started when someone suggested we shouldn't use the term "pop" and I posted that Batis link to show that even Zeiss is using that terminology.
Yeah that was me. My complaint is that the term is rather meaningless without a definition, and thus it will produce endless, fruitless debates like the current one.

As for Zeiss, see my opinion earlier in this thread:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/983034/3#14834161



I would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.

The reason that the conversation is endless is that it has proven fruitless and the reason that it has been fruitless is that no one contributing has been able to pull it all together in a coherent way.

But -just because something is not well understood doesn't make it refractory to understanding.

The original question "Which lens has the most 3D?" is based on the premise that optics contribute and that some have the potential to contribute more than others.

My "a posteriori" experience leads me to believe that they do indeed play a role; some more than others.

Other photographers have not had the same results but that does not negate my experience nor those of others that have made similar observations.

As I stated earlier only one in ten thousand people can confirm the existence of absolute pitch so attempting to achieve knowledge through popular opinion can lead us to ignorance.

In any case this would make a great round-table conversation.

We just need to gather the physiologists, physicists, and optical engineers to help us make sense of it all.

I am sure there is someone at Zeiss (among others) that could bring this conversation to a whole new plane.







Edited on Apr 30, 2019 at 12:34 PM · View previous versions
Apr 30, 2019 at 12:12 PM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.15 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Serious mode ON

DaveFP wrote:
The original question "Which lens has the most 3D?" is based on the premise that optics contribute and that some have the potential to contribute more than others.
My "a posteriori" experience leads me to believe that they do indeed play a role; some more than others.


It's my experience too.
I have three Zeiss ZF.2 "Classic" lenses (21, 35/2, 100/2).
Their "3D POP" doesn't come from what Zeiss marketing claims though.
Here Zeiss states:"brilliant optical design and a sharp transition out of the focused areas create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment."
It's exactly the opposite. Sharp transition between focus plane and planes in front and behind said plane produce a "cartoon", 2D effect. What a good lens must be able to do is a smooth transition, maintaining a large microcontrast in the focus plane. This is I think what gives Zeiss lenses more 3D POP than other lenses. This effect can be visible (at least to my eyes) even when shooting at f/11 ...
Therefore, 3D POP isn't related necessarily to very large apertures.
Apr 30, 2019 at 12:22 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.15 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
DaveFP wrote:
I would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.


why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:






Apr 30, 2019 at 01:50 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.15 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
DaveFP wroteI would say that, at least in the lexicographic circles I travel in, "pop" and "punch" are understood to be synonymous with micro-contrast.
why not just ask which lenses have the most micro-contrast then?

there are obviously people here who are using 3D to mean, as zeiss says, a sharp transition out of the focused areas to create a perfect distinction between the main subject and its environment.

i think this photo has a very good 3D effect, but other people are talking about something that is not present at all in this photo:
http://live.staticflickr.com/3856/14611957123_3b0ecaf40b_h.jpg



I agree but I'm not the OP.

Apr 30, 2019 at 02:21 PM
Kalainen
Offline
Details
p.15 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Here's an article that surely belongs into this thread:

Micro Contrast and the ZEISS ‘Pop’ – by Lloyd Chambers
Apr 30, 2019 at 02:36 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.15 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Kalainen wrote:
Here's an article that surely belongs into this thread:

Micro Contrast and the ZEISS ‘Pop’ – by Lloyd Chambers


I put that up on page 3 but no one commented on it.

Apr 30, 2019 at 02:38 PM
Kalainen
Offline
Details
p.15 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
DaveFP wrote:
Kalainen wroteHere's an article that surely belongs into this thread:

Micro Contrast and the ZEISS ‘Pop’ – by Lloyd Chambers
I put that up on page 3 but no one commented on it.

Oops, sorry I missed it!

Apr 30, 2019 at 03:20 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.15 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
DaveFP wrote:
Kalainen wroteHere's an article that surely belongs into this thread:

Micro Contrast and the ZEISS ‘Pop’ – by Lloyd Chambers
I put that up on page 3 but no one commented on it.



that article seems like a classic example of missing the forest for the trees both literally and figuratively. i bet Nasse wanted to strangle him. what Lloyd is looking for is called accuracy, but increases in accuracy at > 40lp/mm often come at a cost to other types of accuracy (or size in the oti). I'd love to have heard what types of accuracy Nasse and Mandler were most willing to sacrifice.
Apr 30, 2019 at 03:32 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.15 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
DaveFP wrote
Kalainen wroteHere's an article that surely belongs into this thread:

Micro Contrast and the ZEISS ‘Pop’ – by Lloyd Chambers
I put that up on page 3 but no one commented on it.
that article seems like a classic example of missing the forest for the trees both literally and figuratively. i bet Nasse wanted to strangle him. what Lloyd is looking for is called accuracy, but increases in accuracy at > 40lp/mm often come at a cost to other types of accuracy (or size in the oti). I'd love to have heard what types of accuracy Nasse and Mandler were most willing to sacrifice.


I didn't link it as a definitive reference paper; just thought it might be interesting.

You might be right but it is odd that Zeiss would be willing to publish it if it was very far off.

In any case I prefer lenses with lovable aberrations rather than accurate lenses.

(I am a frustrated painter)

By way of example some of my favorites are the Canon 50L, Zeiss Planar 50 1.4, and Zeiss Planar 85 1.4.



Apr 30, 2019 at 03:58 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.15 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
DaveFP wrote:
You might be right but it is odd that Zeiss would be willing to publish it if it was very far off.


it does read like marketing material for zeiss, so i'm not surprised they published it. it can't be that far off since it's mostly just pointing out obvious characteristics of otus lenses and seasoning that language with “pop” or “3D rendering” or “brilliance” or “bite”.
Apr 30, 2019 at 04:25 PM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.15 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
One thing for sure, so many pictures here I don't see any 3D
Apr 30, 2019 at 04:26 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.15 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
sebboh wrote:
DaveFP wroteYou might be right but it is odd that Zeiss would be willing to publish it if it was very far off.
it does read like marketing material for zeiss, so i'm not surprised they published it. it can't be that far off since it's mostly just pointing out obvious characteristics of otus lenses and seasoning that language with “pop” or “3D rendering” or “brilliance” or “bite”.


I can't disagree but, to be fair, Zeiss is famous for designing and/or manufacturing lenses perceived to have those very qualities.

It is not as though they needed to induce mass hypnosis in order to create their reputation.

High build quality, great service, and Zeissiness is what they have on offer so no surprise that they are happy to emphasize it.

If you wander the WWW you will find that Zeiss (and these very terms) come up over and over again in every thread that touches on this topic.

Some of it is simple parroting for sure but most seems to be from the heart (eye?).



Apr 30, 2019 at 04:45 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.15 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?


DaveFP wrote:
sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteYou might be right but it is odd that Zeiss would be willing to publish it if it was very far off.
it does read like marketing material for zeiss, so i'm not surprised they published it. it can't be that far off since it's mostly just pointing out obvious characteristics of otus lenses and seasoning that language with “pop” or “3D rendering” or “brilliance” or “bite”.
I can't disagree but, to be fair, Zeiss is famous for designing and/or manufacturing lenses perceived to have those very qualities.

It is not as though they needed to induce mass hypnosis in order to create their reputation.

High build quality, great service, and Zeissiness is what they have on offer so no surprise that they are happy to emphasize it.

If you wander the WWW you will find that Zeiss (and these very terms) come up over and over again in every thread that touches on this topic.

Some of it is simple parroting for sure but most seems to be from the
...Show more →

perhaps their marketing is better than i give them credit for? i thought it was only the nerdiest corners of the photo internet. they should definitely trademark zeissiness, then we could debate that term.
Apr 30, 2019 at 05:00 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister